Not spent much time on Twitter today.
Too much hate gets spread here - and not just from RW folks.
Everyone's obsessed with identity politics.
Hardly any talk of anything else (except for Govt handles).
Ofc if you're oppressed cos of your identity, it's only natural that you'll want to speak about it.
It's sheer privilege to suggest identity isn't relevant, when we see so much identity-based discrimination.
And yet I sometimes wonder,,,
Discrimination is at multiple levels.
There's deep-rooted discrimination in society.
There are discriminatory laws, reflecting society's mindset.
Yes, this is a battle that MUST be fought.
But there are other battles too.
Like poverty, lack of healthcare, lack of education.
Uplifting the living standards of the poorest of the poor might not seem such a priority for us, cos WE are not in those dire straits.
But for those who ARE (and there are millions) their concern is about how to get through the day.
Do we discuss this enough?
I'd like us to discuss much more about healthcare deficit in this country.
For example, about Ayushman Bharat.
What it does and doesn't do.
Why so many are out of its net?
I'd like us to talk more mohalla clinics.
Not just those in Delhi, but as a concept for the rest of India.
Just like it's (identity) privilege to be blind to identity-based discrimination, it's also (class) privilege to be blind to the suffering of the poorest of the poor.
A sensitive, and sensible, person would recognise, and care about, both.
Yet I find lots of people here talking abt identity-based discrimination, but barely talking about economic suffering of the poor.
Ironically, many of the discriminated groups are actually amongst the poorest of the poor.
So if you work on poverty alleviation, they benefit too.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Raja راجہ - awaaz do, hum ek hain

Raja راجہ - awaaz do, hum ek hain Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Raja_Sw

2 Sep
#Thread on grief.
When I got news that my friend had lost his 25-yr old son to Covid in June, I msgd him, saying "I'm here, call me anytime you feel like it".
A few days later, he called.
Spoke for an hour, giving me all details.
Crying most of the time.
I just listened. 1/n
All I kept telling him was "I'm here, anytime you want to share."
He sends me pics every now and then.
"This was on his last birthday."
Or msgs "He would've been 26 today".
He's always apologetic.
"I hope I'm not bothering you with all this".
I keep saying "No, keep sharing". 2/n
I've realised one of the best things is to just be there for a grieving person when (s)he needs you.
Not overbearing, but letting that person know you're there.
Ppl are sensitive ki "apna dukhda leke auron ko bore nahin karna hai".
They shd feel ok abt it.
They're grieving. 3/n
Read 15 tweets
31 Aug
I keep getting requests for donation help.
Mostly for medical help for little kids, whose parents are too poor to afford surgery.
Wasn't this exactly what the Govt's scheme was supposed to cover?
Or is there a catch?
So, after making a donation today, I thought I'd ask why the patient doesn't avail of Govt's scheme.
Reply:
"Sir, aisa nahin hai ki wo log apply nahin karte hain. Apply karte hain. Par unka koi na koi documents ki wajah se nahin ho paata hai, isiliye hum log ye case lete hain".
To get a quick sense of requirements to be enrolled for Ayushman Bharat scheme, I googled "Ayushman Bharat".
Official website -> pmjay.gov.in

Extremely helpful.
Read 6 tweets
31 Aug
You won't find me mocking any state in India.
UP, Bihar, whatever.
Mocking a state means mocking people who live there. Cos a place is nothing without its people.
Yes, I'm EXTREMELY critical of govts, and regressive thought in society.
These are what we need to fix.
Collectively.
As someone who always wants unity & communal harmony, why would I mock people of any state, and further polarisation in society?
As if we don't have enough divides already.
At the same time what I'd like is that we shed our egos, and honestly take stock of our reality.
It's a fact that some Indian states are better-off than others on various social & economic parameters.
There could be a whole host of reasons for this.
Why not analyse these - see what went wrong in some states, what other states did right?
Learn, and try to emulate success.
Read 13 tweets
30 Aug
You know the BIGGEST problem South Indians have with the Union Govt?
It's not just about feeling of unfair financial allocation, or that they're subsiding a bottomless pit elsewhere in India.
It's the feeling that they don't get RESPECT.
Hindi imposition is a big part of this.
Anyone who knows me here knows how fond I am of Urdu, Hindi.
And other regional languages too, even if I don't speak them.
So if anyone is going to accuse me of language bigotry, (s)he can take a hike.
I'm very clear where I stand on this subject.
All this talk about English "being a foreign language" and so "shouldn't be encouraged" is BS of the HIGHEST ORDER.
English is THE MOST IMPORTANT LANGUAGE in the world if you want to be truly international and mobile.
At least today it is.
Things might change tomorrow.
Read 21 tweets
11 Aug
If "studying on a mobile phone" was indeed the answer, why did privileged students study on a laptop?
Why were parents rushing to buy them laptops?
We all know a mobile phone, for all its wonderful features, is a poor substitute for a laptop for education.

But we're dishonest.
We're dishonest people - we ensured laptops for our children, but pretended that mobiles are good enough for education.
And since "most ppl have smartphones now anyway" (another lie!), even poor kids can continue their education despite lockdown (lie after lie!).
I'm SO ashamed.
We've let down MILLIONS of poor students by not providing them a meaningful alternative.
"Studying on smartphones" was NOT the way - and we KNEW it.
We just didn't CARE.
Cos OUR kids had laptops.
I'm SO ashamed.
No country for underprivileged students.

scroll.in/article/100234…
Read 12 tweets
10 Aug
The privileged in India, and their first-world conversations, while the underprivileged/marginalised get further and further crushed under the weight of oppression.
Other than a few activists, how many people have you seen talking about land-snatching from tribals, amongst the most marginalised of communities?
How many privileged folks talked about Hidme Markam's arrest by Chhatisgarh authorities?
We all live in the same country, no?
When it's the Olympics, we all come together, "India, India".
When it's a tribal woman, Hidme Markam, fighting for rights of her fellow villagers against land-grab, and getting arrested by the police, we don't want to have anything to do with her.
Cos she's underprivileged?
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(