Yesterday, the Biden administration tried to put an end to the Nord Stream 2 controversy. Did it? I doubt it. This appears to be itsa defining foreign policy mistake unless it changes it, as I still hope it will. Everything was wrong.
2. The essence of the German-US joint statement is that the US stopped its opposition to NS2, overruling two US sanctions laws, without getting anything in return, allowing itself to be defeated by Putin, Schröder & Warnig. Is this the US?! auswaertiges-amt.de/en/newsroom/ne…
3. By not inviting the main parties concerned, Ukraine, Poland, the Baltic states, the US & Germany alienated them, notably Ukraine.
4. It appears that the discussion was limited to energy security, so that Putin's aggressive July 12 article, which looked like an ultimatum to Ukraine, was not even part of the discussion.
5. The statement does not acknowledge that Gazprom right now is minimizing its gas deliveries to Europe to minimize EU reserves for the winter. Everything suggests that Gazprom is preparing another bug cut in January & the US & Germany just ignore it.
6. With regard to Nord Stream 1 & 2, Germany has done whatever it can to undermine the EU third energy package of free gas trade. The statement hypocritically claims German compliance with it but "under German jurisdiction," not EU rules.
7. The only actual substance of credibility in the joint statement is that Germany will appoint a special envoy for Ukraine. Why would the US engage in such a tiny issue? The funds mentioned are peanuts requiring no bilateral statement.
8. This unwarranted Biden administration gift to Putin endangers Ukraine's national security. It leads to serious questions about the competence of the Biden administration in foreign policy. Why give up a major foreign policy goal & divide allies for nothing? Fix this!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Immediately after the disastrous US-German agreement on no sanctions on Nord Stream 2, Angela Merkel called Putin to celebrate her achievement with Biden. Why? Is she trying to qualify for a Russian state corporate job after her retirement like Schröder? en.kremlin.ru/events/preside…
"The leaders are satisfied with the construction of the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline, which is nearing completion. The President of Russia noted Germany’s consistent commitment to implementing this project, which is strictly a commercial venture...
...and is designed to enhance energy security of Germany and the rest of the EU. Ms Merkel told Mr Putin about the discussion on the developments around the pipeline project with US President Joseph Biden in Washington." Why?
What the Biden administration should do on Russia/Ukraine/Nord Stream 2. 1. Follow the Interim National Security Strategy: "Russia remains determined to enhance its global influence and play a disruptive role on the world stage." whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/…
2. Russia as a disruptive (possibly rogue) power does not obey international law as Putin proves all the time & it should not be expected to do so. US officials need to stop hoping for "Russia's good will" (even Blinken hope for that recently).
3. The general conclusion is that if you don't hit Putin hard between the eyes, you will not be taken seriously. In order to become serious in relation to Russia, the Biden administration has no choice but to sanction Nord Stream 2 fully as the Congress has LEGISLATED.
This Politico article captures the absurdity of the Biden administration policy on Nord Stream 2. Biden is against it, but his staff want to get it done to the benefit of Putin & his German agents Schröder & Stasi agent Warnig against the EU & Ukraine. politico.com/news/2021/07/2…
Nord Stream 2 is a Russian geopolitical project aiming at breaking up the EU, promoting corrupt revenues of Putin's friends, corrupting German & Austrian elites, damaging the EU market-oriented energy policy & undermining EU energy security. atlanticcouncil.org/in-depth-resea…
Biden used to be against Nord Stream 2, but now his administration has become the main ally of Putin & the corrupt elements in Germany to get it done. Why? Don't they understand or what...? has somebody already been bribed? Putin is so good at that.
It was good that @POTUS & Chancellor Merkel spoke a lot about Ukraine in their press comments, but what they said was not reassuring. whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/…
Biden: "I reiterated my concerns about Nord Stream 2, Chancellor Merkel and I are absolutely united in our conviction that Russia must not be allowed to use energy as a weapon to coerce or threaten its neighbors."
Good but how? This sounds like eyewash.
Merkel: "We will be actively acting should Russia not respect this right of Ukraine that it has as a transit country. So Nord Stream 2 is an additional project and certainly not a project to replace any kind of transit through Ukraine."
As empty as a threat gets.
Most interesting. Moskovsky Komsomolets' excellent pro-Kremlin foreign political observer Mikhail Rostovsky reads Putin's article on Ukraine just like me: "Putin issued the last ultimatum to Ukraine: 'Kiev does not need Donbass'." mk.ru/politics/2021/…
As a Moscow insider, Rostovsky spells out what Putin really meant to those who did not understand. 1. Russia's policy on Ukraine has changed. 2. Russia will not accept what happens in Ukraine's domestic politics but engage. 3. "Russia was actually robbed" of territories.
4. Kiev does not need Donbass any longer. Who needs it? [Russia!] 5. Putin does not only talk about Donbass: Millions of people in Ukraine oppose the Ukrainian project "anti-Russia". 6. Naturally, Russia will defend these millions.
ABC in Russia policy for the new NSC team: 1. Nord Stream 2 is designed to split the EU & the West. With SPD in her coalition government, Angela Merkel is too weak to stop it. Then the US should help but fully sanction it, but it did not.
2. When Russia provokes, always stand up against it. The US was right to send in war ships into the Black Sea at the time of the Russia military mobilization around Ukraine in April & very wrong to stop their entry. The UK acted rightly.
3. When Russia provokes the West, never give it anything for free, such as a summit with the US president.