The answer to both questions depend on a lot of factors.
- What water/mask are we talking about?
- What’s the alternative?
- What else do you have to drink/what else can you do to mitigate your risks?
- How thirsty/immunocompromised are you? 2/10
If the choices are wear a cloth mask that doesn’t work into a crowded indoor space or avoid the space altogether, I’d skip the crowd. 3/10
The only thing more dangerous than a parachute that never works is a parachute that works 95% of the time.
Just reliable enough so you might start to trust it to jump out of an airplane more than once. 4/10
Analogies always fall apart… 5/10
Masks and water and parachutes have similarities but are not the same. 6/10
I realized today I have fallen into a very illogical pattern of behavior:
I have a bunch of cloth, paper, and a couple of N95s in my car. I throw them in and go about my business out in public. 7/10
I have developed a very false sense of security.
Most of my safety comes from my complete vaccination.
I’d probably be smarter to navigate people, crowds, and indoor spaces more carefully and toss out my cloth masks. 8/10
Maybe the paper ones too. 9/10
I think the safest thing to do is wear a mask in public but act like you aren’t wearing one. 10/10
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Let’s discuss 3 facts: 1. You and your parents before you have been managing and balancing RISK v. DOING STUFF your whole life. 2. Over time your risk of dying of COVID will shrink beneath other risks. 3. We’ve been happily killing each other with infectious diseases forever. 1/
Like it or not (and style notwithstanding), this is the debate people like @VPrasadMDMPH and @drjohnm are trying to have right now.
I’m 45-54. You could easily reduce some of my TOP 10 risks of death by:
- outlawing cars: unintentional injury
- outlawing firearms: homicide, suicide
- outlawing tobacco and alcohol: liver/lung dz
There are 5 realms you will master if you want to be a good doctor. 5 bodies of knowledge about which we teach 3 in medical school. 1/
1. Diseases. You must learn their traits and character. Their prey and weaknesses. Their mimics and behavior. In some fields there are hundreds. In internal medicine we have tens of thousands. 2/
2. Bacteria and other infections beings. If you are an orthopod you will become an expert in staph aureus. OBs know Group B strep. Ophthos know that pseudomonas.
It’s weird to get to know some microorganism better than you know your neighbor on your block but you should. 3/