Just finished a piece on secular stagnation and interest rate. Developed version of what I send a few month ago to Trust and Estate magazine. Here are the main points:
1- key driver of interest-rate trend is monetary policy. It is not inflation, fiscal balance, or credit rating.
2- to make sense of what interest rates will do in the future, need to make expectations about what FOMC will do
3- low-growth + high leverage economy makes it difficult for FOMC to raise rate quickly and much + low inflation will persist no incentive to raise policy rates much.
4- growing inequalities, jobless recovery, growing job precariousness, lack of shared prosperity => we can expect low rate to last for a decade or more unless policies are put in place to reverse stagnationist forces.
5- low interest rate environment poses challenge for Money Manager Capitalism that is deeper than "bubble". Money managers have rate of return targets => buy riskier assets and use leverage to compensate for low => promotes use and spread of Ponzi finance
6- Private pension system can't generate financial safety for retirees without promoting overall financial fragility.
7- Economic growth is demand driven (Domar, Walker and Vatter, PKs...) and investment-led growth is unstable => central role for gov to promote ecological and financially sustainable shared economic growth
8- example of major role: ILE show need of rapid and radical shift in energy structure that requires heavy involvement of gov at all levels to shift domestic resources to that goal (R&D, invention to innovation, dvpt and promotion of market)
IEA (not ILE): International Energy Agency (recent Net Zero by 2050 report)
As for my other papers, draft will be on my webpage shortly
A few graphs and tables from the paper (US driven I am afraid)
Monetary policy and nominal interest rates, January 1919 to June 2021
Figure 3. Fiscal Balance and Interest Rates, 1900 to 2021
Figure 4 Inflation and interest rates, 1919 to 2021 (Here only shows long-term rates)
Figure 5. A century of fiscal balance and inflation, Q1 1914 to Q1 2021
Table 2. Long-term economic outlook: Toward Secular Stagnation

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Eric Tymoigne

Eric Tymoigne Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @tymoignee

26 Nov 20
This "bitcoin is better than gold" statement going around once more show that bitcoiners have no clue about monetary history and what the purpose of a monetary system is. A thread.
1- Metal standards were never inflexible; they could not in order to operate properly. Qty of metal was changed, usually lowered, to accommodate for changing economic conditions: price of metal, scarcity of coins, financial needs of economic units (state and private), etc.
2- The purpose of a monetary system is to make the rest of the economy go. It is there to accommodate financial needs. The more elastic one can design the supply, the better.
That doesn't mean that monetary creation & destruction shouldn't follow any rules & have no constraint.
Read 12 tweets
26 Nov 20
@dr_nrl @ShaneOliverAMP @bitterlion @stf18 @StephanieKelton @rch371 @NathanTankus @rohangrey @RaulACarrillo @billy_blog Quick comments on the "Keypoints"
1- MMT is not pro-monetary financing. We don't want to change central bank-treasury financial relation. We show that current/routine/normal financial relation ensure no financial constraint & that, as such, deficits are a financially sustainable.
@dr_nrl @ShaneOliverAMP @bitterlion @stf18 @StephanieKelton @rch371 @NathanTankus @rohangrey @RaulACarrillo @billy_blog 2- Yes below full emp there are free lunch/no opportunity cost. Unemp ressources are left unused. MMT did careful analysis of JG, GND, & student debt relief. Cost of JG is small in normal times GND is manageable if we start now (costlier the longer we wait). Benefits are large.
@dr_nrl @ShaneOliverAMP @bitterlion @stf18 @StephanieKelton @rch371 @NathanTankus @rohangrey @RaulACarrillo @billy_blog 2 (bis)- We are not for monetary financing. We are not for deficit either. We just note that deficit is a usual outcome (and explain why) and that fiscal balance is not a proper policy goal bc gov has little control over it (most G is non-discretionary, T is highly procyclical).
Read 7 tweets
24 Nov 20
Ok. In the mood of sharing a recipe:

Ham and Cheese Cake:

Ingredients:
4 eggs
200g of flower
300g of ham
200g of shredded cheese
1/2 expresso cup of milk
1 expresso cup of oil
One soup spoon of yeast
One loaf pan that is buttered and floured
1- Shred the ham
2- Beat the eggs
3- Mix flower and yeast and add bit by bit to eggs
4- Add ham and cheese and mix well
5- Put in loaf pan
6- Cook at 230F for 15 min
7- Cook at 390f for 45 min
Done.
Final product
Read 4 tweets
24 Sep 20
An animated GIF of the financial balances through time. OECD countries. DPB: Domestic private sector balance, GB: Government balance, FB: Foreign balance.
DPB + GB + FB = 0
It looks to me that we can detect a cycle that reflects the business cycle. Start NE, goes SW, goes E, goes N. Start again. May be I am reading too much into it.
Better quality. made with this ezgif.com/maker
Read 5 tweets
23 Sep 20
The sectoral balance identity, 2015-2019 average (2018 for some), % of GDP. Source: OECD
DPB + GB + FB = 0
DPB: Domestic Private Balance
GB: Government Balance
FB: Foreign Balance
For more on how the graph is constructed: nakedcapitalism.com/2010/03/parent…
Whoops, forgot to change on of the label from data ("0.35") to country. You've got to do it manually, a real pain in the behind.
Read 4 tweets
9 Sep 20
Percent of Public Debt Held by the Public Held by the Fed: 1914-2019 Image
Hold it. I am revising this. Found a few issues.
REVISED VERSION (CORRECTION AND ADDITION) Image
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(