2/

Despair and a sense of futility are part of the zeitgeist.

But the claim that nothing will change with Netanyahu's departure is more than that. It is half true, perhaps more. Importantly true. But not entirely true.
3/

The deep truth? That Netanyahu's ideology has been spliced into the organizational DNA of official Israel. That ideological embrace of occupation brought Netanyahu to power, and he amplified it significant.
4/

Occupation needs no marching orders from an Israeli Prime Minister to sustain itself, and to metastasize. In that sense, his departure in and of itself will, as folks are saying, change nothing.

But that is only part of the story, and part of the truth.
5/

I get up in the morning and try to identify the most egregious things in the occupation of East Jerusalem. To flag them and stop them when I can, to contain them or even roll them back when possible. I fail far more often than I succeed.
6/

But there is no way to putting an end the evils of occupation except by ending occupation. At best one can ameliorate some of the worst manifestations of occupation.
7/

Under this new government, there will be opportunities – opportunities, not guarantees – to prevent some of the pain and suffering that is inherent in the occupation of Palestinian East Jerusalem that did exist under Netanyahu.
8/

The chances of engaging decent members of the cabinet – and they exist - will grow.

The chances of preventing the large-scale displacement in Sheikh Jarrah and Silwan will increase. Far from guaranteed, but the chances will increase.
9/

There is a chance to salvage the status quo on the Temple Mt./Haram al Sharif, which is currently in shambles, and to detoxify Israel's relations with Jordan.
10/

There will the opportunity to restore the Jerusalem police to its previous role of "routine occupier" (and it was bad enough in that role), as opposed to the violent militia into which it has morphed.
11/

It's not a revolution, and it does not end occupation, or even move significantly towards an end of occupation.

But for the Palestinians in E. Jerusalem who've been caught through not fault of their own in the cross-hairs of history, it can make a world of difference.

End

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Daniel Seidemann

Daniel Seidemann Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @DanielSeidemann

28 May
Thread.

1/

There are a number of highly controversial issues that simultaneously converged on 2 the ultimate radioactive issues of the Israel Palestinian conflict: Jerusalem and displacement.

These issues intersect, interact and resonate.

It's worth taking a hard look how.
2/

This week the Irish parliament incurred the wrath of official Israel by declaring Israeli rule over the West Bank tantamount to de facto annexation.

Israel often deflects accusations of apartheid by asserting that the status of "Judea/Samaria" is temporary, to be determined.
3/

This dispute over "de facto" annexation and "temporary" is entirely irrelevant to Israel's position on Jerusalem.

It is Israel that asserts that the annexation of East Jerusalem is not temporary but permanent, even eternal.

It is de jure annexation dating from 1967 &1980,
Read 13 tweets
26 May
Thread.

1/

Anyone who has read the Trump Plan w/o Illusions knows that every fiber of every clause is based on the diminished humanity of Palestinians.

Israelis having inalienable rights, Palestinians having needs. Rights are inalienable. Needs fulfilled by magnanimity.
2/

Proposing that Palestinians negotiate on the basis of the Trump Plan is tantamount to requesting they turn their rights, their dignity and their very humanity into a negotiable commodity.

They said no and they we damned right to do so.
3/

Anything less than recognition of the parity of Palestinian equities in Jerusalem w/ those of Israel - in principle and w/ real indications of being serious -is delusional.

It there is any lesson of these last weeks: don't mess with Jerusalem.

She always has the last word.
Read 4 tweets
18 May
@Istanbultelaviv Thread.

1/

The only Ottoman mosque story I can tell.

Years ago, I attended an absolutely intolerably boring conference in Istanbul on Israel-Palestine.

At one point, a Palestinian friend, a world class expert on Jerusalem and Islamic heritage said: let's get out of here.
@Istanbultelaviv 2/

We ended up in the historic core of Istanbul. I am so ignorant - don't ask me to be more precise.

My friend pointed out a mosque to me, which was not, at least to my untrained eye, particularly impressive.

"Does that mosque look familiar to you" he asked.

Nope, I answered.
@Istanbultelaviv 3/

"Ignore the minaret. Pretend it's not there" he said. "Now does it look familiar"?

Nope I said.

"The Hurva Synagogue in the Jewish Quarter of the Old City" my Palestinian friend told me. "It's a precise copy, once you lop off the minaret".
Read 5 tweets
16 May
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 1/

Thread

It's even worse. The problem of the muezzin loudspeakers on the Mount interfering with the President's solemn speeches at the Western Wall was not new. There has been a longstanding arrangement between the President's office/police.
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 2/

...betw.t he Pres./police and the waqf officials.

It was agreed that the volume on the two problematic loudspeakers on the Mount closest to the W. Wall Plaza would be turned down during the President's speech. It was an arrangement that worked to everyone's satisfaction.

I
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 2/

This year, the Police showed up on the Mount and without warning, and demanded that the waqf turn down the volume on two additional loudspeakers to the east, that were nowhere near the plaza. The waqf officials refused, saying it was contrary to the existing understanding.
Read 9 tweets
4 Mar
Thread.
1/
1. On Monday evening, a Palestinian van driver in Jerusalem, was attacked by a lynch mob yelling “He’s an Arab, he’s an Arab”, just a few yards away from where Netanyahu was having a press conference.

2. Bruised and bleeding, the driver barely escaped with his life.
2/

3. In his attempt to escape the lynch mob, the Palestinian driver ran over an innocent Israeli, killing him.

4. The family of the man killed declared that the Palestinian driver was blameless, and to blame him would desecrate his memory. The ultra-orthodox mob was to blame.
3/

3. The Palestinian driver who they tried to lynch was detained and interrogated by the police, and released after 24 hours.

4. In spite of a wealth of video footage, no one in the lynch mob was detained.
Read 7 tweets
3 Jan
1/

More than example of apartheid, Israel’s failure to provide vaccinations to the W. Bank and Gaza is the embodiment of toxic occupation, where the Oslo Accords have become the foundations of occupation, rather than an engine to ending it.
2/

Even as late as last year this could have been different - even without an end to occupation.

Palestinian and Israeli medical care providers know how to work together, and are the most egalitarian in each respective society.

There is no excuse for not providing vaccinations
3/

Why didn’t it happen?

2 reasons.

Because 53 years of occupation have instilled in many Israelis that we’ve nothing to do w/ Palestinians, & they’re imbued w/ a diminished humanity anyway. Occupation denial.

2nd reason?

Because Netanyahu.

It could have been different.
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(