Commons recall debate on Afghanistan: MPs will now sit for an extra 3 hours until 5pm today, as so many want to speak.
PM immediately bombarded with interventions. Asked by Tobias Ellwood whether he will agree to an independent inquiry into UK’s involvement in Afghanistan? Johnson signals no - “many of the questions have already been answered” - to heckles of anger from MPs on both sides.
Johnson says he spoke to UK ambassador in Kabul Laurie Bristow this morning: “The situation has stabilised since the weekend, but remains precarious. At the moment, the Taliban are allowing the evacuation to go ahead”.
In stark contrast to Joe Biden, Johnson praises Afghan security forces’ “bravery and sacrifice”. Adds: “We should not forget that thousands gave their lives”.
Johnson insists the West could not - and should not - continue the Afghan mission without American support. “I do not believe deploying tens of thousands of British troops to fight the Taliban is an option that would commend itself to the British people or this House”.
Johnson also insists there was no appetite among NATO allies to replace the US. But he’s pushed hard by MPs on how hard he really tried to build a new coalition. Theresa May asks him when he first spoke to Jens Stoltenberg about this. PM ducks a date to only say “the other day”.
Emotions running very high in the chamber. Dozens of MPs still trying to make their points to the PM on an array of issues. But Johnson has stopped taking any interventions.
Starmer accuses Johnson of a failure of leadership to mitigate pull out’s consequences, with NATO or as chair of G7: “The Prime Minister’s response to the Taliban arriving at the gates of Kabul was to go on holiday. You cannot coordinate an international response from the beach”.
Theresa May speaks after Starmer, and is also excoriating on the Johnson government’s failure to do more. “Was our intelligence really so poor? Or did we just feel we had to follow the United States, and on a wing and a prayer it would be alright on the night?”
More from May, on what will be one of the most powerful speeches of the day: “What message does this send around the world? What does it say about us as a nation? What does it say to our enemies? We boast about Global Britain but where was Global Britain on the streets of Kabul?”
Tom Tugendhat is the first Afghan veteran to speak, to a completely silent house. Powerful mourns the West’s collapse of will. “Let’s stop talking about forever wars. Peace is won over time. The tragedy about Afghanistan is we’ve swapping patience for fire, for a second war”.
Tugendhat finishes: “This doesn’t have to be defeat, but at the moment it damn well feels like it”. He sits down to spontaneous applause from MPs.
Another powerful speech from another Afghan veteran, Johnny Mercer, warning of "a bow wave of mental health challenges" to come. Demands more for all vets. "The Prime Minister has consistently failed to honour what he said he would do. He must not wriggle out of his commitments".
Tory MP Nusrat Ghani breaks down in the Commons as she reveals how Afghan women she has worked with are phoning her from Kabul to say "it's game over". Describes the pull out as "catastrophic, cack-handed, cruel and humiliating".
Summing up to end 7 hours of debate, Dominic Raab responds to IDS to say the UK Govt "tested very rigorously" the US’s plan to pull out when it was told about it. IDS actually wanted to know if Raab had asked the Biden administration to reconsider. Raab did not say he had.
Raab reveals the Foreign Office's rapid deployment team only finally arrived in Kabul "last night" - 4 full days after the ambassador and MoD began the evacuation.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tom Newton Dunn

Tom Newton Dunn Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @tnewtondunn

1 Sep
Raab at FAC: asked why he didn't do more to build a new coalition to replace the US in Afghanistan? A key question. Raab evades saying what personal efforts he made to insist it was never doable anyway. “Nobody was going to backfill the capacity that the US provided”.
Raab goes on to say Afghanistan has effectively been a failed mission for years. "At what point did we last have the military objectives identified and the exit strategy to achieve them?" Once it's realised it's a mission without end, the decision must be to pull out, he argues.
Tugendhat immediately hits back to ask: "What is the US’s exit strategy from South Korea?" Raab appears stumped: “I don’t know that”. But then insists the analogy is false.
Read 8 tweets
31 Aug
Dominic Raab appears before the Foreign Affairs Committee at 2pm tomorrow for a special session. Bitterly criticised for FCDO as well as personal failings, the bottom line is the Afghanistan debacle was on his watch so he will be fighting for his job. Here's what to expect (1)
Many of the questions MPs will put to Raab were put to Boris Johnson when Parliament was recalled, but still remain unanswered. They split into three parts. 1. The Past, and the almost total failure to prepare for the US pull out despite years of warning. Could the UK...(2)
...have stayed on by building a new alliance, and why wasn’t the hasty evacuation better planned? 2. The Present: what can be done now for the legitimate evacuees who didn’t make it out of Kabul? At least 1,000 are eligible under UK schemes but are still there. Many more...(3)
Read 10 tweets
17 Aug
Boris Johnson's statement to a recalled Parliament tomorrow on Afghanistan is a very big moment. He has huge calls to make overnight to define UK foreign policy in light of Biden's 'America First' paradigm shift. I've talked to MPs. Here are 8 questions they want him to answer:
1. What historical perspective will the PM overlay on why the 20 year mission ended in catastrophe? There is bitter Cabinet disagreement. Ben Wallace’s sadness over the West failing Afghanistan, or Dominic Raab’s proposition that nation building was long doomed?
2. How does he account for the dramatic Western intelligence failure that didn't foresee the Afghan government collapse so quickly that he and his Foreign Secretary were caught short on holiday? The failing that created this week's pandemonium and international embarrassment.
Read 11 tweets
5 Jul
Some interesting other measures in the Govt's Step 4 policy document that the PM didn't announce: QR codes will continue in pubs / restaurants, and if you're pinged you will still have to isolate - but premises will no longer be forced to display them, just "encouraged" to. Image
There is also a big safety net. Rather than irreversible, the roadmap is actually very reversible. Govt quietly reserving the right to impose "economic and social restrictions at a local, regional or national level" if NHS capacity is threatened. Local authority powers also kept. Image
A further safety net also quietly being kept in reserve: domestic vaccine passports - 'certification' - will be imposed if the NHS comes under heavy pressure in the Autumn / Winter. Image
Read 4 tweets
5 Jul
No10 press conference, Big Bang reopening at Step 4 confirmed. A summary:
- Almost all legal restrictions will end, and guidance will be moved to advisory
- No limits on social contact, no capacity limits at venues, all remaining businesses can reopen, including nightclubs
- Government's domestic vaccine passports scheme not going ahead
- No legal requirement for covid certification to enter any mass events
- Businesses / venues / grounds can voluntarily adopt a vaccine passport regime, and use the NHS app
- 1 Metre Plus rule scrapped
- All legal regulations to wear face masks scrapped, replaced by general health guidance but not specific about any sectors
- businesses or transport provides can still insist on face masks as a condition of custom
- Limit of 5 named visitors to care homes lifted
Read 4 tweets
14 Jun
Interesting conversations with two different ministers tonight. Both support PM’s caution in unlocking this far, but have serious concerns about how the July 19 delay now plays out. They (individually) make the point that cases + hospitalisations and, to a lesser extent, deaths…
…will rise further now sharply, and still be rising in 4 weeks time, but hopefully with a slower rate of incline once more second doses kick in. But they fear the PM will come under huge pressure from the CMO/CSA, Labour and opinion polls, not to unlock when numbers are still…
…pointing upwards, and hospitalisations are in the high 100s and deaths in high two or three figures daily. They wonder, if Johnson doesn’t unlock then, “when can we ever?” The answer, they say, is he will have to bite the bullet once and for all and declare a number of daily…
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(