I pay attention to trolls bc I’m a masochist but also bc they often represent not uncommon views. This guy who comments on my IG blames protesters for the CCP tightening its grip on Hong Kong *but not the CCP itself*.
It’s a hypercynical, hyperpractical belief in the inevitability and inescapability of the CCP’s continued authoritarian rule. They think that HK was doing just fine & that ungrateful protesters who were otherwise enjoying a “decent” quality of life “forced” the CCP to crack down.
It’s a fairly common view amongst older generations & in mainland China: keep your head down, work hard, & accept trade offs on the human rights & democracy fronts in exchange for a stable life and some upward mobility: if no one had complained, things would have stayed the same.
But many Hong Kongers, especially young ppl who would be starting their adult lives in 2047, want more than stability. They saw the limits — and risks — of a govt that isn’t accountable to the ppl, & how that would shrink their future opportunities & prospects for a better life.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Sidewalk march happening on Yee Wo St in Causeway Bay despite heavy police presence. #hongkongprotests
And as quickly as it appeared it has dissipated. Some remain standing by bus stops holding up Apple Daily pages in protest. As has been the case for many protests this year, it’s hard to distinguish between shoppers, bystanders and protesters until they begin chanting.
Just saw two young women walk past at group of police. One exclaimed “Eek! It’s dangerous to be next to all these Ah Sirs!”
At 1:20am, there are still a few dozen people waiting for those arrested to be released outside Hung Hom Police Station.
The Arrestee Support Counter provided by Yau Tsim Mong District Councillors. The table, chairs and snacks make it clear this is not their first rodeo.
3am: a smaller crowd of friends, relatives, and volunteers still waiting. People are still going in and out of the station. The Arrestee Support Counter is handing out drinks and rice boxes.
3,000 people are watching a livestream of a newsstand in Mong Kok, where today's issue of @appledaily_hk will be soon be arriving, fresh off the press. There is already a line of people waiting to buy their copies. #HongKong#nationalsecuritylaw
A man wearing a gas mask is the first person in Hong Kong to get their hands on a copy of today's @appledaily_hk after the arrest of @JimmyLaiApple and the raid on their offices.
We went to a town in Shandong where a social credit system was being piloted and met an information collector who was paid ~USD50/month to write down information on her neighbors. There was a big sign in the town square explaining the social credit system.
We went with a man to get a print-out of his social credit record from a machine. He had not been able to buy plane or first-class train tickets because of his low score.
Actually completely baffled that the HK government is admitting that the chief executive has to invoke emergency powers to delay the elections because otherwise, “it could be regarded as an abuse of power”
If the government really cared about allowing Hong Kongers abroad to vote they’d have absentee voting 🙄.
They are both protests that intensified as a direct result of brutal police crackdowns, with protesters turning/expanding their focus to resisting the police and their abuse of power. Thus both protests appear(ed) increasingly battlelike, with protesters fighting back. 1/
They‘re both movements that have lasted for weeks/months & thus protesters have had time to develop tactics, gear up & grow bolder w/ experience. US protesters have directly borrowed + shared tactics from HK protests (eg how to deal w/ tear gas), largely thx to social media. 2/
Another possible factor: the protests are taking place in wealthy places, w/ the movements being sufficiently organized and able to acquire funds for gear like 3M gas masks (which you’d only get if you have had the time to organize & the experience to know you need them).