1/5
Suppose the RBZ & general analysts were correct that replacing RTGS with printed notes & coins is innocuous.

Then why would RBZ not print enough notes & coins for the convenience of the public?

$2& $5ZWL cannot buy anything in Zim. Why keep them in circulation?
2/5
Why print a $50 ZWL note that cannot buy bread.

Imagine a US$100 or 200ZAR that is not enough for a kombi ride or bread?

The rural economy is a cash society. If replacing RTGS with cash is innocuous why has this not happened already? Why punish the rural folks?
3/5
In Feb 2021. Money supply was $100bn ZWL. While notes & coins was $3bn. Of which only $1.2bn was in circulation ( banking system).

This tells us the RBZ is systemically starving the economy of notes & coins.

But why?

Afterall it matters not whether RTGS OR notes.
4/5
Notes & coins have high velocity. That’s why it’s called high powered money. RBZ has weakened the power by limiting severely its supply.

That is why in June, notes & coins is only $3.9bn. That’s US$27m. Or US$46m. When GDP is US$17bn.

Ideally cash should be 15% of GDP.
5/5
GOZ & RBZ do not believe in markets. Nor listen to market feedback. Therefore they will fix the exchange rate & give useless paper money as they deem fit. While they remain profligate

To them, the people must be grateful they now have mbuya. Never mind Mbuya can’t buy bread.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tinashe

Tinashe Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @baba_nyenyedzi

1 Jul
1/9
Twitter and Economists

In Zim to be specific & Africa in general there is a stiff neck attitude amongst scholars & economic thought leaders to avoid Twitter & social media.

This is most unfortunate & JH university has articulated the impact of social media on Economics
2/9

In their words

“The technological progress in our modern societies has witnessed the emergence of persons who deploy different means of communication across social networks, seeking to generate an impact among their audiences.
3/9

These efforts in social media communications attempt to alter consumption preferences and patterns, political choices, as well as reinforce or modify opinions of all sorts and stripes. Individuals who attain greater relevance due to effects they trigger on third parties are
Read 9 tweets
24 Jun
Kuvimba declares US$5.2m in dividend. How in the world of the living, this is a good thing is beyond me. Perhaps a reflection of our tolerance for pain & suffering as a people.

Firstly, it's not even clear to the tax payer how these assets were acquired and at what cost
How do farmers, War vets, Datvest nominees & other investment vehicles own what was private companies that owed creditors north of US$100m. To whom erstwhile shareholders were paid out north of US$100m. The cost of investment must be established & how the money was paid.
Secondly. GOZ is mandated by our constitution to take care of public health facilities & schools. How many people have died, kids failed for lack of investment. Therefore resources were diverted to buy mining companies & declare a dividend to spurious causes outside the mandate..
Read 6 tweets
19 Jun
1/10

Economic survey by Afrobarometer .. my thoughts

The survey was carried out between April and May. After the Agriculture harvest.

It comes after the WB report that 49% of citizens live under extreme poverty

It’s worth considering what the people themselves are saying.
2/10
The 67% of people believe the country is going in the wrong direction.

There is a gapping disparity between what GOZ says & lived reality.

Agriculture contributes 9.3% of GDP. A good harvest impact on our economy is now negligible. GOZ is out of touch with reality.
3/10
Does it mean GOZ will change course? Especially after launching its National Development Strategy NDS1?

Despite the rejection of NDS1 by the people, GOZ will not change direction. Because of GOZ paternalistic attitudes. Even in the face of hard facts & evidence.
Read 11 tweets
16 Jun
1/13
Who is the risk taker in business?

I realize most people even Economists don’t understand risk taking. This thread hopes to bring to fore risk taking in an enterprise.

I will illustrate with an example that is familiar with many of us in Zimbabwe. A diaspora investment
2/13
Imagine a Zimbabwean working in the City in London and earning £10k a month and living a very comfortable life. No serious worries except long hours at work & the occasion rant from the girlfriend.
3/13
They visit Zim one Christmas holiday and meet up with friends. As often happens in these meet up’s- ideas are exchanged and opportunities explored. One of which is a tomato drying factory. Seems like a good idea enough.
Read 15 tweets
28 May
1/8
Rule by terror

SI 127

So swimmingly was the Auction system that “stability” became a catch phrase in describing the state of the economy. Business leaders & economic analysts told us the second half was going to be amazing.

So one must inquire. Why SI 127? Image
2/8
Accordingly we were sold the following:
(i) a good agricultural season
(ii)a fixed exchange rate for 10 months resulting in decrease in inflation
(iii) Fiscal prudence
(iv) Business tours by the President showcasing successful enterprise
(v) Zimra record breaking collections
3/8
When the reality was;
(i) RBZ quasi fiscal activities & debt of US$5bn
(ii) Unsustainable Afreximbank loan interest above 10% & heavy penalty for defaulting.
(iii) Money supply increase of 535% in Jan 2021.
(iv) Black market rate > 60%
(v) A kowtowing business class
Read 9 tweets
19 May
Part 3

1/20
Zimbabwe and AfCFTA

In the last 2 parts we established;
(i)Trade is the movement of Capital. SA will be the oligopolist leader.

(ii) Zim’s comparative advantage is human capital. Technical skilled labour to be specific.

(iii) AfCFTA is NOT Free Movement of people
2/20
In Part 3 I wish to conclude that;
(i) Zim is not ready for free trade. Let alone one that’s oligopolistic
(ii) GOZ remains inward looking protecting a highly inefficient “local industry”. Reminiscent of UDI.
(iii) Diaspora population explosion will rescue Zim
3/20
While it is true that Comparative Advantage (CA) can lead to competitive advantage is worth considering comparative DISadvantages of a country.

This stark analysis can then help a country realize those things it does that are uncompetitive. And perhaps avoid.
Read 21 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(