One of the urban myths of NAD metabolism is the idea that NAD+ is good, while NADH is bad. NAD+:NADH are a redox couple that differ by a hydride group (a proton with 2 electrons) /1
NAD+ picks up the hydride when small molecules are oxidized, forming NADH. NADH donates the electrons to generate ATP and/or heat at the inner mitochondrial membrane. NADH is also the source of electrons in ketone body formation and gluconeogenesis /2
Thus, ketogenesis and gluconeogenesis are run in a reducing environment while fuel oxidation to produce ATP and/or heat requires oxygen as the ultimate electron acceptor to maintain a high NAD+/NADH ratio /3
NAD+ has 2 phosphates in it but is also phosphorylated to produce NADP+, which has 3 phosphates. NADP+ and NADPH are a redox couple that is mostly involved in anabolic reactions (making stuff). Cells can maintain a high NAD+/NADH ratio while having a high NADPH/NADP+ ratio /4
This is how our cells can simultaneously oxidize glucose (to citrate) while producing fat. #NADtwitter#metabolism#redox /end
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
in 2004, Pawel Bieganowski and I were 1st to describe the NR kinase pathway to NAD+, which--along with 3 related coenzymes--is the central catalyst of metabolism in all forms of life /3
our lab's foundational discovery is that the 4 NAD coenzymes, Crown Jewels of metabolism, are not locked in a vault inside a castle & patrolled by guards. instead, they are exposed to the elements of metabolic stress. many conditions of metabolic stress disturb NAD systems. /1
alcohol, overnutrition, deafening sound, DNA damage, ROS, heart failure, neurodegeneration, inflammation & infection ALL disturb NAD systems in one or more tissues. aging reportedly disturbs NAD, though the evidence is weaker than in all other conditions. /2
when NAD comes under attack, repair processes are compromised, ATP generation is impaired & anabolic processes are disturbed. attributing all of NAD metabolism to SIRTs is just dumb & should have been checked by good reviewers >10,000 publications ago. /3
NAADP is one of the most peculiar & powerful NAD metabolites: a calcium mobilizing 2nd messenger that is important for cell migration in response to IL8. For yrs, it was known to be produced by CD38 but how? We now know dx.doi.org/10.1096/fj.202…
It had been proposed that CD38 reacts on the outside of cells with nicotinic acid (NA) & NADP in an exchange reaction that would form the NAADP plus NAM but there are problems with this idea
1st, there isn't sufficient NA to do this rx. 2nd, forming NAADP outside of cells doesn't solve the problem of calcium mobilization from acidic intracellular stores. 3rd, there has to be a specific signal to form NAADP. NAADP is too powerful to be made willy nilly
every week, i get an email from a desperate parent whose kid has a potentially incurable cancer, asking if they should take #NR, often in a cocktail with resveratrol & other stuff /1
experiences like these make me shudder at the 💩 being peddled in the name of "anti-aging." no phd scientist should tell any such parent that their kid's rare malignancy is curable with their favorite elixir /2
i remind ppl that NR is active in many rodent models of human diseases & conditions of metabolic stress in which the NAD system is under attack (heart failure, fatty liver, neurodegeneration, central brain injury, etc) /3
Many thoughts: 1. Know that blood is rarely the target tissue we are trying to address. These mito disease pts have a muscle disorder but are walking around with low blood NAD. Blood NAD easy to measure and can be increased by NR, NA or NAM
2. Main diffs between activity of these B3s is genes to convert to NAD, NADPH etc. NA pathway not expressed in several key tissues like neuron. NR pathway typically upregulated when NAD under attack, eg heart failure, nerve damage & coronavirus infection
3. Yes we recently unblinded study with postpartum rats with 9 different types of food that indicates that trp, NA, NAM, NR & NMN are not equivalent for pup survival & development into adulthood. Still analyzing massive amounts of data but we will release when we can
NR clinical trials have been done based on hope rather than mechanistic design. Trials of fatty liver, body composition & anti-inflammation require smart patient selection criteria, sufficient duration & should be combined with exercise. Please read this academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-a…
Note that the 12 week trial in which NR seemed to move the needle on fatty liver in men is here academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/1…