Lots of questions about dosing schedules right now as Alberta opens up second shots. I’m pretty stoked about this btw.
First, these schedules are really just how the research protocols are put together when doing the original trials to test a new vaccines. For the Adenovirus vaccines they mostly followed protocols from other AV studies, except they needed to abbreviate them cuz time was short.
That’s why when the dust settled they did follow up research to see if longer dosing intervals evoke better response amplification and hence better efficacy. They compared 6 and 12 weeks. 12 weeks was better, but 6 was still very good.
As mRNA vaccines were new to human trials they again picked arbitrary intervals based on immunological plausibility. These intervals panned out very well. In all of these original studies, variants were just starting to emerge.
AZ efficacy numbers actually looked lower than Pfizer, as B117 was circulating at that time. Still it kicked butt. Now there’s another issue. B.1.617.2. It wasn’t around when these dosing studies were done. It has some vaccine resistance. Not a problem if you are double dosed.
But not up to WHO standard with a single dose. So now the crux of this argument is what is the minimum time we can go between two shots and still have robust immunity. Irony right there I tell you.
There is a time component here too. As we are opening up quickly 😬 a partially vaccinated population will select out B1617.2 as the dominant strain just as it is happening in England. That comes with many of the problems we’ve seen before.
So the best bet now is the fastest road to double shots. Pfizer’s original studies were 3 week dosing intervals, and AZ was authorized for 4, so it’s reasonable to space all three available vaccines out by a month given the situation. So ...
What do I think? 1. If you’ve had Pfizer or Modena, get a booster if you had your first shot a month ago or more. You could push it to 3 weeks. 2. If you can get your AZ booster a month after your first shot, do it. Also blood clots are even more rare with a second dose.
3. If you’ve had AZ and you can’t get a second dose in a timely manner, go for a Pfizer or Moderna booster. There is good real world evidence that this is safe and effective.
If we get 70-80% of our population double dosed we will have this thing in the bag and reduce the risk of future variants.
Again Alberta. Thanks for looking after your vulnerable neighbours who can’t get the shot. 🙏🙏🙏
Almost forgot, you’ll need 2 weeks after you’re second shot for full immunity. NO CHEATING!! 🚨🚨🚨
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
On schools and COVID. This one is a hot topic in our household as my partner is a developmental Pediatrician and I’m an ICU physician. It’s pretty clear that we are directly albeit oppositely effected by the school system and how it handles infections. Yes, we often disagree.
The pinion on which this argument seems to rotate is whether or not schools drive community transmission or they are just a function of it. There seems to be a lot of dancing around these definitions. We know when we shut schools down we see dropping community numbers.
The problem is, those measures come with a bunch of simultaneous interventions. Add lots of variables and it becomes increasingly more difficult to sort out which ones have the greatest effects. There is also heterogeneity amounts school resources and management.
Story time. I hope this isn’t too maudlin, but in the time of COVID, this seems to be the way we eulogize. Today I found out that my elementary guidance councillor died. It should have come as no surprise as he was also one of my patients.
I called his wife to express my condolences, but really it was to grieve over the phone with her. You see, this man was remarkable for so many reasons. Of course he was an amazing teacher, but he was also a force of nature.
I struggled in school. Our family moved around a lot because of my dad, & when we finally settled down, it was because of my dad. He got sick. My mom protected us, shielding us from the diagnosis. As a kid, normal is what you do every day. So I never clued in. Maybe intentionally
Last night before I intubated a lovely man with COVID, he insisted on calling his boss to explain why he wouldn’t be into work on Mon. He was so short of breath I had to finish the call for him. In the aftermath I realized how this job was a lifeline for him. It left me unnerved.
More and more this shows me how disparities drive despair. Without financial support essential workers and the marginalized don’t have a real chance at avoiding these risks. These are the people in our unit. Privilege is protective. I’ve known this, but damn, this hits me.
Without meaningful social change, most of intensive care medicine is just a band aid.
We relish working with the sickest patients & are privileged to walk the most agonizing paths with their families. It’s the impending sense of being overwhelmed at any moment that is grinding us down. It’s that we are here again, as though we have not learned that’s demoralizing.
I am constantly amazed by the heavy lifting our administrators do to adapt and keep things running. They must be feeling this weight as much as we do. The added pressure of being in a leadership role must be immense. I hope they have support too.
You won’t hear it from them. That job doesn’t allow a lot of disclosure, but they are fine people, doing their absolute best in really difficult situations. It’s a job I could never hack, and it is essential to keeping our hospitals running.
As we speak our @CMOH_Alberta and health minister are betting on vaccinations to temper hospital and ICU admissions despite our exponential case numbers. That is a high risk wager if they get it wrong. Based on current hospitalizations and past experiences we should lock down.
This is a similar situation to last wave. Though I hold optimism that vaccines will save lives, using lagging indicators just means we wait for young people to start overwhelming the system. Even though they tend to have better disease outcomes, this remains a percentage game.
This is predictable math. To make infection control an all or nothing game is naive and irresponsible. Lock down now. Continue aggressive vaccination. Open up at 80% vaccine uptake, regardless of how low case counts are. Better yet push for #CovidZero.
The Covid situation in Ontario is making people pretty jumpy, so let’s focus on some positives.
- GenX showed up like crazy for their vaccination
- Our elderly are vaccinated
- We have had a 2 week head start
- Our population is younger
- We have lower population density.
Now let’s focus on what we can do about it in the short term.
- don’t let your mask slip.
- support and advocate for racialized and essential workers
- enjoy spring while following the rules
- push for #covidzero
- help curb vaccine hesitancy (be nice about it)
- take the jab.
When your brain isn’t overloaded, in those quite moments, think about long term solutions.
- wage disparity
- marginalized populations
- health and social equity
- socialized healthcare and health prevention
- mental health and addictions stigma
- political polarization