When the GOP cited “health freedom” to make opposition to pre-existing condition protections their mainstream view a decade ago, it became only a half a step away from today’s full scale embrace of anti-science, anti-health measures. 1/
“Health freedom” is one of those phrases someone cleverly arrives at because it sounds better than “full hospitals and portable morgues.” But its without a practical difference.
What exactly am I entitled to with my health freedom?
2/
It’s a big rallying cry for major candidates.
Scott Jensen in MN, Larry Elder in CA & JD Vance in OH are untalented even as politicians go.
So 10k likes from Russian bots and @Yolo304741 are all the encouragement they need to convince themselves they’re on the right track. 3/
This new wave of GOP politicians aren’t out to just follow Trump’s lead. To be truly great, they aim to sound as unhinged today as he did in 2016 when the bar was much lower.
So the rhetoric has a natural escalation. For MN’s Jensen opposition to the ACA is almost quaint... 4/
Vance & Jensen are calling for people to break the law. Jensen is now comparing himself to a Civil Rights leader in an interview with the @StarTribune.
Scott, don’t worry at all that no one sees that. Sometimes you’re the only one who knows your own greatness. 5/
The passionate voices of a few lunatics should never be taken lightly again. Thankfully Elder & Jensen are waking voters up.
We’ll never know whether people were happy with Newsom in CA because once Larry Elder entered the race it became a referendum on, well, being alive. 6/
One reason “health freedom” doesn’t deliver politically is that eventually Ayn Rand Libertarians eventually get sick too. Sticking with a movement through illness & death requires real commitment.
5/
When your spouse or child or parent is in the hospital with something serious, it’s not “freedom” we pray for.
We’re begging for medical science, resilience, healing care & the money to pay for it. 6/
When our “health freedom” IS really challenged, it’s not an overzealous government, but an overzealous virus or disease that’s the threat.
The followers of JD Vance et al end up in the same refuge that health freedom lovers have found over the last decade— the Gofundme pages.7/
Gofundme is the denizen of the hardcore “health freedom” followers who come face to face with their choices.
Gofundme caters to freedom fighters who turn out to be not so prideful that they don’t expect others to pay their medical care or funeral expenses. 8/
GOP politicians have it backwards.
We should be concerned over the role of government when it infringes on the ability of people to live their lives. But when government protects our ability to live our lives, it is wildly wildly seen as doing their jobs. 9/
Larry Elder’s race ended in embarrassment. Scott Jensen will follow the same fate. Even in Texas, Beto O’Rourke stands an outstanding chance of decimating Abbott.
Amazing how people will show up when someone tries to serve them a plate of dangerous bullshit. /end
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
COVID Update: The very unclear story of boosters will become clear.
I will try to sort it out. And attempt to be clear myself! 1/
The evidence for a booster shot is obvious for people as they age or are at risk. The immune response was lower to begin with & after 6 months vs Delta that adds up to risk of hospitalization. 2/
Boosters dramatically increase antibody levels. And the safety profile of the boosters is also pristine. No real side effects.
It’s a no brainer for everyone with immune system issues or a little, ah, age on them. How much age? 65? 60? 50? 40? Will get back to that. 3/
There are a lot of moving pieces. We are monitoring & the head of the FDA is coming on @inthebubblepod Monday.
Follow here if interested today for updates & explanation of what to expect. 1/
As background, the FDA meeting starts today and will hopefully end today.
The CDC will then meet to make recommendations on: age, time, mix-match recommendations, nursing homes, and more. I will address each of these.
It could be a full week before all that is ironed out. 2/
Let me start with where there is certainty & likelihood.
Americans over 65: the evidence says 3 things.
-Booster is safe
-Booster dramatically increases immune response, symptom reduction, hospitalization#
-Seniors have lower levels of immunity after 2nd dose
COVID Update: There is an amazing array of efforts, some not very visible, to tackle COVID.
If you want to know how COVID plays out, the variables are here. But there’s the fatal flaw: us. 1/
I can try to classify many of the efforts to address COVID as now (high impact progress we are working on now), med term (things underway but not immediate), and long term (potential big game changers). 2/
The now items are critical to saving lives today & reducing the odds of future variants.
Number one on that list is to vaccinate the majority of the globe by the first quarter. 3/
This chart is interesting.
What it says is that Delta is spreading within households (that’s what Secondary Attack Rate means) at the same level as peak flu season.
Note the increase over last September.
It implies at least 3 things we should try to understand better. 1/
First, kids are getting COVID at school and infecting family members.
Policies preventing schools from protecting kids are failing the entire family including seriously at risk adults. 2/
Second, household infections are going to grow over the Fall and early Winter without more layered interventions. 3/
COVID Update: Watching the reactions & meltdowns to the proposal that Americans are required to get vaccinated (or tested) to be around others.
There is so little actually controversial here but the sideshow is first rate. 1/
Real people by large majorities support vaccine requirements. We’ve had them for decades, even centuries with little controversy.
No governor has threatened to light himself on fire & blow himself up (until now). 2/
Like traffic lights, as inconvenient as they sometimes are, people are pretty ok with rules if they do things like keep kids safe, reduce deaths, and allow businesses to be open safely. 3/