Happy #ATBDay to all you #energytwitter nerds out there. Let's do a thread on how important the ATB and @NREL are. 1/16
The NREL Annual Technology Baseline, or ATB as the cool kids call it, is the only PUBLICLY accessible set of multiple generation tech FORECASTS for both PERFORMANCE and PRICING for GEOGRAPHICALLY SPECIFIC resources. It's also EDITABLE and TRANSPARENT. 2/16
PUBLIC DATA MATTERS - A lot of utilities use in-house or purchased generation tech data that are opaque and don't include all the financial assumptions ATB does. Here's onshore wind's assumptions. 3/16
There was this one IRP I was working on where the utility claimed to use NREL's data. "Cool, then compare the LCOE's." Their wind/solar LCOE: $40-$50/MWh. NREL's ATB: $20's/$30's. Something was off. 4/16
The utility was double-counting inflation and adding some crazy adder fees on renewables that weren't listed *anywhere* in the IRP documentation. Public data helps uncover the IRP black boxes. 5/ 16
FORECASTS ARE VITAL - I know, folks love the Lazard stuff. I get it, it's nice, clean and clear. Even LevelTen has some great data on PPA's. But : those PPA's were prob signed 2 yrs ago. RE prices keep dropping. If you only use existing $, you're missing the future. 6/16
Everyone's like, "Oh, solar/wind prices can't get much cheaper." Well, they're wrong. And the ATB sees all. ATB projecting solar/wind CAPEX prices to decline maybe another 30-50% within 10 years. 7/16
While installation prices decline, *performance* increases - so wind/solar have higher capacity factors, boosting more energy production, pushing levelized cost of energy even l o w e r. Solar CF's may reach in the 30%'s, and wind nearing 60% CF's within a decade. 8/16
Those levelized costs of energy (LCOE's) are breaking below $20/MWh for wind and solar consistently by 2031 for both wind *and* solar. Dang. 9/16
MAJOR ATB IMPROVEMENT: NREL takes recommendations on how to improve the ATB. Big improvement this year: Solar ~Classes~

Not all GEOGRAPHIES have same solar/wind resource, hence, classes. Last year we had to hobble together what Kansas City solar looked like. It was weird. 10/16
Now: Ahhhh. A good solar resource can get 30%+ capacity factor (Class 1). A good wind resource can get 50%+ capacity factor (Class 1). Harmonization across the techs. 11/16
ATB is *editable*. Don't like the ITC assumption of 0%? Cool. Change it. Let the macros figure it out. 12/16
OH shizzle. ATB also includes solar+storage this year. That's a big deal. Now there's zero, zero reason for any utility to not model it in their IRP's. 13/16
The ATB 2021 also includes improved clarity on battery storage!!!! Standardized *language* around this "new" industry is key for resource planners (and advocates) to discuss specific data inputs for IRP's. Vital! 14/16
Of course, ATB isn't perfect. Here's their native LCOE chart...it, needs some love. But you know what? You can go into the spreadsheet and find the data.
That's T R A N S P A R E N C Y that is unmatched 15/16
From the bottom of #energytwitter's heart, thank you to the TEAM of folks at @NREL that provide this FREE SERVICE to all of us. We depend on you. Otherwise our energy world would be much, much darker place. 16/fin

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Simon Mahan

Simon Mahan Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SimonMahan

3 Mar
This afternoon, @MISO_energy is hosting its final workshop on the Renewable Integration Impact Assessment report. Didn’t read the 217pg report? I’ve created this thread to prep you for the 1pm CT call. (here's the report: cdn.misoenergy.org/RIIA%20Summary…, and the report as a word cloud:)
RIIA began in 2017 as a study to find “inflection points” for renewable penetration in MISO. These are the key questions RIIA set out to tackle: When does renewable integration get hard, and how do we fix it?
If there’s one key takeaway from RIIA, it’s this pull quote from the report: “Through coordinated action with MISO stakeholders, RIIA concludes that renewable penetration beyond 50% can be achieved.” That’s great news, and a big deal.
Read 11 tweets
22 Feb
This past week has focused a lot on Texas' blackout and response to the polar vortex, Uri. There were also considerable problems in MISO South that are probably going to get ignored (except from MISO South customers, and regulators). So let's talk about it. Thread 1/8-
During Polar Vortex '21, aka, Uri...
MISO was importing (-) a lot of power from PJM (MIDA) almost 10GW, and also exporting (+) a lot of power to SPP (CENT) to keep the lights on, almost 5GW. 2/8
eia.gov/beta/electrici… Image
SPP (CENT) was also sending its max 831 MW of power into Texas nearly all last week. 3/8 Image
Read 10 tweets
17 Feb
What are kilowatts, megawatt hours, and giga...whats?

The US power system uses metric prefixes. The most basic unit of energy is the watt. 1,000 watts = 1 kilowatt (KW). 1,000 kW = 1 megawatt (MW). 1,000 MW = 1 gigawatt (GW).
A kilowatt or megawatt indicates capacity or instant power demand/generation. A kilowatt hour or megawatt hour indicates power usage over time.

A microwave uses 1,000 watts of power.
If it runs for 1 hour, it consumes 1kWh of electricity.

A typical TX house uses 30kWh daily.
Power plants are often rated in megawatts. A typical wind turbine is about 2 MW's, meaning it can generate at max output 2MWh in a single hour, or 48MWh's in a day. Wind farms put together dozens of turbines, up to hundreds of MW's of capacity.
Read 7 tweets
17 Feb
While debate rages over blackout causes (fossil fuels? market design?) few have pointed out transmission expansion planning failures. @aripescoe published this great paper (in January!) explaining why major utilities are hampering transmission planning. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cf…
One aspect of RTO/ISO's is "transmission expansion planning". MISO's process is the MISO Transmission Expansion Plan MTEP. There are many *types* of transmission projects from small to big.
Small projects are 100% paid for by the local utility. Baseline Reliability Projects/"Other"/Age & Condition upgrades. Entergy has argued those projects don't need MISO review/approval. So, they're accepted as-is bottom-up projects.
Read 18 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(