…not least because the UK is institutionally racist, and these issues are highlighted (and magnified) in educational experiences and outcomes.
An evidence-based thread…🧵
1/
Before we get going, there is no profusion or absence of ability/talent or aspiration/ambition in any racial or ethnic group. Assuming the former is true is racist; the latter is used to explain away social inequalities. We do NOT live in a meritocracy. tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
2/
There are deep racial inequalities in education, with major variations between groups. These are gendered and classed (among other things) but factoring in these other dimensions still exposes racial inequalities. @NicolaRollock@CarolVincent100 tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
3/
A major issue is that the school curriculum is evidently exclusionary, denigrating and erasing the histories and perspectives of ethnic minorities while the PREVENT agenda specifically targets - and others - Muslims. @amna_kaleem journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.11…
4/
It's a cultural issue, too: the teaching profession is predominantly white, and as a corollary, Black children are more likely to be excluded/punished more severely at school than their white counterparts. tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
5/
The recruitment of BAME teachers has been a priority, but it is difficult when a) the school system treats those people with disdain and b) undertaking teacher training and then being a teacher is harder for them. tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.108…
6/
These issues in education then transfer into university admissions - and not simply because of the uneven distribution of grades between ethnic groups - the ‘top’ universities are also the most racially exclusive. @VikkiBoliver journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00…
7/
Then there is an 'attainment' (i.e. awarding) gap, where BAME students aren’t enabled to do as well due to systemic, curricular and other everyday racisms which reduce their capacity to engage fully with their student experience. @L_Bunce@NabeelaTalib tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
8/
This is certainly not helped by the fact that support services – including mental health support – are often not well set up to understand BAME students’ experiences; this is a fault in the system, not those students 'deficits'. mdpi.com/2076-0760/7/10…
9/
Racism is endemic in the labour market, and even those from ethnic minorities who attend the ‘best’ universities have a disadvantage relative to their white counterparts from those unis. @DrLaurenceLP@VikkiBoliver journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/14…
10/
For those who want to progress to doctoral study, the fact that scholarships are largely located in (whiter) ‘top’ unis makes accessing (and graduating from) doctorates more difficult for BAME students. tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
11/
If they do get a doctorate and then find jobs post-PhD, BAME Drs are at the sharpest end of the dire situation facing ECRs, being more likely to be in fixed term, temporary contracts than their white counterparts. @KalwantBhopal@HendersonHollyC birmingham.ac.uk/Documents/coll…
12/
Within the university the workforce, systemic and everyday racisms make what is already a difficult job more difficult than it should be. tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
13/
Thus progression through the ranks - which is also heavily classed and gendered - make it very difficult for BAME staff to progress to senior leadership positions. The UK professoriate and leadership is therefore overwhelmingly white. @KalwantBhopal tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.108…
14/
Perhaps it’s no wonder that the (university) policy system doesn’t take race issues seriously – even if there is policy specifically on race - it doesn’t go far enough, imposing superficial and incomplete systems for equality. @KalwantBhopal tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.108…
15/
Alongside things like the Race Equality Charter, more bottom up approaches like decolonising can place heavier workloads on BAME staff (while their white colleagues instrumentalise that work to further their own careers). @PhD_NDoharty@mannymadriaga tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
15/
UK HE is institutionally racist. We need to do much, much better.
Apologies to scholars whose work has been mentioned but who've not tagged (couldn't find you). Also the emphasis has been for journals for easy access. Feel free to add names and literature to this thread.
16/END
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Don't know who need to hear this*, but reducing tuition fees for *mostly* online learning might seem like common sense, but in fact it's not...universities can't reduce fees for a host of reasons.
N.B. a): 'Tuition Fee' is a misnomer. It pays for academic time and expertise in teaching, but also cleaning and maintenance, administration, the library, tech, some research, widening participation bursaries, MH and other support. And management and marketing.
N.B. b): Expensive to run courses (engineering, medicine etc) are subsidised by 'cheaper' ones (social sciences, arts/humanities). Having lower/variable fees messes this (and access issues) up, as does likely earnings. In short: the £9K+ sticker price is a mess.
Apologies for the white hot ranty thread, but the Covid situation has highlighted how fundamental the problems are in higher education.
Headline Point: University leaderships really don't care about staff or students. A short thread.
1/
Everyone* knew this was coming. The situation wasn't ever fully under control, the movement of people across the world/country, into close proximity, was high risk. Staff and students would get sick, some would die.
*Except the head of UK's Track and Trace, apparently.
2/
UK Universities are in a situation where, often excessively mortgaged, they're always looking to cut costs and maximise income. Staff were already overworked and students are seen as numbers on a spreadsheet - although not by front line staff.
3/
A large group of people goes to a restaurant and places their orders. The food comes, and despite protestations that the portions are both miserly and incorrect, the management insists that this is all they’re getting. The people are hungry, so they eat it. #examshambles
1/
Just as they’re finishing their meals, the management returns and says that they had in fact been given the wrong food. Therefore, to make amends, they would now be given the right food, but this time in supersized portions. #examshambles
2/
The older members of the group, who belong to the landed gentry, are experts in gluttony. They not only tuck in but also steal their neighbours' food. The victims protest to the management who claim helplessness but wink conspiratorially at the gluttons. #examshambles
3/
The Exzellenzinitiative, in part driven by the nonsense of rankings and 'world leadingness', has created hierarchies in a university system which essentially didn't have them. It has allowed some universities to grow and develop at the expense of others.
2/
Sidenote: Imagine a sector in which universities don't expend time and money chasing internal and external metrics, marketising themselves etc...the focus is on research and teaching, public service, and no fees.
(Not that German HE is a paradise for students or ECRs, mind.)
2/
1. A university which closes may not have been mismanaged. It's more likely to be newish, undergrad-focused, lower status (not lower quality).
There is bad practice in HE, mistakes are made, but low-ranking universities don't have a monopoly on this. It's possibly the opposite.
2. A university which closes has huge effects on hundreds of people: academics and support staff, the students, and the local neighbourhood (housing, retail, services).
If it's a low status uni, it's more likely to be in a less affluent area, its students are local, less mobile.
We thought we'd do a thread on reasons to dislike Toby Daniel Moorsom Young. All of these are variations on the same theme: that Toby Young is foetid bellend.
He spends much of his time throwing shitbombs at any moves towards equality and inclusion because it highlights and undermines his enormous white, male, middle class privilege.
He can't imagine why a lot of people in higher education are left leaning, even though much of their lives are spent developing a criticality which is then personally or professionally used to think about the unfair world we live in.