For those who came in late...

Ashoka was a Buddhist at least 2.5 years before Kalinga, as he himself admits in his minor rock edict at Maski, 260 BCE.

Hence, any views of him converting to Buddhism after seeing the carnage at Kalinga is an utter lie.
He uses the 'Buddha-Sakya' = Ordinary Follower of Buddhism in his edict at Maski.

The word 'Buddha-Sakya' in Brahmi
Ashoka, however, did not inherit, but was a convert to Buddhism.

Like his predecessors, he freely allowed the slaughter of animals in royal kitchens every day, prior to conversion. In fact, Ashoka did not become an absolute vegetarian, even after his conversion.
His meat diet was limited to the flesh of two deers and one peacock , even in 258 BCE; some six years after his conversion and though the deer was discarded later, it is not definitely known if the peacock was given up as well.
The list of animals and birds specified by Ashoka for protection in his Pillar Edict V, issued in 243 / 242 BCE does not include Peacock.

Similarly, he induldged in all kinds of royal parties and merry-making before his conversion. ( translation of a part of Pillar Edict V )
And he had been described in all texts as the one who killed his elder brother, Prince Susima for the throne.

Lastly, even as a Buddhist he didn't desist from a bloody battle at Kalinga, some 2.5 years after his conversion to Buddhism. This battle gave rise to 4 lac casualties.
Thus, no stories such as those anxiously invented by the Buddhist texts are needed to prove the miraculous power of Buddhism in converting an ordinary king into a saint.

The facts speak for themselves!

Source: 'Ashoka' by Dr. R. K. Mookerji

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with The Phantom

The Phantom Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @PrasunNagar

8 Aug
General Neil ( 1810-1857) was a notorious military officer of East India Company, who is remembered for his cruelty towards Indians.

At Kanpur, he ordered the Brahmins to lick the blood of Bibighar victims, had them whipped and hanged them from trees. Image
William Hodson (1821-1858), was a soldier of British, who shot to death unarmed princes of the last mughal emperor in 1857.

He left their bodies to rot at 'Khooni Darwaza' ( Bloody Gate).

He was shot dead at Lucknow in March 1858. Image
General Nicholson (1822-1857) was a soldier of British Army, who is remembered for his sadistic role in suppressing the events of 1857.

He has been called " The Great Imperial Psycopath" & " byword for brutality & racism." Image
Read 4 tweets
19 Jul
Ancient Battles of India

1. Battle of Mandsaur 528 AD

This battle was fought between Mihirkula & an allied army of Indian kings led by Yashovarman & Narasimha Gupta Baladitya.

Despite of not being a very famous event, this battle decided the fate of India for next centuries. Image
Mihirkula, ruling most parts of Central and Western India, since 513 AD, was a barbarian, who in the absence of Central authority created a vast kingdom & enjoyed wanton destruction.

These Huns destroyed the great university at Taxila as well.

Image of Mihirkula Image
Such was the audacity of these Huns, that after the death of Skanda Gupta, they again invaded India and occupied territories in North and in the West.

The terrorized the local Indian kings, & the populace, and extorted money from the Gupta emperors.
Read 83 tweets
14 Jul
Capture of Jerusalem by Crusaders

On 15 July 1099, the Crusaders captured Jerusalem from the Fatimid Caliphate, and thus brought an end to the first crusade.
In June 1099 AD, the Crusaders reached Jerusalem.

For them, it was like reaching the 'Promised Land', after three years of struggles.

Many soldiers wept at seeing the city and others prostrated themselves before the city where Jesus Christ had been crucified.
Jerusalem was a difficult city to besiege.

It was a large city with a garrison of at least 5,000 soldiers, including some light cavalry, and it's walls were 50 feet high .

The crusaders needed wood to make siege towers and ladders in order to enter the city.
Read 23 tweets
10 Jul
Siege of Antioch, 1098 AD, between Crusaders and Turks, led by Yagi Siyan.

After months of siege, the crusaders bribed a gatekeeper named Firoz.

They then entered the city, at night and massacred every Muslim, Jew they could find.
However, the Crusaders were themselves besieged by Karbogha, a warlord, who came to help the Muslims.

The crusaders tried diplomacy with Karbogha, but it was unsuccessful.

Their supplies were running out and they had only 200 horses left.
At this moment, a pilgrim named Peter Bartholomew came forward claiming to have had visions of St. Andrew, who told him that the Holy Lance was inside the city.

He along with some of his disciplines, went inside the church, dug up the earth and came out with rusty piece of metal
Read 7 tweets
30 Jun
Legend of Vikramaditya

The short thread would try and identify Vikramaditya, mention legends about him and would place him historically, in proper space and time.
Name:

'Vikramaditya' is a title and not a name.

Vikramaditya= Valour like the Sun.

And there have been plenty of kings, who have been identified with this title.

Let us describe them one by one.
Vikramaditya of Ujjain ( 57 BCE)

The earliest references to Vikramaditya is in 'Britha-katha manjari', however the book is lost and portions of it may be Gupta era interpolations, like in Katha-saritasagara.
Read 37 tweets
9 Jun
The Nanda Dynasty ( 387/382/365/345 - 322 BCE)

The Nandas were a dynasty of ancient Magadha, which created a large empire from Beas river to Odhisa.

They were exceedingly rich, powerful and perhaps the first Shudra dynasty of India.
Dates:

1) Vishnu Puran gives a date of 40 years of Nandas reign;

2) Matasya Purana gives 88 years ;

3) Tāranātha gives 29 years to Nanda dynasty.

Historians have given the dates which ranges from 387 BCE to 345 BCE.
Origins of Nandas : Buddhist Sources

Urgrasena Nanda or Mahapadma Nanda :-

The pali texts on the origin of Nandas present a glimpse on the origin of Nandas. His early life was quite romantic. Originally, he was from frontiers ( pachhanta-vasika).
Read 38 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(