Top judge Charles Wide criticizes Law Commission for relying on a narrow range of campaign groups to advise govt. LC draws on contentious theories without heeding other views. Judge Wide is critical of any campaigning group being treated “more like a consultant than consultee”.
“Judge Wide said he was also concerned over the impact on free speech because of the failure to consult people who feared being accused of a hate crime if they challenged current orthodoxies on gender and other subjects.”
“‘The consultation paper displays almost no awareness of an elephant in the room, affecting both the substance of the subject and the conduct of the consultation: the apprehension, even fear, which results in self-censorship.’”
“‘It should be a matter of real concern if the Law Commission is morphing, at least in part, into an engine of social change, pursuing agendas of its own formulation, having a privileged position close to the heart of government,’he said.”
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
So many people are being impacted negatively by the gender identity movement. In particular Lesbian and gay teens, many of whom are confused about sexual orientation and feel disconnected from their bodies. But young people in general are affected./1of6
We also hear from transsexuals, who were living harmonious lives a few years ago and now find themselves in a spotlight they never sought. And so many professionals, afraid to speak obvious truths such as the fact that there are two sexes, write to us in despair for advice./2of6
We hear from lesbians who are told they are like racists for not being attracted to people with male bodies. From health workers afraid to use words like “mother”. From gay men from across the political spectrum who feel alienated from what was once their community./3of6
A call to action for US citizens in the UK. Many critics say they can't understand why we're so concerned about the US Equality Act #HR5. What's not to like about a law that protects people from being discriminated against on the basis of sexual orientation? Let us explain…/1
There are indeed wonderful things in the Equality Act which we welcome. Of course there are. But sometimes as that fabulously camp film from 2004 'Troy' reminds us, big glitzy gifts can come with hidden dangers lurking inside./2
So while there's plenty about the Act that advances our LGB rights, too much of the gay movement is so relieved after waiting so long it's reacted completely uncritically. So what IS it we fear that's lurking inside? To be clear the problem is NOT trans people.👇/3
We will be live tweeting again today in the preliminary employment tribunal hearing on @BluskyeAllison’s claim against Garden Court Chambers (GC) and @stonewalluk (SW).
To follow the live tweeting, it will be helpful to read Allison’s account of the events leading up to her claim in her crowdfunder. allisonbailey.co.uk
We are live tweeting from the preliminary hearing of the Employment Tribunal case in which #AllisonBailey is suing Stonewall and Garden Court chambers.
The judge has ruled that for this hearing only, the names should remain redacted.
It is a Rule 50 Order. These particular individuals are members of Stonewall’s Trans Advisory Group and their names may well be known elsewhere. What is relevant is the messages from the group to Garden Court.
What is wrong with you @nytimes? It’s not conservative to accept the reality that males and females are biologically different. Every person on the planet was born from a female./1of8 nytimes.com/2021/01/31/opi…
“You’d think that legislation affecting the lives of so many young people would be based on hard research and science.” Yes it is! @WorldRugby cites *dozens* of scientific studies in its decision to keep women’s rugby safe. Sex, not gender, is based on science./2of8
Homophobia is dislike of or prejudice against gays and lesbians. We will oppose it whatever form it takes. We oppose it when it is based on regressive, traditionalist, religious, sexist bias branded as “family values”./1of4
We oppose it when it is based on the regressive stereotypes and sexist bias known as “gender identity” and falsely branded as “inclusiveness”. The belief that “sex” should be replaced by “gender” excludes and is hostile to people with same-sex sexual orientation./2of4
We oppose homophobia whether it comes from the right or the left. Whether those who attack us call themselves conservative or progressive./3of4