Among the many damning details in this @DavidLat interview with Trent Colbert: other members of the Native American group chat had liked his messages using "trap house." If the term had racial connotations, Yale's Native students weren't aware of them.
@DavidLat "I had been calling our house the 'NALSA trap house' for months before this incident. I had been calling it that in messages with other NALSA board members for months, and nobody had said anything to me about it."
@DavidLat A friend of Colbert's, also interviewed by Lat, alludes to an important point: the internet has sped up the pace of memetic evolution to such a degree that a 3-4 year age difference can completely change how one uses and perceives certain slang.
@DavidLat Colbert: "Nobody reached out to me before filing their complaints...I received one message two days after my original invitation was reposted into the class GroupMe. By that point, I had already been reported by at least nine students to the [Office of Student Affairs]."
@DavidLat Colbert's friend: "I really admire Trent’s courage and willingness to say, 'Maybe this will be painful for me, but the potential effect on the whole climate in our society could be far worse than what I’m going to endure—so someone needs to stand up, and that someone is me.'"
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
NEW: Yale Law administrators are doing damage control as faculty members slam the school's dishonesty—and as students continue to go after Colbert.
One YLS professor told the school: "Please correct the record—I would not want to have to do it for you." freebeacon.com/campus/convuls…
Today, YLS dean Heather Gerken promised an investigation into the controversy. YLS told the Free Beacon that this investigation would not result in any further action against Colbert. "As our statement last week made clear, this is protected speech," a YLS spokesperson said.
The law school's statement, released Oct. 13 in the wake of my Free Beacon story, denied that Colbert faced "any disciplinary investigation" or action over his email. That denial sparked fierce blowback from two YLS professors who lambasted the dishonesty of their own university.
Some people have claimed that my article left out crucial details that exonerate the Yale Law administrators. This excellent follow-up from FIRE shows that, on the contrary, the added details is even more damning. Let's walk through some of them: 🧵
The administrators "repeatedly reference[d] their administrative roles — the need to produce a final 'report' to the university’s administration, the possibility of a 'formal recommendation' for bias training"—and "at no time" assured the student his speech was protected.
"Even if Colbert was being deliberately provocative"—and there is no reason to think that he was—"his speech is still protected by Yale’s explicit promises of free expression. But those policies were no obstacle to Yale administrators."
Administrators at Yale Law School spent weeks pressuring a student to apologize for a "triggering" email he sent out. Part of what made the email "triggering," the administrators told the student, was his membership in a conservative organization. 🧵freebeacon.com/campus/a-yale-…
The second-year law student, a member of both the Native American Law Students Association and the conservative Federalist Society, had invited classmates to an event cohosted by the two groups. Here is what the student wrote in an email to the Native American listserv:
The student is part Cherokee, the Indian tribe that was forcibly displaced during the infamous Trail of Tears.
Within minutes, the email elicited furious accusations of racism from his classmates, several of whom alleged that the term "trap house" indicated a blackface party.
SCOOP: Students at one of the oldest and most prestigious boys schools in the United States could soon face expulsion for a single "misplaced" joke, according to a draft "anti-bias" policy obtained by the Washington Free Beacon.
Long seen as a conservative holdout among private schools,
St. Albans is considering a crackdown on "harmful" speech that prioritizes the impact of the speech rather than the intent of the speaker.
"It is the impact of hate speech, rather than the intent of those perpetrating it, that is of utmost importance," the draft policy states. As such, boys could be expelled "even in the case of a single expression, act, or gesture"—including "misplaced humor.”
James Zimmermann was the principal clarinetist of the Nashville Symphony Orchestra for more than a decade—until he was fired last February over allegations of racial harassment.
What happened to him, and to the orchestra, would soon happen everywhere. 🧵
To hear his accusers tell it, Zimmermann had insulted, intimidated, and even stalked his black colleagues, going so far as to menacingly drive by their homes. But six of Zimmermann’s ex-colleagues and the orchestra’s own documents tell a very different story.
They suggest that Zimmermann himself was the target of a witch hunt, instigated by a black oboist whom Zimmermann had stuck his neck out to help.
They also suggest that the orchestra lied about Zimmermann's disciplinary record in order to justify firing him.
Some scientists are now arguing we don't need boosters because the vaccine remains effective against severe disease. But those same scientists have spent months warning that Delta necessitates a return to masks and social distancing—even for the vaccinated.freebeacon.com/coronavirus/cr…
The scientists from the WHO and FDA who weighed in against boosters this week have consistently opposed lifting public health restrictions in the face of new variants. But that guidance that seems to contradict their argument about the mildness of breakthrough cases.
The vaccinated "need to continue to wear masks," the World Health Organization's chief scientist, Soumya Swaminathan, tweeted in August, adding that the Delta variant "demands that."