Remote "learning" in 2020-21 was an abject failure in Texas school districts: tea.texas.gov/sites/default/…
Divided into quartiles, the more school districts were remote rather than in-person in 2020-21, the worse they did on reading and math tests.
In every category of STAAR Test achievement (Masters, Meets, Approaches, or Did Not Meet Grade Level), in every subject, in every grade, the more remote school districts had worse learning loss than the more in-person school districts.
If one were designing policies to intentionally weaken the long-term competitiveness of Texas students in the global economy, remote "learning" would be a great place to start.

These learning losses in math are statewide aggregates, but they're concentrated in remote districts.
In reading, the learning losses were not as severe as in math, but these numbers still don't portend great things for Texas students going forward:
Who needs writing, science, social studies, or history, anyway?

tea.texas.gov/about-tea/news…
Austin-area @EanesISD is the top-ranked school district in Texas, according to @NicheSocial and other rankings: niche.com/k12/d/eanes-in…

Eanes was not classified as fully in-person in 2020-21.

Let's look at STAAR test achievement in E.I.S.D.
I just grabbed the reading and math numbers from 3rd, 5th, and 7th grades in the interest of time and to keep it simple. Maybe other grades/subjects performed better. Who knows. You can look it all up yourself here: txreports.emetric.net

Failure was up in each category.
On the STAAR Test, third graders failing reading and math in @EanesISD doubled and more-than-doubled, respectively, from the 2019 test to the 2021 test.
On the STAAR Test, fifth graders failing reading and math in @EanesISD nearly-doubled and more-than-doubled, respectively, from the 2019 test to the 2021 test.
On the STAAR Test, seventh graders failing reading and math in @EanesISD increased significantly and more-than-doubled, respectively, from the 2019 test to the 2021 test.
Failure doubling in most categories is bad enough, but @EanesISD also saw the proportions of those mastering reading and math plummeting dramatically from 2019 to 2021.
On the STAAR Test, the percentage of @EanesISD third graders mastering reading and math fell significantly from the 2019 test to the 2021 test.
On the STAAR Test, the percentage of @EanesISD fifth graders mastering reading fell only a little, while the percentage mastering math fell significantly, from the 2019 test to the 2021 test.
On the STAAR Test, the percentage of @EanesISD seventh graders mastering both reading and math fell significantly from the 2019 test to the 2021 test.
What proportions of increases in "did not meet" scores and declines in "masters" scores are attributable to "the pandemic," generically?

What, more specifically, is attributable to lockdowns, shutdowns, closures, quarantines, remote/hybrid "learning," and even mask monomania?
Moreover, what role did @EanesISD's abrupt shift in focus toward Critical Race Theory play in its declining standardized test scores?
The numbers are clear.

Remote "learning" in Texas was an abject failure.

That some districts are still pressing ahead with it, again, in 2021-22 is completely absurd, but I suppose we do live in absurd times.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Will Franklin

Will Franklin Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @WILLisms

21 Jul
Although there was only one lonely, single, solitary randomized controlled trial on masks in the COVID era (in Denmark), we do have U.S. data from last year.

Turns out, the COVID results were better in mask-optional than in forced-mask schools.
The student infection rate in mask-optional schools was lower than in forced-mask schools during the past school year.

Forced-mask schools had higher infection rates in 10 out of 14 two-week periods, more dramatic peaks, and a higher average infection rate. Data here: https://statsiq.co1.qualtrics.com/public-dashboar
The infection rate for staff in mask-optional schools was lower than in forced-mask schools during the past school year.

Forced-mask schools had higher infection rates in 11 out of 14 two-week periods, a 3x higher peak, and a much higher average infection rate. Data here: https://statsiq.co1.qualtrics.com/public-dashboar
Read 29 tweets
1 Jun
It has been 91 days since @GregAbbott_TX announced that Texas would reopen "100%" with no statewide mask mandate.

At the time, there was much weeping and gnashing of teeth about it. Many predictions of impending doom.

Turns out, Texas was fine.
Sure, it's the day after Memorial Day, so this will go up this week, but Texas reported 94 new "cases" today.

In the whole state.

That's the lowest since March 23.

Of 2020.

Today's 7-day average: lowest since April 7, 2020.

Back when testing hadn't really ramped up yet.
If you want to zoom out a bit, here's what the cases look like since the beginning of 2021.

I still see some arguing for continued masking and restrictions because we're "in the middle of a global pandemic!!!"

No. We aren't. It's over.

The case for been over for a while now.
Read 21 tweets
25 Apr
46 days ago, Texas opened "100%" with no statewide mask mandate, 8 days after @GregAbbott_TX announced the new policy.

Blue checkmarks predicted the apocalypse.

It's now undeniably been long enough to declare that the apocalypse did not arrive. Instead, everything is better.
Since March 10th, when Texas reopened 100% with no statewide mask mandate...
✅Cases: DOWN 25.4%
✅Hospitalizations: DOWN 39.1%
✅% of beds used by COVID patients: DOWN 36.6%
✅% of patients that are COVID+: DOWN 35.2%
✅COVID ICU: DOWN 38.8%
✅Deaths through April 11: DOWN 70.4%
Cases (7-day statewide average per day) are:

✅Down 25.4% since Texas reopened 100% without a statewide mask mandate.

✅Down 50.6% since @GovAbbott made his announcement.

✅Down 88.2% since the January peak.
Read 15 tweets
23 Apr
It's been another two-and-a-half weeks since we last checked in with the Texas COVID-19 numbers. So how's it going?
It has now been 52 days since @GovAbbott made his announcement that Texas would open on March 10th, "100%," without a statewide mask mandate.

It has been 44 days since Texas reopened 100% with no mask mandates.

The promised apocalypse has apparently been postponed yet again.
COVID-19 "cases," hospital patients, ICU patients, and deaths have all fallen in Texas in the 44 days since Texas opened 100% without a statewide mask mandate.

Data from @TexasDSHS: dshs.texas.gov/coronavirus/Ad… The average number of daily...Fewer who test positive for...Fewer ICU patients who test...COVID-19 deaths are down in...
Read 15 tweets
5 Apr
It has now been 26 days since March 10th, when Texas "reopened 100%" with no statewide mask mandate; it has been 34 days since @GovAbbott announced the reopening.

So far, so good.

"Cases," positivity rate, hospital and ICU patients with COVID-19, and deaths are all down.
"Cases" are noisy, bouncy, and uneven, for a variety of reasons. Holidays and three-day-weekends impact the reporting. They're a mess. But they're down since Texas reopened 100%, according to @TexasDSHS data.

Next, let's look at the seven-day-averages to get a clearer picture.
The seven-day-average of Texas "cases" of COVID-19:

-DOWN 30.5% from the day Texas "reopened 100%" with no more statewide mask mandate.

-DOWN 54% from the day @GovAbbott made his announcement.

-DOWN 89% from the January peak.
Read 8 tweets
3 Apr
It has been 24 days since Texas "reopened 100%" and eliminated statewide mask mandates.

COVID-19 "cases," hospital patients, and ICU patients all dropped again today in Texas. ImageImageImage
With 1,250 "cases" reported today in Texas, the 7-day-average of "cases" = down 23.4% since Texas fully reopened without a statewide mask mandate.

Down 49.3% since @GregAbbott_TX announced it March 2nd.

The 7-day-average "case" level is down 87.9% from the peak back in January. Image
According to @TexasDSHS data, the number of patients in Texas hospitals who also tested positive for COVID-19: down 35.5% since Texas reopened "100%" without a statewide mask mandate.

Down 48.4% since @GovAbbott's announcement.

Down 80% from the peak. Image
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(