@kampeas @ruvirivlin 1/

Thread

It's even worse. The problem of the muezzin loudspeakers on the Mount interfering with the President's solemn speeches at the Western Wall was not new. There has been a longstanding arrangement between the President's office/police.
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 2/

...betw.t he Pres./police and the waqf officials.

It was agreed that the volume on the two problematic loudspeakers on the Mount closest to the W. Wall Plaza would be turned down during the President's speech. It was an arrangement that worked to everyone's satisfaction.

I
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 2/

This year, the Police showed up on the Mount and without warning, and demanded that the waqf turn down the volume on two additional loudspeakers to the east, that were nowhere near the plaza. The waqf officials refused, saying it was contrary to the existing understanding.
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 4/

When the waqf refused to the Police demand that simply cut the wires to the two additional speakers, and also punished the waqf by forbidding a post-prayer gathering on the esplanade that had been customary in the past.

It's worth analyzing just how problematic this is.
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 5/

One of the foundations of the status quo, dating to 1967, that Israel respects the autonomy and authority of the Jordanian/ Palestinian waqf on the Mount.

It is essential to maintaining the fragile stability on the site.
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 6/

The actions of the police with the wires was not any isolated incident and is an example of just how the status quo has been eroded in recent years.

The police actions send a number of clear messages to the waqf, the worshipers and the Israeli and Palestinian publics.
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 7/

The police messages:

1. We are in charge here, not the autonomous.

2. If you don't do as we tell you, we'll force you to.

3. Whenever the interests of the Muslim worshipers conflict with a real or perceived Israeli/Jewish interest, the latter takes precedence.
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 8/

4. In this manner, a site recognized by Israel as a Muslim place of worship open to the respectful visits of non-Muslims in accordance with the decorum of the site and coordinated with an autonomous waqf is morphing into a joint Jewish-Muslim site.
@kampeas @ruvirivlin 9/

This erosion of the status quo not only the police and the Temple Mt. movements has been going on for years. In the past, Netanyahu imposed discipline. No longer.

These trends accelerated in recent weeks and were a significant contributory factor to the eruption of violence.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Daniel Seidemann

Daniel Seidemann Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @DanielSeidemann

4 Mar
Thread.
1/
1. On Monday evening, a Palestinian van driver in Jerusalem, was attacked by a lynch mob yelling “He’s an Arab, he’s an Arab”, just a few yards away from where Netanyahu was having a press conference.

2. Bruised and bleeding, the driver barely escaped with his life.
2/

3. In his attempt to escape the lynch mob, the Palestinian driver ran over an innocent Israeli, killing him.

4. The family of the man killed declared that the Palestinian driver was blameless, and to blame him would desecrate his memory. The ultra-orthodox mob was to blame.
3/

3. The Palestinian driver who they tried to lynch was detained and interrogated by the police, and released after 24 hours.

4. In spite of a wealth of video footage, no one in the lynch mob was detained.
Read 7 tweets
3 Jan
1/

More than example of apartheid, Israel’s failure to provide vaccinations to the W. Bank and Gaza is the embodiment of toxic occupation, where the Oslo Accords have become the foundations of occupation, rather than an engine to ending it.
2/

Even as late as last year this could have been different - even without an end to occupation.

Palestinian and Israeli medical care providers know how to work together, and are the most egalitarian in each respective society.

There is no excuse for not providing vaccinations
3/

Why didn’t it happen?

2 reasons.

Because 53 years of occupation have instilled in many Israelis that we’ve nothing to do w/ Palestinians, & they’re imbued w/ a diminished humanity anyway. Occupation denial.

2nd reason?

Because Netanyahu.

It could have been different.
Read 4 tweets
18 Aug 20
Thread.

1/

1. I know that I am the occupier and not the occupied. But occupation is the greatest existential threat to the long term viability of Israel.

Israel will end occupation, or occupation will be the end of us.
2/

2. Anything that perpetuates occupation is bad. It is devastating to the Palestinian people, their dignity &their rights to self determination, and very harmful to Israel.

3. The goal of the Trump Plan is to denationalize the Palestinians, creating occupation with deodorant.
4/

4. Palestinians across town despair of ever ending occupation; my Israeli compatriots are in deep denial, sipping cappuccino on the edge of volcano.

5. The Trump Plan tells Palestinians to abandon hope, and Israelis not to worry about an occupation that does not exist.
Read 6 tweets
3 Mar 20
Thread.

1/

Courtesy of @LeeKoren2 , wise words from Israeli author David Grossman in the wake yesterday's election.

The words and wisdom are all his, the flaws in translation solely my own. Apologies.
@LeeKoren2 2/

"There are moments and situations in the life of a nation, as in the life of a person, when you find yourself standing in awe.
@LeeKoren2 3/
And you don't understand how this happened, and who could have thought, and how is it and you try to enlist explanations from various fields, economic, social, anthropological, philosophical and psychological explanations, and you once again don't believe how is this possible
Read 9 tweets
18 Feb 20
Thread
1/

A guide to the perplexed:

1. This plan has been around since 2007. Every few years rears its ugly head, only to disappear for another few years.

2. The obstacles to implementation are almost insurmountable but under Trump & Netanyahu, the unthinkable is commonplace.
2/

3. The plan keeps being ressurrected because it is the darling of the ultra-Orthodox. The land reserves in Jerusalem have been pretty mmuch exhausted, and the haredim are leaving for Beit Shemesh and the settlements of Beitar and Modi'in Illit.

They are pushing.
3/

44. There is even talk of a surrealistic plan to build a tunnel under the Qalandia Refugee Camp, linking the planned Atarot settlement with the exisiting West Bank settlement of Kochav Yaacov.
Read 5 tweets
21 Dec 19
Thread.

1/

The announcement of the ICC prosecutor is Netanyahu's true legacy. He brought us here, and deserves full credit.

True. He did not invent occupation, or settlements, or the settler regime that enforces occupation. That began the day after the war in 1967.
2/

However, with one exception, every Israeli Prime Minister since Rabin has recognized the exstence of occupation and its perils to Israel

They did so halfheartedly while perpetuating that occupation. But some acted in good faith to end it, however inadequately. Not Netanyahu
3/

For the past decade, Netanyahu has willfully, systematically placed all of the powers of government in service of making the end of occupation impossible. He denied and denies its very existence. He double down on its most toxic manifestations.

The maestro of occupation.
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(