A thread on Israel and #Palestine and why the media’s “both sideing” and false equivalency between the occupier and the occupied means the average person in this country has no understanding of the basic facts surrounding the worlds longest running military occupation.
1. I’m very fortunate to have spent time in Israel and Palestine and to have travelled and worked across the Occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip. I’ve worked with Palestinian refugees in Lebanon and displaced Palestinian in Syria and Iraq over more than 15 years.
2. The first time I travelled to Palestine it was to volunteer alongside the Palestine Red Crescent as an international observer. I spent my days terrified - riding in ambulances with paramedics to ensure patients got through heavily militarised checkpoints to reach hospital.
3. All around me was the machinery and weapons of the occupation, tanks, machine guns, and jittery Israeli soldiers, most of whom looked like they were in their early twenties. The entire West Bank was under military curfew at the time.
4. We transported pregnant women, older patients, children, incl a child who had been shot in the face by the Israeli army to hospital. For the first time in my life I started truly understanding the meaning of the words “curfew” “checkpoints” and “occupation”.
5. I’m ashamed to say I had never fully comprehended the meaning of these words or the lived reality of these words and I’m a journalist who prides myself in understanding a bit about the world. I fast realised that I understood very little precisely because
6. so much of the distorted and white-washed media coverage of Palestine replaces the word occupation with the word conflict and the word Hamas with the words Palestinian people and the words resistance with the word terrorism.
7. Everyday in the occupied West Bank I witnessed the daily resistance of the Palestinians to the occupation.
Resistance looked like this:
School teaches opening up their schools and classrooms to their students.
Children being tear gassed on their way to school.
8. Shop keepers and bakers opening up their businesses.
Paramedics, doctors, nurses, medical staff going to work daily knowing they will be seeing the worst of the horrors.
Children playing football on the streets of Nablus and the Balata Refugee Camp under military curfew
9. People laughing, singing and feeling and breathing joy, despite knowing their lives hang by a thread.
This is the resistance the West doesn’t name or show. To do so would mean to value and individualise Palestinians, their stories, history, their dignity and thirst for life.
10. To do so would mean to reject the racist framing of Arabs. This doesn’t fit the distorted western narratives of Palestinians, Arabs and Muslims (of course not all Palestinians are Muslim).
11. It’s when I arrived in Gaza and in particular when I set foot in the refugee camps that I started to really, really see the brutality of the occupation. In the West Bank there were Israeli soldiers on the ground, you could try and talk to them to negotiate your way through a
12. check point, in Gaza, there were no soldiers, only watch towers, electronic gadgets, extreme deprivation and a visceral feeling of being trapped amongst concrete, people, the sea, inbetween lots and lots of people, most striking of all, lots of children and young people.
13. I also met Israelis and representatives from Israeli human rights organisations and civil society organisations working to end the occupation. These brave and principled people are targeted by the state of Israel for the work they do.
14. I seldom hear their voices or see their faces in our news bulletins or hear their stories. There is next to no nuance, there is no room or space given to hear and see these stories and realities. It’s fifty years + from the the world’s longest running military occupation
15. the average person in this county and around the world can’t even relay the most basic of facts about Israel and Palestine. This isn’t by accident. Language, terminology and images matter. Being factually accurate, providing context and nuance matters.
16. Not creating false equivalency between the occupier and the occupied matters.
All the Palestinians I know and the Israelis I know want peace and justice. They want to live, to breathe, they want to see their children flourish and thrive, they want the occupation to end.
17. Those of us who want the same for them need to raise our voices. We need to not fall into traps of “both sides” the only both sides are the civilians and the people of Palestine and Israel.
18. We need to be extremely vigilant of and stand up to antisemitism, Islamophobia and racism gaining more traction in our society, cities and communities and we need to stop anyone from dividing us with their words and actions.
19. We need to speak the truth with compassion at all times and act to amplify the truth with compassion at all times.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Thread on #USAElections2020 1. What happens now is also on the US media. They have to stand firm and hold the line and hold their ground. The election result is too close to call and it will be for some time.
2. Trump will use this fact to declare he’s won and to invite chaos, harm, even more racism and hate and to turn things upside down. This is what narcissists do. They set fire to things and watch the rest of us scrambling around to find water to put the fires out.
3. The media have to stand firm and not let him manipulate this moment for his propaganda, for his hate, for violence OR to ‘steal the election.’ The media have to stand firm and not let him manipulate this moment for his propaganda, for his hate, OR to ‘steal the election.’
#JohnnyDepp#AmberHeard#DomesticAbuse. Here’s @SolaceWomensAid’s statement: 1. “This libel trial, focused on the reputation of one of the worlds highest profile and well known Hollywood actors will of course generate further global headlines.
2. The fact remains #AmberHeard was not on trial. She was a witness who claims she has been subjected to sustained violence and abuse during her relationship and marriage to #JohnnyDepp. @SolaceWomensAid expects the media to refocus on the disturbing details that have emerged in
3. court over the past few weeks. We know some sections of the media will pour over these details to generate further salacious and insensitive coverage, minimising violence against women and girls. @SolaceWomensAid calls on the media to show restraint and act responsibly in
A THREAD on cognitive dissonance, white supremacy, racism, and the media and political narrative of ‘counter protests’ and ‘both sides.’ #BlackLivesMatter
👇🏾
1. I’m seeing many white people on social media saying yesterday’s terrifying, horrific violence by the organised far-right in London and a number of cities across the country does not represent Britain, it’s only a ‘small minority’ of people and its why “we” should ignore “them”
2. Newsflash: This argument holds absolutely no water and is based on a collective, overwhelmingly white, nationwide, cognitive dissonance. This theory of cognitive dissonance, developed by Leon Festinger, outlines how overwhelmingly, most people, and in the case of racism,
A THREAD on attempts to derail a (now global)anti-racism, racial justice movement #BlackLivesMatter 1. It’s truly shameful how a movement focused on ending systemic racism, structural state and police brutality towards Black people & POC is being framed as a ‘culture war’ by
2. large sections of the media and many elected politicians and public figures. This derailment goes to the heart of power, white supremacy, white fragility, and the very violence of racism in all its forms.
3. Those of us who are anti-racists or striving to be anti-racists need to be wiser to these tactics. We also need to be wiser to those seeking to co-opt our voices and our work on every level including those who purport to be with us and for us.
THREAD on separation of the media and the police when reporting on protests. #BlacklivesMaters 1. I found myself watching CNN at 4am and following the excellent reporting by a team of journalists, all people of colour, reporting from across US cities where people are protesting
2. the latest brutality and racist murders of Black people by the police. I was struck by how journalists and the protestors were wearing masks to protect themselves from Covid-19 at the same time as trying to protect themselves from huge volume of tear gas used against crowds.
3. I was also struck by what a difference it makes to our understanding of a situation when experienced journalists, most of whom are known for reporting from countries where there is war, all people of colour, are not standing behind the heavily militarised police lines but are
THREAD What happens when you refuse to perform for the media and become part of the spectacle that is racism. Earlier I received a text message from a producer working for a national radio station. I’m not naming the radio station as the producer is only following instructions.
2. Producer: Hi Shaista, would you be available to speak to Xxx over the phone at xxx to discuss how far the press coverage about Meghan Markle has been driven by racism? Thank you!
3. Me: Hi, is the discussion going to focus on analysing the evidence which clearly shows the racism or is it a discussion about if the actual evidence can be denied as racist? If you could let me know how this discussion is being framed I can then decide if I want to take part.