Suggested Short Read:-
✨The wonderful Dialogues"
The questions of Dalit leader "Shri Suraj Bhan ji"(The Previous Governor of UP and HP) and the reply given by HH Puri Shankracharya ji✨
Sooraj Bhan ji was the former governor of Uttarpradesh and Himanchal. He started his Childhood education in an arya samaji gurukul. Being distressed He later joined a school run by Jains. He was a face of Dalit upliftment.

The incident I'm going to narrate occurred in aug 2002 .
He reached Sringeri Shankracharya peetham to meet HH Shankracharya Bharti Tirth MahaSwami. He sought the support of Sringeri Shankracharya ji "to delete the objectionable statements regarding Shudras from Manusmriti and others.
Sringeri Shankracharya ji consented and provided his assurance for the upliftment of Dalits but regarding the "amendment in scriptures" he said:- "It's appropriate to consult other Shankracharyas,He inspired Suraj Bhan ji to meet Puri Shankracharya ji"
The Date of 2nd August 2005 was fixed. Suraj Bhan ji along with Many ministers of govt of India reached the Govardhan math puri.
Suraj bhan ji expressed his feelings in fifteen minutes. One of his statements was:-
"Shankracharya ji If hindus are to be saved ,please remove the disparity in the name of castes. Please give Dalits the right to become preists etc. Half of the Hindu population belongs to Dalits.
"Manusmriti and ramcharitmanas can be reprinted after deleting objectionable words regarding Shudras".
Shankracharya ji cleared his doubts one by one, The answers were overwhelming and filled with affection. In the end He offered fruits and clothes to Suraj Bhan ji and his Retinue.
Overwhelmed with love,Sooraj Bhanji said, "My closed eyes have opened. I shall be coming for darshan from time to time. It was my fault that I could not get our conversation recorded. One of your disciples has recorded it. I entreat that your personal secretary may send it to me"
This beautiful conversation is published in the form of a short book called "The wonderful Dialogues" in English and "#विचित्रसंवाद" in Hindi.

Acharyas have answers to every doubt,They are ready for any arguments. Please visit them and ask your doubts before forming an opinion.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with VedaEchoes

VedaEchoes Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @vedaechoesji

14 Jul
Recently the Government of Uttar Pradesh has passed the population control Bill and many governments are planning to do it in future.
Here is a short analysis of the policies ( Taken from my instagram post) Image
I have seen guys celebrating because the population of "Muzlims" will decrease they care nothing about their own population and families. Image
SP Minister said :- "No matter how many laws you make,one who has to take birth will take birth" Image
Read 10 tweets
4 Jul
✨Story of Brahma and ma Saraswati✨
Are they Husband-wife? Father-daughter or something else?
Long thread but you'll understand it in one go. Please continue till end.
The claim that people make is: - In the Vedas & Puranas it is written that " Brahma ji married his own daughter Saraswati . For this they give references from Rigveda Samhita ( 10.61.5-7 ) Aitareya Brahmana ( 3.9.13-33 ) , SrimadBhagvatam(7.11) , Matsya purana and various others
Here is the story from SrimadBhagvatam

इतिहासपुराणाभ्यां वेदं समुपबृंहयेत् ।। ( Mahabharta 1-1-293 ) one has to decode and expand the meaning of Vedas through the Help of Puranas . We are going to look at this story in the light of Vedas , puranas and traditional Acharyas .
Read 16 tweets
1 Jul
Read this till end
Ks Lal in his book "the growth of scheduled tribes" writes that caste system is the reason why we survived and didn't suffer the fate of arabia and iran.
The caste organization is to the Hindu his club, his trade union, his benefit society, his philanthropic society. There are no work-houses in India and none are as yet needed"
(Sidney Low in his Vision of India' (pp. 262-263, 2nd ed. of 1907)
Abbe Dubois, after being in close touch with Hindus of all castes for 15 years as a missionary, remarks (in his work on the character, manners and customs of the people of India, translated into English and published in London in 1817):
Read 5 tweets
29 Jun
They:- Love is Love it can happen with anybody.
🌟 Well it's not true,If your upbringings are right&you mana is in control.

When Maharaj Dushyant was attracted towards Shakuntala what he said? Continue till end to read the beautiful story🌟 Image
This is the story when Dushyanta met Shakuntala .Maharaj Dushyant began to like her. Dushyant was in confusion that she is the Daughter of Mahrshi Kanva{Because she lived in Kavashram} and therefore she is a brahmin. Image
King Dushyant said:- My mind does not dwell towards any other girl than that of a kshatriya " O soft - spoken { shakuntala ) you must know that I have full control over my heart , but I'm having affection towards you . Hence , you're a Kshatriya's daughter Tell me who are you ?
Read 6 tweets
9 Jun
Childish Talks Again.
Again he is quoting Puranas in competition with Vedas. Let's continue till end to understand this. I can quote puranas that mentions animal sacrifice(quoted) but let's start from basic.

I have explained this whole thing already in thread but still.
Mimansa स्मृत्याधिकरण (१/३/३) The authority of Smriti vachan is not valid if it goes against Vedas.
या वेदबाह्याः स्मृतयो याश्च काश्च कुदृष्टयः ।(Manu १२/९५)
Vyas smriti १/४ describes Vedas>>>Smritis>>puranas. Former blocks later.
An entry level gurukula student know such basics
This Manu- Vachan can solve all problems.
"तस्माद्यज्ञे वधोSवध:" in yajnas वध is अवध. Similarly Devi Bhagvat ३/२६/३३ "for yajnas Pashu Hinsa is not Hinsa" So half of problems gone.

Don't try to misinterpret medhatithi or cry about Adulteration. This one is from Kulluka Bhashya.
Read 7 tweets
9 Jun
Lol this is the best you came up with 😂😂 Changing topic from Ashvamedha to Mahidhara
Anyways Okay Continue till end.
Here Mahidhara explains the meaning of words in 22 almost similar words are used in 23. So people can note them. Dayanand uses derivate meaning which is not valid.
Now continue
Ashvamedha is सर्ववाचात्मक as stated in Shukla yajurveda shatpath brahmana,All type of Speeches are made there. During Yajna the meaning of mantra is not Spoken.
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(