Although it's obvious (hopefully) that the "Great Replacement" nonsense pushed by Tucker Carlson, Charlie Kirk, Matt Gaetz, et al. is racist to the core, it's also blindingly absurd on its face. Of course, those pushing it know their audience is too stupid to know this...(1)
The MAGA verse doesn't understand the forces driving demographic change, and millions of other folks don't understand them either, making them vulnerable to these white nationalist fears of "takeover" and a presumed conspiracy to make it happen...(2)
The truth of course is that "globalists" don't need to import labor from poorer countries into the "white West" when they can just export capital and do the work offshore...(3)
And for the Democrats to support bringing in immigrants in the hopes they'll vote Dem (after becoming naturalized--a process they can't begin for 5 years), or have kids who will (18 yrs later) is a pretty slow way to do a power grab...(4)
There are natural economic and demographic forces causing population shifts in the U.S. Nothing conspiratorial about it. In fact, ironically, it's the result of white Western dominance & disproportionate power/opportunity, as I explain here.
It's time for progressive parents to start showing up at these school board meetings and handing out giant paper snowflakes to the right-wing MAGA parents who are afraid to let their kids read books about MLK and Ruby Bridges, or who think masks are child abuse...Mock them. Daily
They should not be spoken to like adults or reasonable people They should be ridiculed, mocked, called out for their snowflake-like behavior, their cowardice to confront the truth about history or COVID for that matter...
They cannot be reasoned with. They should be treated like the broken brain people they are. Every time they shout laugh at them, point at them, make fun of them...
(1) The fact that there are people who still think the left should make common cause (around issues of class, the 1%, etc) w/the kind of people storming school board meetings in anger about masks, vaccines and anti-racist teaching is why the left is such a joke in this country...
(2)...they actually think we should build coalitions with openly fascist people, people who threaten violence against teachers and school board members over public health measures and books about MLK/Rosa Parks, all to "stick it to the billionaires!"...News flash:...
(3) These people don't hate the rich. They want to be them. The only rich people they hate are entertainers and rich Black athletes. They are not a constituency for progressive change, the revolution, or your stupid Leninist fantasies...
These parents in Southlake TX, forcing libraries and teachers to pull any books off the shelves about racism (historical or contemporary) unless they are "viewpoint neutral" are the face of conservatism: book banning authoritarians, and snowflakes at the same time...(1)
There is no "viewpoint neutrality." We all have perspectives. And those parents don't really want that anyway. They wouldn't want us to teach the Nazi side of WWII, or al-Qaeda's perspective on 9/11. They just want to silence Black people. And all "liberal" perspectives (2)...
All education is political. When you hold up the founders as heroes, without discussing their deep flaws as enslavers or apologists for slavery, you take a perspective. And it's an offensive one (3)...
(THREAD w/essay link below) The "Can Black People Be Racist?" question is among the most aggravating that most of us who do anti-racism work get from folks. But sadly, our standard answer (racism = prejudice + power) isn't particularly helpful, let alone convincing...
(2) Even though the underlying rationale for it is true -- that power makes bias more destructive and worthy of concern -- it doesn't follow from that that racism is ONLY systemic and determined by power dynamics. "Isms" are systems and ideologies...
(3) At the systemic level, racism doesn't require prejudice, making the above equation false. And at the personal, ideological level, it doesn't require power, also making it false...
Why are people so stupid? When Bill Gates said better health care and vaccines could reduce population growth he didn't mean "reduce population," or "hey, we should use vaccines to kill surplus people." The fact I have to explain this is pathetic, but here goes...(1)
...First off, if he DID think that, and was part of a conspiratorial plan to make that happen, do you think he'd say that in a public forum like a TED Talk, which is the accusation here? That's not how conspiracies work y'all...(2)
...Second, his point was rooted in an accurate understanding of how population growth works. Fact is, when life expectancy is lower in a country & infant mortality is higher (due to disease, famine, lack of vaccines, etc), folks have more kids to replace those who sadly die...(3)
A not-too-long (but important) thread on the right's war on history & memory and what it's really about
When you ask a conservative why they think we should leave confederate statues & monuments up they usually won’t say it’s because they agree with the confederate cause. (1)...
Indeed that’s the point where they remind you the confederates were Democrats. Then they say something like: we shouldn’t erase history, we should learn from it. They never explain what you can learn from a statue, but OK, what's the implied lesson they're speaking of here? (2)..
Presumably, it’s that yes, there have been people who supported awful causes in our history, like enslavement—which was indeed the chief reason the South broke away—and we should remember that so as to a) not repeat past mistakes, and b) recognize our progress (3)...