Debjani Bhattacharyya 🇮🇳 Profile picture
May 11, 2021 15 tweets 9 min read Read on X
1. A must read thread to understand #WestBengalViolence

Statistical projections were done on two sets of given data.
I: Average voter turnout as per ECI was 75%
II: Religious demography of #WestBengal as extrapolated from 2011 Census data i.e WB has 67% Hindus, 31% Muslims &
2. 2%—other faiths.

Thru' statistical projections frm given data & certain assumptions regarding factors whr exact data were not available, % of votes casted appeared to be distributed as follows.

Hindus 45%,Muslims 29%
&Others 1%—Total 75% (approx voter turnout—ECI) #Bengal
3. Out of all Hindu voters of #WestBengal,
—41.6% voted to BJP
—10.9% to TMC
—14.6% to LEFTs, Congress, ISF, Independent, NOTA etc. combined

—32.8% stayed away from voting altogether.
4. Out of all Muslim voters of #WestBengal,
—91% voted to TMC
—1% to BJP
—2% to LEFTs, Congress, ISF, Independent, NOTA etc. combined

—only 6% stayed away from voting
5. Out of 100% casted Hindu Votes in #WestBengal

—62% went to BJP
—16.2% to TMC &
—21.8% to LEFTs, Congress, ISF, Independent, NOTA etc. combined.

Those who're saying WB HINDUS didn't vote much for BJP, r wrong.

Is greater consolidation than 62% desirable in a Democracy?
6. As per ECI data, #bjp4bengal received 38.1% of total casted votes. #WestBengalViolence

Out of this 38.1% vote share of BJP, Hindu votes accounted for 37.2%.

(62% of 67.2% of 67% out of total 75%)
7. This also means that 97.6% votes casted to BJP, came from Hindus of #WestBengal.

[Please kindly note, all previous ideas spread by BJP IT Cell that Muslim women would vote for BJP etc. appears misconceptions.]
8. On the other hand, out of 100% of casted Muslim Votes,
—97.1% to TMC
—1% to BJP
—1.9% to LEFTs, Congress, ISF, Independent, NOTA etc. combined

Is such sectional consolidation a sign of democracy? Muslims of #WestBengal voted without any democratic variance. ALL FOR TMC.
9. As per ECI data, TMC received 47.9% of the total casted votes. Out of this 47.9% vote share of TMC, Muslim votes accounted for 37.5%.

(97.1% of 93.5% of 31% out of total 75%)

Muslims of #WestBengal didn't want #SonarBangla as promised by BJP.
10. This also means that 78.3% votes casted to TMC, came from Muslims.

Isn't this huge sectional consolidation behind TMC in #WestBengal a corroborative evidence of sectional appeasement?

Didn't a democracy fail the very moment when sectional appeasement began?
11. 83.8% Hindus who voted, VOTED AGAINST TMC

—62% Hindus who’d voted,voted for BJP
—Even LEFTs, Congress, ISF, Independent,NOTA got 21.8% of Hindu votes, way more than what TMC got.
—Only 16.2% Hindus voted for TMC

Strong anti-incumbency amongst Hindus of #WestBengal existed.
12. Hindu voters aggrieved of TMC, voted unhesitatingly for BJP.

Out of all anti-incumbent Hindu votes of #WestBengal, 73.99% went to BJP.

All other opposition candidates combined secured only 26.01% of Hindu votes.

Hindus DID vote for BJP please note.
13. The miniscule number of anti-TMC Muslims of #WestBengal too didn't vote for BJP.

65.52% of anti-incumbent Muslims voted for LEFT/CONG/ISF/NOTA

This shows Muslims' desperate antipathy against BJP.

NO EFFORT OF BJP TO WOO MUSLIMS WOULD BE ELECTORALLY FRUITFUL, IT SEEMS.
14. Fair distribution of Hindu votes (SAFFRON CHUNKS) across parties is in congruence with democracy. Hindus of #WestBengal exercised their voting rights as per own choice & opinion.

Muslims formed a robotically consolidated army (THE HUGE GREEN CHUNK) to use Election as war.
15. While Saffron Chunks r distributed across different political parties, the huge GREEN CHUNK is unified under d umbrella of TMC who're attacking units of the SAFFRON CHUNKS. Is #WestBengalViolence post war plunder & mayhem by GREEN BRIGADE in reality? Data suggests so. (END)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Debjani Bhattacharyya 🇮🇳

Debjani Bhattacharyya 🇮🇳 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @DebjaniBhatta20

May 9
Listen to reactions of individual ladies of Sandeshkhali to TMC's abominable beastly efforts by means of a sting operation to claim that incidents of oppression on women in Sandeshkhali were fake as nothing like that ever happened.

Women ask,why didn't WB CM go to see them once?
TMC's loathsome allegation that Sandeshkhali ladies went on a movement in lieu of money & engaged in prostitution by choice.

In reply, the upright women said 'only those can attempt to vilify us in this way who themselves r experienced in prostitution.'

They felt dejected.
Whatever is being heard about Sandeshkhali are all true. They snatched all our lands & properties, women were tortured in the locality where fisheries are there.
Read 4 tweets
Nov 30, 2023
Listened to Hon'ble HM @AmitShah'Ji's speech yesterday at Dharmatala, Kolkata.

Following are the points which may instill hope in the people of the hapless State.

1) He remembered the founder of Jana Sangha Syamaprasad Mookerjee & his Father Sir Ashutosh in the beginning.
This is heartening as BJP won't be able to do justice to West Bengal w/o carrying forward the legacy of SPM.

2) HM mentioned rampant infiltration through West Bengal border while infiltration through Assam & Tripura border is being curbed by both BSF & State Police YUGALBANDI.
Those who'd ask the clichè question "what is BSF doing to stop infiltration" may note 'tis an inane argument born out of sheer ignorance about individual role, responsibility & accountability of BSF & d State Police as per legal & Constitutional formats.

Corrupt State Police
Read 8 tweets
Nov 3, 2023
The Singur-slip of West Bengal Govt

A 🧵

Why was Mamata Banerjee's opportunist movement became successful to destroy West Bengal's Singur hope?

Why was CPM screwed up in there?

In brevity, it was Jyoti Basu's legacy that both screwed up CPM & brought in success for Mamata.
Jyoti Basu's "land reform" model "Operation Barga" (post 1977) had broken the spine of West Bengal reducing the wealth of ALL.

Lands of large land owners were captured by the Left Front Govt under Jyoti Basu distributing those large plots into smaller ones letting small farmers
i.e. bargadars produce thereon under Govt surveillance.

While beginning the test-run of this exercise in 1967-68 during Bangla Congress-CPM United Front Govt,

Jyoti Basu's CPM had primarily chosen the lands of those landowners who were supporters of Congress.

This selective
Read 20 tweets
Jun 16, 2023
West Bengal Govt filed review petition in #CalcuttaHighCourt

They don't want Central Forces in all districts for #PanchayatElection2023

This was expected & spoke on this yesterday in this video👇



In presence of Central Forces, manipulating d poll turns
difficult for administrative machinery

Also note, State Election Commissioner Rajiva Sinha stated yesterday that SEC would comply with the #CalcuttaHighCourt order

But GoWB didn't admit it & filed review petition
Note the concerted effort & the nexus

When GoWB says yes, SEC says no, when SEC says yes, GoWB says no

Why doesn't GoWB want Central Forces in all districts while West Bengal doesn't have adequate & competent police force?

Haven't we repeatedly seen WB police in mute spectator
Read 6 tweets
Jun 14, 2023
To intimidate people & curb their fundamental right to personal liberty & freedom of expression both TMC & CPM are applying the same mechanism

2018 act by TMC

Before Pachayat Election 2018, Biplob Mondal, a TOI photographer clicked a few photos of the nomination proceedings
in his phone in front of a South 24 Parganas administrative building on April 9.

Group of men physically forced him to delete all photos,took him to a village,stripped him naked, took his nude shots & threatened him they’d make them viral if he wrote anything about what he saw Image
2023 act by CPM

A student of Balurghat wanted to leave CPM’s Student Union SFI to pursue higher education. On June 9, the student was called in to the house of an SFI leader where, allegedly, he was assaulted as they got him naked and took shots of his nude & threatened him to Image
Read 4 tweets
Jun 14, 2023
West Bengal CM's Bhaipo's alleged benaamdaar "Kalighater Kaku" revealing facts to ED (as per sources)

In front of the media he said, if Adani can have money, why can't I?

Kaku originally had an inconspicuous grocery-shop in Behala

Yesterday, even Sougata Roy of #TMC, reacting
to #PMModi's "cash for job" statement, asked how many jobs did Adanis offer?

Indicates, TMC trying to equate themselves with the industrialist group Adani

But TMC ≠ Adani

Had TMC been Adani, they would have been Adani from before 2011, not after—

Had TMC been Adani,
West Bengal would NOT have had such grave infrastructural deficits

WB would have had several manufacturing industries

Had TMC been Adani Kolkata would truly be a logistics hub of eastern India(as West Bengal CM promised several times in so called Bengal Global Business Summits)
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(