The Pension War Room™️ would like to announce another public appearance at the Standing Committee on Private Members' Public Bills. The meeting starts Monday morning at 8:00 AM, you can get the video link at this page 👇👇👇 #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
If you can't watch live a recording will be available later in the day.
@yomeeks will be doing a stakeholder presentations on Bill 208, Alberta Investment Management Corporation Amendment Act brought forward by @SPhillipsAB. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
Bill 208 brings forward several changes to the AIMCO Act that are required, if not seriously overdue. It would remove the ability of TBF to issue "directives" to AIMCO. It would require the appointment of Directors to the AIMCO Board from each of the big pension plans. #AbLeg
Directors would be appointed from LAPP, PSPP, SFPP, and, you guessed it, ATRF. This is essential because since the spring of 2019 the legal status of AIMCO and its harem of clients has changed twice. AIMCO governance needs to be updated. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
It is fundamentally illogical to have a joint pension plan and not have both of the sponsors on the AIMCO Board. BCIMC has a Board that only has a minority of members representing the government. The majority are appointed by the pension plans.#AbLeg#handsoffmypension
The Bill also requires a referendum on the stupidity of leaving CPP. And, if we choose to leave the CPP a referendum on weather we should use AIMCO as an investment manager for the assets. #fail#AbLeg#AIMCOfail
And that Board operates just fine.
BTW, results for 2020 are in. AIMCO is not releasing theirs. LAPP results are bad. I need to quote the press release to do it justice:
"For the whole of 2020, the LAPP fund generated a return of +4.53%, relative to the Plan’s policy benchmark return of +9.46%. The negative alpha of 493 basis points for the last fiscal year represents the largest drop in the fund's relative performance in the previous ten years."
And, it gets worse:
"As of December 31, 2020, the Fund posted a four-year, annualized return (net of fees) of 7.06% underperforming the policy benchmark for the same period of 7.88% by 0.82%." #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
And worse yet:
"As measured by quarter ends, AIMCo has been short of LAPP’s SIPP-specified value-added expectations for 50 consecutive quarters, or 12.5 years." #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
AIMCo has not met LAPP's expectation ever. Think about that.
If you get a chance this weekend, if your MLA is on this committee, let them know how important this Bill is. And let them know that you will be watching.
Mr. Mike Ellis is the Chair. The rest of the Committee members are on the page linked above. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️is sifting for nuggets in the giant litter box that is the provincial budget! First, we have Dr. Bob, giving us a detailed breakdown of the budget. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
As well I would remind you of the many shortcomings of the MacKinnon report. She refused to use Saskatchewan as a a comparator whose cost of government per capita is very comparable to AB. Even after her round of closing hospitals across SK. #AbLeg
Equally vexing is her inclusion of the the pre-1992 pension liability in teacher's compensation. This under-funding arose from the GOA did not make timely contributions THAT THEY WERE LEGALLY OBLIGATED TO MAKE FROM 1957 TO 1992. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
The Pension War Room brings the budget edition! A couple of observations:
First, there is less Trudeau bashing than the last fiscal update. It wasn't a good look. So good to see a slight improvement here. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
That stuff has no place in these docs. Grow up.
Second, in the "garbage in, garbage out category" we have a regurgitation of MacKinnon:
"MacKinnon found that Alberta has a lower cost of living (measured by a comparison of provincial taxes and utilities in key cities in each of the provinces) ...." #AbLeg
So MacKinnon ignored every other economist on Earth that would use a basket of goods and services to measure cost of living. (food+rent+transportation, for example) She instead said (low)taxes+(low)utilities=cost of living
This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️notes imminent legal action!
Lots of UCP MLAs are expressing concerns at the number of teachers going at them. Keep at it! Remind them that @MarkDWiseman thinks it is a bad idea to politicize pensions! #AbLeg
They all seem to be coming back with the same thing: one investment operation will cost less than two. That is wrong on several counts. Investment operations don't follow the same economics as 7-Eleven stores. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
But the real "go back to your MLA" question is why do you think you can make arbitrary decisions about money in a plan that the GOA is only a 49% partner in? Really? Joint plan since 1938 and the GOA has veto? #AbLeg What planet are you on? #uranus
This is your daily pension announcement. The Pension War Room™️ recognizes that the GOA budget is imminent. Ah... remembering MacKinnon it has been so long since so little was done. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
Remember that Travis, in his last fiscal update said something to the effect of: "AB spends a bit more than BC per capita on education, therefore education is well funded in AB". Travis loves to start a sentence with something that is true then veer off from there... #AbLeg#fail
The truth is that BC spends the least in Canada, AB the next lowest. AB would have the lowest spending if they did not generously support private schools and busing. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
The Pension War Room™️ passes on this wisdom from the current AIMCO Board Chair. It seems to me he is throwing shade on Travis and @jkenney. Read it and tell me if I am wrong..... #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
He starts by recognizing that Canadian pensions are "well managed and safe" especially when compared to the rest of the developing world.
Then the bomb:
"it is vitally important that these plans continue to operate with the independence and strong corporate governance" #ALeg
Independence? That has been established as critical to successful pension funds. I wonder what he thinks about Travis meddling in investment managers for ATRF.....
Strong governance? I wonder what advice he is giving Travis about AIMCO..
This is your daily pension announcement! Management Employees' Pension Plan (MEPP) has their 2019 Annual Report available. AIMCO earned return: 12.5% against a benchmark of 13.3%. Not good. Bonuses should never be paid for below benchmark performance. #AbLeg@premiamgmt#fail
Not a big problem for MEPP, after all, they are 120% funded. Interesting to note that AIMCO charged MEPP 80 bps in costs. ATRF last year had investment costs of 76 bps, Travis tell me again how Bill 22 is going to save money... @AbLeg#handsoffmypension
@JasonCoppingAB has not replied to my email about the errors he was making about pensions. MEPP is a good example of a single sponsor (ie not joint) plan. Travis is the sole authority for the plan and is responsible for deficiencies. It is also fairly small ~$5 billion. #AbLeg