Can anyone doubt that American culture is simply *weaker* than it was a generation ago? We can't even handle the name of Boba Fett's spaceship anymore. As totalitarian politics advances, culture withers.
There is a certain grim logic to it. Totalitarianism is the politicization of everything. As it advances, it leaves less room to say, draw, sing, or film anything that doesn't advance the agenda, damage the enemies of the elite, or deliver an approved political payload.
Culture could be seen as a process of asking questions, challenging preconceptions, speculating and mocking, dreaming and guessing. None of that is allowed under totalitarianism, which provides all the answers and requires culture to work backwards from its conclusions.
We're being stripped of the language necessary to express challenging ideas or debate politically correct conclusions. It's getting to where we can hardly communicate with each other any longer. Our culture is becoming an impenetrable morass of incomprehensible gobbledygook.
Culture can also be seen as a bridge between the past and future, tradition and possibility. How can such a bridge stand when the past is systematically erased and the future has been ordained by political correctness? Culture now comes from nothing and goes nowhere interesting.
A culture defined by hapless neurotics demanding the destruction of everything that hurts their feelings or challenges their conclusions is not going to produce interesting ideas. It is doomed to contract into an ever-smaller safe space.
Growing up in the time between 60s counterculture and the rise of political correctness, it was common to mock old-time speech codes and decency laws - but they were far less restrictive than today's Woke Jihad, weren't they? Culture was more vibrant beneath them.
There were things you couldn't say a hundred years ago, but today much more is unspeakable, and unthinkable. Maybe the old-time standards of cultural decency were simply less concerned with controlling what people THINK than Wokeism is. Implication was more permissible.
Modern culture has become horribly weak because it's too preoccupied with killing ideas. Without challenge there is no growth. Culture becomes flabby and listless, devoid of sunlight and exercise, forbidden to do anything that might challenge political power.
Politicized culture is alienating because it's so busy enforcing preconceived notions and silencing "incorrect" ideas that it doesn't resemble real life anymore. It just isn't rooted in the human experience. It rings false. It cannot envision anything its masters disapprove of.
There is less you can say today than you could 20 years ago, less you can dream, less you can dare. Much of what we were doing and saying only a generation ago is now forbidden. Our culture is unquestionably weaker and smaller than it used to be. We are diminished. /end

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with John Hayward

John Hayward Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Doc_0

8 Jul
The battle to define freedom must be won before the war to defend it can be fought.

That's why totalitarian statists and outright fascists can look you in the eye and claim they love "freedom" and see themselves on a patriotic crusade to preserve it.
America was founded on a vision of individual freedom, built from the ground up. The Founders tried to isolate the essential characteristics of individual sovereignty and write a Constitution that would limit the power of government to damage those vital freedoms.
The notion of "inalienable rights" is an example of building the definition of freedom from the ground up. These rights are inherent to free men and women and cannot be compromised, so a just and moral government will fully respect them.
Read 19 tweets
6 Jul
The utter failure of nation-building in Afghanistan, where the Taliban is rolling up the whole country with little resistance while U.S. troops are still boarding the planes for home, has profound implications for Western civilization in an age of globalism and mass migration.
The great nation-building crusade of the neocons was a complete and absolute disaster. 20 years, billions spent, so many lives lost, and we made few lasting impressions on Afghanistan. We walked across sand, and now the evening tide of savagery rolls in to erase our footprints.
Iraq teeters on the verge of becoming an Iranian satrapy, with Tehran's militia proxies brazenly attacking American positions. Obama's nation-building in Libya unleashed a decade-long hell of warlords and terrorists that will now become part of Turkey's Islamist empire.
Read 18 tweets
2 Jul
The next few decades will see an ideological and economic struggle in which nationalism is the most important weapon. Hyper-nationalist states like China have a huge advantage over neurotic self-loathing post-nationalist Western nations that have unilaterally disarmed themselves.
All conflict is a test of will. The battle ends when the enemy loses his will to fight. Nationalism is a vital reservoir of will for ideological conflicts. The new century's authoritarian horror, Communist China, is determined not to be defeated as the Soviet Union was.
Meanwhile, the West is filled with teams that can barely take their own side. The very concept of national cohesion is under sustained, blistering attack all over the "free world" - and it is very clearly becoming less free as that scorched-earth campaign proceeds.
Read 18 tweets
30 Jun
The quest for Big, Clean Government is utterly futile, and most people who promise it know it's impossible. Corruption is written into the DNA of Big Government, including authoritarian and totalitarian systems. Only small governments can be clean, and even then it's tough.
One of the biggest lies of authoritarianism is that it can provide Big, Clean Government at last. Authoritarians often gain power by criticizing the corruption of democratic Big Government and blaming it all on the private sector. Honest government requires less freedom!
Authoritarians promise that if government becomes a stern religion, and working for the State becomes an act of religious devotion, then corruption will be vanquished at last. Only a selfless overclass of born-and-bred bureaucrats can properly serve the people.
Read 11 tweets
29 Jun
The Sunk Costs Fallacy is a key principle of statist growth. The Left is constantly grabbing piles of money, blowing it on useless or counterproductive programs - and then insisting we can never abandon the "investments" they made on our behalf, so we must keep spending.
Every dollar statists can seize from free people becomes a flag planted on the next hill they plan to conquer. They insist we must be "progressive" and can never "go back," because that would be an unconscionable waste of all the money they've already spent.
Economists call this a fallacy, an irrational and destructive tendency to keep pouring money into failed endeavors because we fear to "waste" or "lose" what we've already spent. In statist politics, it's not a fallacy - it's a key tactic, indeed a core principle.
Read 11 tweets
25 Jun
Your Green New Deal future: fantastically expensive electric cars the middle class can't afford, subsidized by taxes the middle class is forced to pay - but even rich people can't use them all the time because the junk "green power grid" can't handle charging them.
I absolutely guarantee you this ends with confused six-figure-income folks standing next to inert electric cars that cost five times as much as Honda Civics used to, while their political overlords cruise by in reliable gas-powered vehicles that are now forbidden to the masses.
Electric cars just never made sense as anything but an expensive indulgence for virtue-signalers with loads of disposable income - and even then, they survive only by looting taxpayers for huge subsidies. It's just logistically impossible for them to "replace" gas cars.
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(