@OpenIDExchange Indeed we still need governance, at various nested levels. The world is full of "trust frameworks" (as every trust framework tutorial says at the very outset). The trick with digitising credentials is to minimise the introduction of new and novel governance. -/2
@OpenIDExchange So we should start with the way credentials are governed by their respective communities. The nursing profession for example credentials its members, with rules for what the credential means, how it's issued and relied upon. -/3 Image
@OpenIDExchange Communities of patients are governed separately, with different rule sets for enrolling into insurance programs, admitting them to clinics or registering them for treatments like vaccinations. -/4
@OpenIDExchange 4. Note that WHO guidance for #VaccineCertificates says when digitising the fact of vaccination, we must not change the way extant health systems identify and register patients. See who.int/publications/m…
And my analysis here: linkedin.com/pulse/who-goes… -/5
@OpenIDExchange 5. So when we digitise credentials in e.g. mobile phone wallets, we need a layer of technology management, with standards, APIs, data carriers, tools for transaction signing, distribution etc. This layer must not interfere with the core credential governance. Image
@OpenIDExchange 6. That's how e.g. the Apple Wallet works. It has lots of sophisticated and strictly standardised technologies into which credentials (credit cards, boarding passes, driver licences soon) are inserted, without changing the meaning or any of the rules of the credentials. -/7
@OpenIDExchange 7. And then there's the law, the ultimate governance layer. -/8 Image
@OpenIDExchange 8/8. So there's plenty governance out there already. As @ByrneNick has called out, the #SSI has come to "over-emphasise" governance. nickbyrne.substack.com/p/the-challeng…
IMHO the last thing we need is more trust frameworks. Let's simply digitize credentials in context. #VerifiableCredentials

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Steve Wilson

Steve Wilson Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Steve_Lockstep

2 Jun
“If punishment is ... to shape future behaviors, then I think that is a justifiable way to dole it out” — ⁦@bgreene
But there’s no “if” about it, because the universe can only play out one way. @Forbesforbes.com/sites/dporterf…
This seems to point to something like the Anthropic Principle. If everything is strictly deterministic and the universe can only play out one way, then our social institutions weren’t designed. Yet they seem to function with sensible outcomes (which Brian even appeals to).
And there’s no room here for a “Blind Watchmaker” to explain this design, because a deterministic universe only has one shot at it.
Read 4 tweets
5 Feb
A rant about #trust following the terrific discussions at #IDPolicyForum yesterday and today.
#digitalidentity
THREAD ...
1/9 "Trust" of course is talked of everywhere. In #IDPolicyForum, a speaker bounced around from cryptographic trust, hardware roots of trust, and an anecdote about trusting the conference organiser because they were introduced by a mutual friend.
2/9 The trouble with this discourse and widespread use of the label is that it over-states what cryptographic "trust" is all about. It inflates lay peoples’ expectations of what #digitalidentity technology delivers.
Read 10 tweets
5 Feb
'What should Biden do in #DigitalIdentity?' panel, @RossNodurft carefully draws a distinction between [the prospect of a] "National ID" versus a "national approach to digital identity". Hear hear!! #IDPolicyForum
In Australia, any mention of national approaches to digital identity as national infrastructure sadly gets bogged down in the spectre of a dreaded National ID. #IDPolicyForum
MyPOV: One way to position a national *approach* without scaring people with a national ID is to remember how retail banking is standardised. All bank cards work in an identical fashion but each is different. There is no single bank account. #IDPolicyForum
Read 8 tweets
4 Feb
Up next @RepBillFoster of the #FosterBill #IDIA2020 and his optimism for congress to make policy progress on #digitalidentity for American citizens. #IDPolicyForum
'90% of Americans have access to smartphones' -- @RepBillFoster #IDpolicyforum #digitalidentity #infostructure
Congress now overwhelmingly supports a national unique health identitifer (or at least overturning the ban on a health ID). Dealing with the opioid crisis is a driver. @RepBillFoster #IDpolicyforum
Read 4 tweets
29 Mar 20
@rohitprabhakar @rwang0 @fxrseen @drsubirsaha @neeraj @vfiorese_ @roxanasoi @hessiejones @AlaricAloor @sarbjeetjohal @MiaD @jrhunt @defcon_5 Thanks Ray for the recommendation. I'm not sure where to begin except to say I don't have special insights into public trust. I tend to agree there seem to be stereotypical differences between countries in the public's trust in government versus trust in business. -/2
@rohitprabhakar @rwang0 @fxrseen @drsubirsaha @neeraj @vfiorese_ @roxanasoi @hessiejones @AlaricAloor @sarbjeetjohal @MiaD @jrhunt @defcon_5 2/n: So the cliche goes that Americans distrust government but have faith in the invisible hand of the markets, and so they "trust" businesses more (shudder quotes are deliberate when we're talking in such broad generalizations). -/3
@rohitprabhakar @rwang0 @fxrseen @drsubirsaha @neeraj @vfiorese_ @roxanasoi @hessiejones @AlaricAloor @sarbjeetjohal @MiaD @jrhunt @defcon_5 3/n: Conversely continental Europeans stereotypically tend to trust governments more than business (and so when Iceland wanted to DNA-test the entire population for research purposes, compliance was pretty high; citizens trusted in the outcomes, and trusted in due care). -/4
Read 15 tweets
16 Jul 19
@Jo_Plays @bhaines0 @IdentityHutch @WomeninID @dgwbirch @windley @IdentityWoman @Libra_ What makes digital identity (call it "ID" here) so hard?

1. There's a always been this strong drive to make ID reusable, to reduce on-boarding friction, reduce accounts & passwords, save cost, even make money. -/2
@Jo_Plays @bhaines0 @IdentityHutch @WomeninID @dgwbirch @windley @IdentityWoman @Libra_ 2. Most ID initiatives (especially Federated Identity) are based on something of a false intuition. We look in our purses and see dozens of identities that all seem the same. -/3

[I'm dropping all @'s now to avoid annoying people]
3. I have dozens of cards and accounts all labeled "Steve Wilson" and it seems redundant. Can't I boil them down to one? No, they're really not the same identity. Each is a different relationship. -/4
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(