I totally agree with this. That’s why I’ve avoided writing meta with a personal slant, and I’ve limited it to a lit analysis style. I didn’t grow up in China so my experiences might not be the same as that of a CN person. Cultural context and language wise, I have to check
before posting it. Like with any language, language doesn’t equate to cultural knowledge. An also, being racially Chinese doesn’t equate to being proficient in Chinese either. It’s actually important to have an idea about the writer’s background and their language proficiency
skill level before you read any translated work. (chinese or not)
It’s the same for any language really! There are slangs and cultural differences within English speaking countries as well. :)
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Jiang Fengmian is an ineffective leader whose actions does not make sense within the context of their society. Firstly, you’d need to understand what exactly is a “Clan 氏 (Shi)”. (I’ll also explain the origin of the modern term for surname “姓“ (Xing) - a thread
Prior to the Zhou Dynasty, the nobles had both a “Xing” 姓 (the modern word for surname) and a Clan “Shi” 氏. There were several ways one could obtain a “Clan” name. (ie. hold an post, be related to the Zhou King, be of noble blood, through their job) In the Shang/Zhou Dynasty,
the surname of men were ‘Clans” 氏, and and “Xing” 姓 was surname of ladies (your mum’s heritage to be precise). Generally the idea was that 氏 was a reflection of a societal status (wealth, riches, and military might) and 姓 was a reflection of one’s origin. (ie. which tribe
A quick start to Chinese funerary practices - meta thread!
I'll be explaining the coffin houses, paper money, paper effigies, and the chinese version of hell using my footnotes from Chapter 33. (Wangxian enter the Yi City)