When straight ppl get together to talk about their struggle against sexual sin, it’s normal, expected, part of healthy “accountability,” a way to fight against ongoing temptation.
When gay ppl do the same thing, it’s part of defining ourselves by sin.
I can’t count the number of church community groups I’ve seen for straight men over the years to discuss their ongoing struggles against sexual temptation.
I can’t count the number of PASTORS I’ve seen admit from the PULPIT that they have a porn addiction & keep covenant eyes on their devices to help them stay accountable to their wife and overseers.
But gay people? If we want to talk about OUR experiences with sexuality and the challenges WE face, unacceptable. Forget using plain vernacular to describe ourselves as gay. English PERIOD is off the table. Same-sex attraction is not only a sin, it can’t even be talked about.
The #pcaga is currently floating a proposition to permanently bar people like me from holding office, claiming that we define ourselves by our “remaining sinfulness” and are therefore disqualified from leadership.
I’m a Christian. Reformed. Committed to an orthodox theology. Celibate & more conservative in my personal beliefs about human sexuality than the vast maj. of Xns I know.
I’m also attracted to women & don’t keep it secret.
For many, this alone is anathema.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The PCA general assembly voted to pass Overture 23 with an overwhelming majority. The overture states, in part, that same-sex attraction is a sin & that calling yourself gay or same-sex attracted disqualifies you from office.
Behold, Christian “love.”
A few additional notes:
Some are saying that this overture only disqualifies gay people from holding office if they deny that same-sex attraction is a sin, deny sanctification, or fail to pursue victory over their sinful desires. In other words, calling yourself gay is okay.
In fact, that is patently not the intention of this overture. Discussion amongst its supporters explicitly expressed their desire to prevent people from calling themselves gay or same-sex attracted. See here from @TheGrantHartley:
Attraction draws us to some people over others. It brings us into *relationship* with human beings.
Desire drives our motivation to *possess.* It brings our *wants* into reality.
Being attracted to someone doesn’t mean you desire them.
It is possible to be attracted to another human being without desiring to do something sinful with them.
Failing to understand this very basic principle leads many to conclude that they have no control over their sinful nature and can’t help but engage in sexual sin.
It creates a domino effect in which mostly men blame the people they are attracted to for supposedly leading them into worse and worse manifestations of sexual sin, harassment, and abuse.
Did you know that according to traditional Christian teaching the vast majority of sexually active *straight* evangelicals are unrepentant sodomites?
In fact, sodomy is traditionally a sin that mostly heterosexual people do. It’s not by definition a gay thing.
How so? Well, traditionally, sodomy is defined as any sexual intercourse that subverts the procreative purpose of sex. Meaning that intentionally preventing baby-making during sex was considered among the worst sins you could possibly do—right up until the 20th century.
"The correct definition of sodomy--then and now--is simply non-procreative sex, whether practiced by heterosexuals or homosexuals. It includes oral sex, masturbation, mutual masturbation, contraceptive sex, coitus interruptus, and anal sex."
People think it’s weird that I’m gay & celibate & don’t find celibacy toxic. They want to know how I “do it.”
To begin with, I don’t start with sin.
Most Christians start their approach to sexual ethics with sin. Why? What good does this do? It creates a theology obsessed with all of the ways we might “fall to temptation” instead of how we might follow the witness of Jesus in our lives.
Jesus came to defeat the power of sin. Why lay our foundations in a thing that Jesus came to abolish?
Did you know the word “lesbian” is falling out of practice in queer spaces?
The reason has everything to do w/ “lesbian” being the ONLY word in the LGBTQ lexicon that refers to women alone.
That’s right. It’s not just the straights uncomfortable with the “L-word.” Even most QUEER WOMEN use the word “gay” to describe themselves before they EVER use “lesbian.”
Why?
Historians observe that words referring to women tend to “derogate” over time. Meaning they become pejoratives. Whereas words referring to men retain their meaning.
LGBTQ people experience some of the highest rates of medical discrimination in the country. When we experience illness, many believe we deserve to be sick & die.
And now it’s legal in Arkansas to deny us ANY healthcare service on the grounds of “moral conscience.”
The only qualifier in this bill is that doctors must provide care in the case of an “emergency.” This is laughable, as the vast majority of healthcare services—many if not most of which are lifesaving—do not fall under the category of “emergency.”
Some argue that the bill does not name LGBTQ people explicitly, so it’s not actually targeting LGBTQ people. Again, this is laughable. We all know what demographics this law is going to be used against the most. Laws like these in the US *always* target LGBTQ people and women.