On the [publicly accessible] International Transgender Health FB page, someone posts a video created by a female detransitioner. In it, the onetime-FTM says ...
...She never had dysphoria & wishes she had had more skillful therapy before embarking on medical transition. Sympathy & even some support for more "gatekeeping" is expressed by a few trans members
of the FB group.
But...surprise! Perhaps the most well known US gender doctor --
--Johanna Olson-Kennedy, shows up in thread, taking the opportunity to compare removal of healthy breasts or genitals to an appendectomy. (There's just a *slight* difference: Appendix-removal-regret is not a thing.) facebook.com/groups/transge…
It's one thing to scoff (as JOK has) at those who worry a person MIGHT later regret a medical transition. Here, Dr. Olson-Kennedy dismisses patients who themselves regret irreversible procedures. What on earth would cause such a flippant & callous attitude--in a doctor?
A pernicious rumor started by Jack Turban is that my daughter was "sent" to a horse farm to isolate & "deprogram" her. Nope. Chiara CHOSE her internship, an experience she found enriching. And far from being isolated, she made new friends & became an accomplished horsewoman.
Thread:
This week Pres. Biden's nominee for Asst. Health Secretary, Rachel Levine, was grilled during confirmation hearings. The MSM is unified in condemning Sen. Rand Paul, who pressed Levine (to no avail) to opine on under-18 medical transition. 1/n
It's no secret Levine is a proponent of the "affirmative" model of pediatric transition, as demonstrated in the video described in this quoted tweet. Among other things, Levine thinks teens living on the street should be prescribed cross-sex hormones. 2/n
Levine also says in the 2017 speech that under-18s can and should in some cases be allowed to undergo gender surgeries. But Levine is hardly alone in the "affirmative" clinician crowd... 3/n
What actually happened is Levine was repeatedly asked whether Levine was for or against **minors** receiving hormones and/or surgeries without parental consent. Levine refused to answer the question. Repeatedly.
Rachel Levine could become US Assistant Sec. of Health. Paul cited the #KeiraBell case, quoting Bell directly: "I made a brash decision as a teenager, as a lot of teenagers do. Trying to find competence & happiness, except now the rest of my life will be negatively affected."
While now a legal adult, the most intimate details of Jazz's life continue to be broadcast to the world & generate cash for @TLC & the Jennings family. But as Jazz ages out, now there are two more young MTF stars to feed to the prurient public, one on @netflix , the other @HBO.
Then there's Avery, the latest entrant in the trans-child media industry, starring in the HBO film "Transhood." Avery also started as a child activist, even making the cover of National Geographic a few years ago.
While this is PREFERABLE to a more impulsive young teen, it doesn't obviate the fact that even a relatively mature 13-year-old often holds views that may change (or they may regret) as an adult.
Raise your hand if you were absolutely confident of something at 14 that you now think is totally wrong. Now, what if that something you firmly believed was an irreversible decision (such as permanent infertility)?
🖐️
And yes, puberty blockers by themselves don't cause permanent infertility, but nearly ALL blocked kids proceed to cross sex hormones (as was noted in the court case), and that combination is what sterilizes.
“These drugs seriously harmed me in more ways than one and they have harmed many more…particularly girls and young women.” 1/n
"I would like to personally call on professionals and clinicians to create better mental health services and models to help those dealing with gender dysphoria to reconcile with their sex. " 2/n #KeiraBell
"And furthermore I call on society to accept those who do not conform to sex stereotypes -- not push them into a life of drugs and concealment from who they truly are. This means stopping the homophobia, the misogyny and the bullying of those that are different.” 3/n #KeiraBell