The worst pandemic of the last 100 years is engulfing India. People are dying like mosquitos. Not *one* major Indian celebrity - film stars, cricketers,et. al - otherwise highly active on Twitter with millions of followers *worldwide* have tweeted about it. Not one. (1/n)
Think about it. Why are these worthies - otherwise tweeting all day long - not managing a word of support or condolence for their gasping countrymen? It has been at least 2 weeks of mayhem. Indian social media is full of requests for hospital beds, oxygen cylinders, etc. (2/n)
Why have no major celebrities - superstars with global followings like @SrBachchan@sachin_rt@iamsrk@iHrithik@imVkohli - tweeted anything, amplified anything, reassured the people ? Why this concerted radio silence on Twitter? Think about it.
India is today ruled by a fascistic cult headed by Narendra Modi, which ruthlessly exerts total control over all popular forms of public broadcasting & information. Modi's billionaire cronies bankroll vast spectacles & PR campaigns, and have taken over the media (4/n)
While limited opposition and dissidence is allowed in some elite spaces (and usually in English), the ruling dispensation exercises total domination over genuine mass communication.Controlling the public speech of genuinely popular celebrities is vital to the totalitarian effort
Additionally, Twitter has tremendous reach and influence abroad (and outsized influence compared to its reach even in India). Modi's government is brazenly pretending that all is well and there is no shortage of essential medical facilities and supplies ...
while people literally die gasping for breath waiting for hospital beds and Remdivisir. Major celebrities, in this situation, cannot tweet (even messages of support and condolences, forget criticism of the regime!) because that pierces right through the govt's repeated denials.
This situation is not sustainable. Something has to give. My reading is that the government is desperately trying to spin something as a success for Modi, whereupon the celebrities will be trotted out with prepared template messages to praise the Great Leader's foresight.
Incidentally, the government got 52 tweets pulled down (and @Twitter complied) for criticizing the handling of COVID-19. Like all authoritarian governments, this one is hyper sensitive about its image abroad, especially in important Western countries.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Very important. The prominent Left “allowed” in US and even in UK is loudly (too loudly) anti communist. It’s a source of continued amusement (and irritation) that GA Cohen is trotted out as a “Marxist philosopher” in anglo American circles.
Most of the so called analytical Marxists group deny core ideas like labour theory of value, alienation, freedom as self ownership, etc. They are socialists (of a sort) but certainly not Marxists in any meaningful sense.
The chichele chair in political theory at Oxford (held by Cohen & before him by Berlin) seemingly exists to coopt left thinking into conservative mainstream anglo American discourse by discrediting & invisibilizing genuinely radical views.
The blunt fact is India was the one third world country exceptionally well placed to manage covid-19 and also help other countries through it. We have the world’s largest pharmaceutical industry, well trained experts, know how, & the infrastructure for mass vaccination.(Contd.)
Modi’s government has walked into a humanitarian disaster of epic proportions *despite* these advantages. You can’t run a country with this small shopkeeper mentality. Who are the epidemiologists guiding policy ? Why did govt contract for just 100 million vaccine doses?
UK had ordered 5x its population in vaccines (300 million doses). Similar for US. Modi ordered 10% of India’s population! What the hell was going on? Why has vaccination still not gathered real pace ? Looks like modis “experts” at niti aayog (lol) didn’t factor in mutations