The Budget: a rapid response thread 1/ Sunak broke with the Tory austerian decade to extend the short term stimulus. But he's promised £68bn of fiscal austerity between 2023-26, mainly tax rises...
2/ The aim is to trap Labour into a position where it cannot promise fiscal expansion during a Labour govt, and to tee up a snap election before April 2023....
3/ Labour was right to oppose up front CT increases, and would be right to support them form 2023 onwards, for reasons of redistribution, not "balancing the books"....
4/ But Labour's strategic task - so clear from now until the election - is to make the case for a fiscal expansion: borrowing to invest, reject arbitrary debt ceilings and with clear focus on social, environmental, racial and economic justice...
5/ Likewise for the left, the task is pretty clear: to come up with concrete proposals and borrowing/investment sums to match them. Sunak said nothing on NHS, social care, social housing, radical green energy...
6/ Now the argument is no longer about strategic fiscal austerity, Labour's focus has to be on values and vision. You can't outsource that to focus groups: it's what we believe in free education, a world class health service, well funded local services and human rights...
7/ Having seen the void of values at the heart of Sunak as a politician on display today, nobody should fear going up against him if he takes over because Johnson gets bored... Rishi believes in Rishi, was today's performance highlight...
8/ And what was the point of Labour attacking each other over a Tory tax rise that never happened? Social democracy is winning an argument about investment, growth and borrowing - let's go on the front foot.
9/ By the way, the "spend now, tax later strategy" is also a time-bomb for Scottish independence. The Growth Commission report should be shredded: if Scotland wants independence it will have to experience something nationalists don't contemplate - class struggle.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Ahead of the budget, what would the left do faced with OBR's likely fiscal projections: 1/ Don't stop borrowing. Signal major strategic fiscal expansion over the next 3 years and get the BoE into line for continued support... medium.com/mosquito-ridge…
2/ Impose a windfall tax on companies whose profits grew significantly through the lockdowns. medium.com/mosquito-ridge…
3/ Signal the rise of corporation tax to 25% over four years, back-loaded, but with serious upfront measures on avoidance medium.com/mosquito-ridge…
R is for Rosa, a project in collaboration with @rosalux_global is three short documentaries about the ideas of the German revolutionary Rosa Luxemburg... in Episode 1 she dives into the 1905 revolution, ends up in jail, and writes The Mass Strike...
Episode 2 finds Luxemburg teaching in the SPD party school with a bunch of old reformists ... check out the archive shots to see how happy that made her feel... she writes a major work on economics, and then the war breaks out...
Episode 3 begins with Rosa in jail in Breslau... writing her diatribe against Lenin over democracy... she rushes to Berlin as the war ends, forms the KPD and is murdered by the Freikorps...
Sunak signals austerity lite - time for Labour to wake up and start making an argument: for borrowing, spending, growth and monetary activism... 1/ link.medium.com/UwVlHTWReeb
2/ Sunak plans to plug £43bn "hole" though freezing income tax allowances, a phased-in corporation tax rise and cutting the aid budget - plus around £20bn of cuts or further tax rises not specified. Labour's job is to *oppose it all* - because it's austerity. But...
3/ What we need now is a comprehensive alternative vision, argument and policies. The remainder of Sunak's post-Covid stimulus is piss-poor: £20bn on offshore wind? Labour pledged £88bn. We need a Biden-scale 10% of GDP stimulus - and to stop worrying about bond yields...
Thread: 1/ Labour's @JohnHealey_MP just set out a pretty comprehensive defence overview that is a) clearly anti-tory both in policy and principle b) stands a chance of reconnecting with the voters Labour needs to win...
2/ The key points were - as under Corbyn - support for NATO, for Trident renewal, multilateralism and rule of law, and UK-focused defence procurement strategy...
3/ Healey pointed out that all wings of Labour supported NATO at foundation - IIRC there were only 6 votes against it in parliament - 2x communists and 4x pro-CP ex-Labour MPs.... Bevan/Lee etc supported it and of course the Labour right designed it...
What would a left government do in next week's Budget? 1/ A massive pro-cyclical stimulus to put rocket boosters under those parts of the economy we want to recover fastest in H2 - ie start rebalancing away from low-value/low wage growth in the next phase...
2/ .... stimulus means a public spending hike, both on investment and day-to-day spend; that should be Labour's differentiator; there's no need for short-term tax rises *except* for rebalancing investment and behaviour...
3/ ... stimulus also means defect scrapping central bank independence. I don't care what you do de jury but independence is already a myth. Monetary sovereignty's gonna be a powerful tool against collapsonomics in the 2020s...
On Starmer's "reset" speech 1/ Tone better than content. He's genuinely indignant over the health inequalities Marmot points to, and with concrete language and examples - and policies - this will translate into an agenda for working class families...
2/ ... Roadmap to Yesterday a resonant phrase; inequality is economic stupidity likewise... and it was a "reset" in the sense of saying the phase of muted criticism during the pandemic is over... but...
3/ As I've said here: the case is clear for massive fiscal expansion now. Both Starmer speech and Dodds' Mais lecture frame permission for this - and he will be asked: how much is needed to build this new Britain... newstatesman.com/writers/315559