I don't have much of a brain for religion. It just doesn't really register with me. So a couple years ago when my wife and I were wandering around Jerusalem and we happened to go into the Church of the Holy Sepulchre it did not really register with me that it was Easter.
After wandering through the church, we got to the main rotunda and almost immediately it began filling with people. Soon a choir began to sing and then we were swept into a group that was walking in circles around the aedicule which supposedly contains the tomb of Jesus.
The three different sects that have rights to the church were represented--Eastern Orthodox, Catholic and Armenian Apostolic--as well as Coptic Orthodox and others. Each had a different ritual, there were women ululating and prayers could be heard in a dozen languages.
As we circled under the rotunda each of these languages and rituals blurred together. A handsome young priest approached my wife and started to speak to her in Italian. She speaks half a dozen languages and is Catholic and so felt more at home in this cultural blender.
To me it was all like a kind of fever dream. I felt like a space alien or a time traveler who had landed somewhere where I understood nothing that was going on, each activity or ritual being more remote from my life experience than the next.
But there was something very moving about it. As I said, I have a tin ear for the religious, rituals make me deeply uncomfortable. But there was this kind of shared hope among all these people. You could feel some of the rivalry between the sects. But also the connection.
They all wanted to be close to a miracle, close to what seemed an escape hatch for the temporal trap in which we live. And I found that very moving. It wasn't the supernatural that got to me, but the raw humanity of it.
Afterwards as we continued to walk through the old city, amid olive trees and flowering bushes, I had the clear sense that over time, every spring, regardless of religion or location, this is what people did, they expressed their post-winter hopes, their desire to start afresh.
That resonates with me now on this post-pandemic Easter/Passover, this Sunday a.m. when it is warming a little & their are buds & blossoms on the trees lining our street here in New York. So happy hope, everybody. Take some joy in the fact one thing we all share is aspiration.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with David Rothkopf

David Rothkopf Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @djrothkopf

21 Mar
Perhaps a little context is in order. The prior administration's policies serially violated human rights and were profoundly cruel. When this administration ended those policies it was inevitable that immigrants seeking hope in the US would return to the border.
This administration's "crisis" is that it is more humane and decent than its predecessors, acting more consistently with international and domestic law. It is a direct result of doing the right thing in the right way. And they are actively seeking to manage it.
Ascribing blame, as the MTP framing does, is deeply misleading. Is this an issue requiring urgent action? Yes. But it is also a situation created by the repugnant behavior of the last administration and the on-going aspiration so many have to come to America.
Read 5 tweets
20 Mar
The problem isn't that Larry Summers was right once and is wrong now. The problem is that so many people told him he was right when he was wrong before that he thinks that he remains right even though he is still wrong now.
He (and all of us in the self-described Democratic "center") were part of the problem. Our policies contributed to inequality, to the hollowing out of the middle class, to the worsening plight of the poorest, and thereby to the weakening of the US economy.
The rationale was markets know best. But not only do markets lack consciences (and would leave the vulnerable by the roadside to die) they turn attention away from the right metrics by which to judge economic progress.
Read 11 tweets
3 Mar
@SecBlinken gave an important speech today, outlining the pillars of Biden Admin foreign policy. It was a departure in several major ways--not just from Trump policies but from those of the Obama Era and before. It deserves careful attention and recognition for its soundness.
Blinken framed the speech noting that the questions confronting American foreign policymakers "aren't the same as they were in 2017 or 2009." He said, "This is a different time...so we're looking at the world with fresh eyes."
From there he enumerated eight core issues: stopping COVID, ending the global economic crisis, renewing democracy (at home and abroad), reforming our immigration system, revitalizing "ties with our allies and partners," tackling the climate crisis & leading a green revolution...
Read 17 tweets
27 Feb
A (v. brief) thread on the Biden Admin decision not to directly sanction MBS for his role in the murder of Jamal Khashoggi:

As I noted yesterday, I was disappointed in the fact that the admin did not impose more direct penalties on MBS for being the architect of the murder.
I did feel they generally handled the matter well otherwise, making a declassified version of the intel findings public, sanctioning Saudis close to MBS, launching a program penalizing others who persecute journalists and naming it after Khashoggi, respecting process, etc.
Not sanctioning MBS directly does send a message that top government officials who have interests that intersect with those of the US may act with impunity. It also suggested that the US so needed the Saudis that we dare not offend them by doing what is right.
Read 12 tweets
26 Feb
I'm afraid that on this, I think the WH blinked. By not specifically sanctioning MBS they send the message that top officials worldwide have impunity in the eyes of the US. They also imply that we need the Saudis more than they need us...which is untrue. An error.
I should add that the Biden policy of exposing the truth and penalizing the Saudis is light-years better than Trump's effective defense of them and rewarding them despite abuses. But being better than Trump cannot become the "don't do stupid shit" of Biden foreign policy.
Having said that, the swift declassification of the Khashoggi report, the introduction of meaningful sanctions, the broader lessons drawn by the admin, and the communications regarding their rationale was handled extremely well.
Read 4 tweets
14 Feb
When I wake up in an optimistic mood, despite yesterday's frustrating Senate outcome, I think that with each such exercise Trump is revealed more clearly, is pushed further into our past. We've had many Trump-free days since 1/20 & they are all better than the alternative.
No doubt he remains as do the malevolent fools who still do his bidding in the Senate, the House and elsewhere. But they have failed repeatedly politically, are ever-more tarnished, and are certain to be more so as the crimes of the past few years are revealed & prosecuted.
The mob remains, the threat remains and we must not be complacent about defeating it and every last vestige of it until it is gone. But with with the House Dem's victory in 2018, with Joe Biden & Kamala Harris' victory in Nov, with the small but growing GOP rejection of Trump...
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!