Re-upping this fine piece from Dr. Bob in honor of Kevin's last day at AIMCO: the day the UCP declared war on teachers. (I differ in that I place the date earlier but that is a minor issue.)
A great review of the bullshit that got us to this point. #AbLeg abpolecon.ca/2021/01/17/ucp…
Dr. Bob even includes a quote from @MarkDWiseman before it was stricken from the web. In defense of the ordered IMA his statement said in part:
(good governance and operational independence) "These factors define the success of the Canadian model of pension management." #AbLeg
@MarkDWiseman should know that the current structure of AIMCO and the GOA DOES NOT AT ALL REPRESENT THE VAUNTED Canadian pension model.
That is false inclusion. The Canadian model does not ans has not ever included governments overruling the joint trustee of the plan. #AbLeg
It does not include being forced to use an investment manager that is wholly owned by one of the sponsors.
It does not include one sponsor being able to issue "directives" to the investment manager in secret.
Remember UCP MLAs now have talking points about UAPP being "separate" when AIMCO was formed so it was not forced to use them. That, of course, is crap. ATRF was separate for decades prior to AIMCO. #AbLeg
Who is the fiduciary and trustee of our pension funds? It sure as hell isn't Travis and @MarkDWiseman.
Good riddance to Kevin Uebelein. He will fly away secure in the knowledge that Alberta workers will use his name in vain for years to come. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
It might be on the eve of a national holiday, but it is here, AIMCO's Annual Report. The Pension war Room will spend the next several days sussing out the naughty bits. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension aimco.ca
ATRF 10-year return 9.2% against a benchmark of 8.5% for a value add of 0.7%, for comparisons sake.
AIMCO 10-year return 7.7%, against a benchmark of "we are not telling you". That is some real cajones there. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
AIMCO 1-year return 2.5% against a benchmark OF 8.0% FOR A VALUE ADD OF -5.5%. That is the whopper.
In fact, they have only hit their target return 2 of the last 5 years. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
The Pension War Room™️ brings you the continuing saga of the lies of Travis! Straight from his email to a constituent... (honestly I could not make this shit up)....
The taxpayer writes in with concerns that UAPP can pull out of AIMCO and ATRF can't: #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
"By way of background, the UAPP transitioned to its current governance structure over 20 years ago when it moved from a public sector statutory plan to a registered pension plan under the Employment Pension Plans Act." #AbLeg True but...
"This governance change occurred before the establishment of AIMCo and prior to the more recent governance changes that affected some of the other public sector plans." #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
ATRF WAS ESTABLISHED IN 1938!!!! LONG BEFORE AIMCO EXISTED!!!!!
The Pension War Room™️brings you the letters from Travis edition. Or at least email that he probably had a minion write to a concerned taxpayer.
This was referred to Travis because the local UCP MLA was unable/unwilling to engage on this topic. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
It was sent to me for further analysis. Like we have seen with all of Travis's correspondence: some parts are correct, some stretch the truth, and some are just plain wrong. A UCP sandwich of the good, the bad and the ugly. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
First, it was interesting to note that he did not acknowledge the mistakes he made in his previous email where he represented 2018 investment results as 2019 investment results. Really, it is a bit concerning for getting the right numbers on billion dollar decisions.... #AbLeg
This is your daily pension announcement! AIMCO performance under the microscope at the Heritage Fund meeting. I still don't have the report....apparently mere taxpayers don't deserve such things..... #ABLeg#handsoffmypension
First the good news: Amit, the new investment strategy exec was presenting. Because he was trotted out publicly (in place of both the CEO and CIO) it is unlikely he will be fired in the coming shakeup. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
Then the bad: 5-year value add was -0.6%, the target was +1.0%. With a negative five-year value add no investment bonuses should be paid. #ABLeg#nobonusforyou
You could have done better with an index fund.
This is your daily pension announcement. The Pension War Room™️ notes that another Heritage Savings Trust Fund Annual Report is upon us! Tomorrow morning from 9-11 AM. You can watch it through the link below. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension assembly.ab.ca/assembly-busin…
The Annual Report actually has to be approved by the committee before mere citizens such as myself are allowed to peruse it. Look for high investment costs from AIMCO. Substantially higher than the 0.76% that it cost the ATRF to invest. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension#aimcofail
I thought AIMCO was supposed to save on costs? And insource from private managers? It still seems to outsource $36 billion or 40% of its public equity.
I don't know who will show up from AIMCO. Kevin is probably busy packing up his office, so don't count on him. #AbLeg
This is your daily pension announcement. I can guarantee you there are people at AIMCO that wish they never tried to take over ATRF!!!! Regrets, there are many of them. The line of thought is something like... "man we overreached" and "we should have just been happy with LAPP".
Along with UCP MLAs who are collectively shocked at the tenacity and pension knowledge of teachers. They thought little white lies like "the GOA guarantees your pension" would go unnoticed. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
From way back in the Leo De Bever days until the present time AIMCO has always been able to successfully evade public examination of its investment results. Until now. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension