As Hannah Arendt, one of the foremost analysts of the rise of Nazism warned, lies destroy democracy. By tolerating a serial liar like Johnson the House of Commons has become a cancer eating away our democracy. We can have democracy or the lies and liars. We cannot have both.
When lies they become endemic they breed fear, distrust, cynism and apathy, they destroy people's ability to make reasoned political judgements, they divide us into warring groups unable to converse with each other. They push society into a politics of raw emotion & brute power.
To have a reasoned disagreement with someone, you have to agree with them about almost everything. If you disagree about too much, you don't have a debate, you just have a shouting match, the other person seems mad or plain evil. That's why lies are so dangerous politically.
The Putin/Trump/Murdoch/Brexit/ Tory axis have systematically sought to undermine the shared ground of truth which underpins democratic debate. They have worked to divide society into groups incapable of reasoned communication with each other.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ #WhitePrivilege It is not anti-racism that has caused white working class kids to perform badly at school, and it's cynical and divisive of the Tories to suggest otherwise.
But there is clearly a problem among a segment of the white working class. So some thoughts.
2/ Deindustrialisation has hit the working class hard. Employment patterns, communities and working class organisations have crumbled. Millions of stable unskilled jobs have disappeared and those that remain are often in the gig economy.
3/ Since the 1970s patterns of working class life that had endured for generations have disappeared. Many working class people have adapted and thrived in the post-industrial economy, but many others are struggling in a less stable economy that demands higher skills.
Bercow says the Tories have become “reactionary, populist, nationalistic and sometimes even xenophobic”, and that "people are sick of lies, sick of empty slogans, sick of a failure to deliver.’’
This is what Starmer should be saying - the plain truth about the Tories.
I like Starmer, he's decent and intelligent, but he is a hopeless leader, like a rabbit frozen in the headlights. He should be rallying Labour support on all sides of the party through an all-out attack on the Tories - and there is so much to attack.
Starmer acts like he's in a courtroom. He's very good at it. But politics isn't like that. It's about the relentless repetition of simple emotionally charged messages, and Starmer is far too polite and reasonable for that.
1/ Tory misrule is populist ideology in action. In populism the 'Will of the People' authorises an elected government to smash through laws, rules, norms or Parliamentary scutiny. In short it is elected dictatorship posing as an ideal form of democracy.
2/ The present outbreak of populist misrule in the UK has its root in Brexit politics when the Brexiters copied the Nazis in using a referendum victory to demonise those opposing or seen as hindering Brexit as enemies of the 'democratic will of the people'.
3/ Dictators stage & win votes, because democracy isn't just about votes. It's equally about the right to oppose, the rule of law and accurate information - all of which were cynically violated by the Brexiters & continue to be violated by the Tories & their media allies.
Andy Burnham urges UK to 'embrace' Brexit as 'new reality'
No @AndyBurnhamGM, Brexit damages the country, robs us of our Freedom of Movement and was obtained through the worst abuses of democracy in modern British history. Brexit is a crime. theneweuropean.co.uk/brexit-news/we…
Dear Andy Burnham, Labour cannot properly challenge Tory authoritarianism until it accepts that the Tory attack on our democracy began with the tsunami of Brexit lies and hate propaganda and Vote Leave's electoral fraud which robbed us of a fair vote.
Labour cannot properly challenge Tory authoritarianism until it accepts that after the referendum the Brexiters unleashed the fascist notion that the "Will of the People" overrides the democratic right to oppose and legal and Parliamentary checks on government power.
1/ Where Labour may be going wrong is by looking too woke. Labour was always a party that cared for ordinary working people. Its concern for minorities was always anchored in that care for the great mass of ordinary people.
2/ Labour was seldom the main force driving social liberalisation, but it didn't oppose it either, and when liberalising projects gained social traction Labour governments put the changes into law.
3/ Labour in the Corbyn years was often seen (perhaps unfairly) as being more interested in minorities than in the great mass of ordinary folk, and more interested in cutting edge ideas for social reform rather than in the concerns of ordinary people.
1/ Working class support for the Tories isn't just due to disorientated people in a fragmented society clinging onto tribal nationalism.
It's also because economic stagnation makes economics and politics seem like a zero sum struggle for resources between social groups.
2/ Economic and social change has disrupted the white working class more than any other large social group. They feel that as natives they deserve preferential treatment, and feel that the liberal-left focus on minorities betrays them.
3/ So identification with the bogus security and solidarity of tribal nationalism is augmented by a bitter white nativist resentment against a progressive politics that they believe puts them at the back of the queue.