This is your daily pension announcement: the mailbag edition! Or, at least, the inner workings of pension policy edition. 1. First question, was something like why did @ewsiddall start his chat yesterday by going on about living in Edmonton? #ABLeg aimco.ca/insights/first…
Well, that is a bit of a sore point with the GOA. They have, in the past, been embarrassed to find out that they have hired high profile execs that have "commuted" (Ahem, no names) from Toronto or other cities.
So it was important yesterday to put "Alberta" in AIMCO. #AbLeg
2. Second question was something like "what is the worst thing that Travis has said?"(I am assuming about pensions)
Well there is a bountiful garden of stupidity to choose from. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
I would take yo back to his Nov 26, 2019 Op-Ed. I have attached the last paragraph. If you looked up stupid in the dictionary you might find this quote and his picture. How did the brain trust let this out without a proofread? #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
In this paragraph Travis tells us that he will lower contribution rates for public sector pension plans.
Travis does NOT set the contribution rates for the plans. The trustees do. He shat on the 12 years I spent poring through actuarial reports setting rates. #ABLeg
Travis tells us that he alone, the bargain shopper, can save the plans money.
Each one of these plans is responsible for finding the most cost effective solutions. Not Travis. In fact, he has made it very evident that he has little understanding of ATRF. #AbLeg
And, Travis tells us that he alone can deliver benefit improvements "if possible" again neglecting that he is one of two sponsors that must negotiate such things.
Travis represents the sponsor that, in the case of teachers, contributes less than 50% to the cost of the plan.
This has remained a gold star level of UCP gaslighting that we have become so familiar with.
With one paragraph he misstated the legal framework in AB, and denigrated the volume of work the plan trustees have done. #ABLeg#handsoffmypension
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This is your daily pension announcement: here is the video of Evan's first Heritage Fund appearance. Great first half of the year but don't forget: 5 year return 8.2% 0% over the benchmark. (Target would be 1.0% over.)
CIO Dale is retiring. So the executive team will only have 2 members (I think) that have been at AIMCO for more than a year. I remember the first time I met the AIMCO executive team. A bunch of them were fired the week after. (Leo was CEO at the time.) #ABLeg#handsoffmypension
Accountability and transparency are great themes for @ewsiddall. Those are things that have been lacking. Kevin had some backroom deals going on with the UCP. You can't have that with an "arms-length" manager. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️notes that Evan is the new Kevin! Take a look below at the deep cut interview below. "I'm going to lead differently" is a good start because the last guy really sucked! #handsoffmypension
I will not needlessly disparage Evan. Ever. But, given my experience on the ATRF Board, if I see injustice I will speak out. I will restrict my comments today to a couple of things. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
To quote: "Siddall — who pledged to keep a lower profile in his new assignment".
This is a really good idea. Nothing galvanized the anti-AIMCO forces better than Kevin's self serving Op-Ed in the Journal complete with a come-hither photo. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
This is not true. Please read the MacKinnon report. We have a bargain basement system second lowest cost in the country. (BC=lowest) AB would be the lowest if we did not pay private schools and provided less transport. #AbLeg
My analysis: to use the "one of the best-funded" would mean in the top 3 out of provinces. MacKinnon showed us we were nearly the bottom and falling further as enrollment⬆️and inflation erodes. #ABLeg
This is your daily pension announcement: throwback to the World Bank Group's case study on the much vaunted (and rightly so) Canadian Pension Model. You can access the paper from the article below, but be warned it may be TL:dr and too much Kevin. #AbLeg optrust.com/AboutOPTrust/N…
This paper is from 2017, before any of the crazy UCP/AIMCO stuff. But it gives you insight into the things that Travis did to weaken pensions in AB. Strap in, this is going to be a long ride. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
1. "Because of their success, the World Bank Group partnered with four Canadian pension funds, Alberta Investment Management Corporation (AIMCo)".
Er, yeah. AIMCO is not a pension fund. They are an investment manager, a service provider to pension funds if you will. #AbLeg
This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️ notes that Travis writes another op-ed for the Journal. It is filled with the typical lies and misrepresentations of the equalization referendum. Don't read it. It is a waste of time. #AbLeg
Do take a look at the end note:
"This byline information was changed at the author’s request to reflect his capacity as MLA instead of as finance minister and president of Treasury Board."
Why would Travis need to write this as an anonymous MLA instead of as a Finance Minister?
Well, funny you should ask. I suspect it is because the loyal and hardworking servants at Treasury Board and Finance are embarrassed by Travis and his facile arguments. They have provided Travis with no research on equalization. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
This is your daily pension announcement: I will again direct your attention to what Canada's preeminent pension expert has to say about an Alberta Pension Plan.
It is a stupid idea based on the underwriting risk alone. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension kpa-advisory.com/policy-papers/…
Defined benefit pensions are all about risk management. A point that is not well understood by the sellers of the APP "vision". Simply put, since the APP would be so much smaller than the CPP premiums would have to be more since the fund has less ability to absorb shocks. #ABLeg
These shocks might be investment (think financial crisis) or experience (think people living longer). But either way the plan needs to be structured to be able to deal with these risks. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension