"It is not for the pursuer to stand in the shoes of parliamentarians". These were the words put forward to the court by the Lord Advocate on behalf of the Scottish Government in the #PeoplesAS30.

What it was meant to convey to the court was that despite the fact I....
...was standing as pursuer for 10,000 members of the Scottish Electorate backing the case, I did not have the right to ask a simple question about our own parliament because I am NOT A MEMBER OF PARLIAMENT.
This is one of the primary reasons I am running for Mid-Scotland and Fife in the Scottish Elections - no other elected person can join the case (because it's at appeal stage) and become a pursuer, so I am trying to do it the other way around.
The UK Government advanced absolutely no argument against our arguments that the Scottish Parliament could legislate for indyref2 tomorrow WITHOUT Westminster's consent. They only ever argued against the publics right to ask this question of the court.
In other words, if this needs to go to the supreme court (and if we win the UK Government will probably appeal) being both an MSP the pursuer means there's no more question over standing.
Some have made the accusation that I pursued this case out of ego, they are wrong. There are far better ways of doing that sort of thing without exposing yourself to bankruptcy and the destruction of your financial future at the hands of the Government.
Both Governments have delayed and have taken actions in this case simply to run up costs, delay and to go out to do just that - and they've used taxpayers unlimited funds to do it. It's something when you have to face bankruptcy just to ask a simple question...
...which politicians have consistently (and I think deliberately) failed to answer for over two decades.

The coming weeks will be some of the most nerve-racking of my life. But I am doing this for only one reason....
...to prove that the Scottish Parliament could legislate for and call indyref 2 tomorrow without a section 30 order. I made a commitment to 10,000 people, I think I have kept that commitment and one way or another, I intend to see this through.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Martin Keatings 4 Mid-Scotland and Fife (Personal)

Martin Keatings 4 Mid-Scotland and Fife (Personal) Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @MartinJKeatings

26 Apr
These constant punchup between SNP1/2 advocates and alba advocates (and I don't mean those who actually debate in a robust but congenial fashion) - please leave me out of it. I don't care if someone is snp, green, alba, independent, or another denomination, I'll work...
...with them, if they are pushing forward the cause of independence. Bickering, arguing, slagging each other off - I have no interest in it. I'm interested in only two things: (1) Furthering the cause of independence; and (2) Trying to improve the lives of people in...
...Mid-Scotland and Fife and Scotland as a whole. That's it...period!

I have no interest in the said and she said and I am unable to opine on things I haven't seen or was unaware about.
Read 6 tweets
26 Apr
SNP 1/2 advocates going nuts about my post earlier about Mid-Scotland and Fife - but they can go as nuts as they want to - it doesn't change the maths and I only have to ask one single question about Mid-Scotland and Fife to prove my point.
How are the SNP going to gain an additional 46000 votes in Mid-Scotland and Fife (minimum) over and above their 120000, just to get their first seat on the Mid-Scotland and Fife regional Ballot?
The answer is - They can't! It is mathematically impossible.

That 46000 additional votes by the way, goes up to 80000 additional votes if they take willie rennies seat.
Read 5 tweets
21 Apr
Lord Advocate has gone rogue again - Backers of #PeoplesAS30 check your emails please. For everyone else here's the breakdown.
Yesterday, the Lord Advocate (Yes! The person who is supposed to defend the Scottish Parliament and who is a member of the Scottish Government) took it upon himself to lodge documents with the court with regards to a case brought in the high court of England...
and try to found upon it as a precedent which the court should consider as part of the people's action. Today, the Advocate General (Yes! The conservative advocate general that represents the Tory Government at Westminster) predictably lodged paperwork that basically says....
Read 13 tweets
20 Apr
Update on #PeoplesAS30: It would seem that the UK Gov is trying to enter irrelevant rulings into the case after the hearings. A case under English law (so different jurisdiction) on a judicial review (ours is not a judicial review)....
...in which the people's action is mentioned. The substance of the case submitted is wholly irrelevant to the people's action.
Oh! and the case itself was based on English Constitutional convention, not Scottish. So just hogwash, basically.
Read 4 tweets
20 Apr
This whole #GetOutOfMyPub incident just goes to show how angry the hospitality industry is and people will say that closing pubs was necessary, and they'd be right....the first time round. However, we live on an Island. Had the UK Government setup proper track and trace...
...with testing at the UK's ports and airports, they could have gone for broke like the likes of New Zealand and eradicated this virus from the UK mainland. Testing would have seriously mitigated the chance of COVID coming back with a vengeance and disruption...
...to UK businesses would have been much less than it has been. They like to blame the public for the second wave etc, but the reality is that if they'd actually implemented proper testing (like the WHO kept repeating TEST TEST TEST) at ports...
Read 5 tweets
19 Apr
A very stark opinion from a friend in medicine this week who's been reviewing my medical notes and believes that as a child I might not just have had "balance issues" which you've already seen me talk about previously...
...instead, combined with medical issues in adulthood, they believe I may have dyspraxia (or similar). It not only explains my medical issues which appeared 15 years ago but also explains something more worrying. Nobody picked up on it, and because...
...clinicians selectively disregarded certain information over the last decade and a half, they chose to deal with my symptoms like they would a normal person. The problem is that the medications they've been giving me are Central Nervous System depressants...
Read 16 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!