A #marathon running project in drought-prone Marathwada has opened up the possibility of govt jobs for young women. As parents begin to view their daughters as economic prospects, one behavioural shift is that girls may be fed the same as boys. My story + fiftytwo.in/story/stamina/
Dowry remains a prevalent problem here: a doctor son-in-law costs about Rs 51 lakh plus a kilo of gold, a teacher Rs 10 lakh plus some gold. Higher education doesn't seem to pay off in terms of a dowry discount. On the other hand, sports offers more viable job prospects +
It also offers opportunity for extraordinary achievement. The second Indian woman to qualify for a track and field final at the Olympics is Lalita Babar at 2016 Rio for the steeplechase. A girl from a drought prone village in Satara, she became one of India's finest marathoners +
But the other side of this women's empowerment is the erosion of communities that the neoliberal marathon culture promotes. Marathons are corporate projects, embodying the takeover of our cities, our countryside, our lives with the designs of big money ++
Sport facilities like stadia or playgrounds are common goodwill projects that corporates mining natural resources in the countryside offer communities. In my travel across India, I've seen these oases of green in dusty smog-filled towns. It's lovely to hear the happy laughter +
of children playing, especially to see girls at play. Yet there is unmistakeable evidence of ecological devastation as big money travels deep into the countryside. It's hard then to weigh what is good: the happier lives of women or the impoverishment of communities +
It took me a couple of months to write this. And years to see the transaction, so to speak, between sport, community, nation and the capitalist impulse for profit
I've promoted this story a fair bit this past week. Thanks for your patience...it's a part of my book in the works🙏
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This week I had a conversation about end of life care with a physician. I've been thinking about it for years but unable to implement it as there are barely in doctors in Calcutta who talk death without intervention.
The few who do, do palliative care for cancer patients ++
Conversations about end of life care, in my experience, bring an uncomfortable silence, which carries the accusation that I am enabling the death of my patient, passive murder.
But the pandemic truly underlined the paucity of hospital beds in India. If an 80+ years old patient +
who has articulated a wish for a gentle death without intervention falls ill, why should they take up an ICU bed? It's a criminal waste of resources! Yet ERs in private hospital assign ICU care to geriatric patients as a matter of routine!
Geriatric care specialists are scarce +
5 Sept is a good day to remember Prof Jadunath Sinha who filed a case of plagiarism against Prof Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan in Aug 1929 for deriving substantive portions of his book Indian Philosophy Vol II from Sinha's Indian Psychology of Perception Vols 1 + II (image Wikipedia)
Radhakrishnan was one of the examiners of Sinha's thesis at Calcutta University along with Sir Brajen Seal. Sinha is reported to have been a brilliant student who won several awards including the Premchand Roychand studentship. Here's Sinha's Amazon page amazon.in/Books-Jadunath… +
Sinha sued for Rs 20,000. Backing his claim was the fact that Sinha had published parts of the theses he said Radhakrishnan plagiarised from in 1924 + 1926. Radhakrishnan sued Sinha back for Rs 100,000 ++
A good precis on the row: roundtableindia.co.in/index.php?opti…
It was 1940. The Olympics, initially meant to be in Tokyo, became the first edition of the modern Olympics to be cancelled; WWII was imminent. A 15-year-old Calcutta girl Ila Mitra missed being the first Indian woman at the Games. This is her story + thehindu.com/society/athlet…
The 1940s were to be a devastating decade for Bengal. The famine, officially declared in 1943, was evident from rural reports in 1940 itself. Churchill was Prime Minister. Mitra passed her Intermediate exams with a first class, enrolled in Bethune and plunged into famine relief +
Food prices soared so high, women were sold for sex to the soldiers parked in Calcutta for the eastern front of WWII. The Mahila Atmaraksha Samiti of the Communist Party of India was formed to protect women from being trafficked for sex. Mitra joined the CPI in college ++
A #Dalit "servant" girl is found dead in her upper-caste Delhi employer's home, family is not told about her death, police cremate her body forcefully, beat up Caravan reporter writing on it.
No front-page or prime time news about it.
But remember Devyani Khobragade' story? >>
One reason that story about an Indian woman being paid less than minimum wage in the US received HUGE coverage is the international case. But another equally important reason to my mind is that Khobragade is a Dalit reserved quota officer. Suchitra Vijayan doesn't say it but >>
I do. The anger about reservations in the coveted Indian civil service is huge. I hold no brief to defend Khobragade and I am not defending her. I am only asking, why such little news about a Dalit "servant" girl's death?
Here's @suchitrav's piece >> rediff.com/news/report/in…
I hear an inherent sneer when Indians, news orgs says: "Even Bangladesh's economy is doing better than India."
Why this "even"?
The polite way to see this "even" is that it is used because Bangladesh is a younger country, formed 24 years after India >>
The real reason Indians say "even Bangladesh" is because this country is seen as a nation of maids and rickshaw drivers providing the dirt cheap labour that keeps New Delhi, Mumbai, Bangalore and Calcutta running.
The real reason is also poor, lungi-clad, dark-skinned Muslims >>
"Even" is also used for Pakistan, but less so that Bangladesh. Pakistanis are fair-skinned, taller, more aristocratic.
In the popular imagination constructed by Bollywood, India and Pakistan are blood brothers severed by Partition. Indians can abide fair-skinned Pakistan >>
There's been a slew of editorials in prestige publications) about Bollywood's inclusive values and how Modi are destroyed it.
This is the wrong way of looking at it. Bollywood has always broadcast Dilli's politics. In the Nehruvian years, it was secular socialism >>
After Liberalisation, it was the NRI romance establishing Indian culture in global capitals. In the Modi years, it is Hindu pride in history and the muscular Hindu nation-state vanquishing terror in the capitals of Islamicate: Istanbul, Dubai, Tangiers, Kabul, Central Asia >>
Bollywood exists to broadcast Dilli (= central govt) narrative. Why else do you need a Hindi-language industry in a Marathi land with a Marathi industry?
I have written this in multiple essays. Here is a brief list. How nationalism took over Hindi cinema livemint.com/Leisure/b59Z5F…