Another week, Another #IPThursday. Sorry its late, life happened. This week we take a quick look at the “Sun Jam” case recently decided by the Zim Supreme Court.
Our story this week takes part in a Teapot country formerly known as the bread basket of Africa, Zimbabwe. Why did I just mention that we were the bread basket of Africa?
Well because its important to set the scene, just so we all understand the importance that Zimbos attach to certain food products.
You see, after independence in 1980 (maybe before then too), led by Mugabe the country would export a lot of goods to the world, this included corn, wheat, tobacco etc. and for the most part local products dominated the shelves, and we didn’t need to import as much as we do now.
The result of this was that Zimbabweans grew significantly attached to certain local products. This is important, because even during an economic crisis that has lasted over 2 decades, Zimbabweans still prefer their original products over foreign imports.
The most common examples are probably Mazoe, Cerevita and snacks such as Thingz, Jupiters and Cheesies. If you’re visiting anyone wherever you are and see all this in their cupboard, just know they are likely a Zimbo or are dating one or have an ex from Zim!
It does not matter where in the world a Zimbo is, they will find a way to have these products shipped to them. It may be nostalgia, but I think they are just high quality goods and they taste really good.
One of these is a very popular mixed fruit jam called Sun Jam. Produced by Cairns Foods, it is probably the most popular jam in the country and has been around for over 65 years. My grandparents, parents and myself probably all grew up on it.
It is made from sun ripened fruits which are hand-picked from the Eastern Highlands of Zimbabwe but like Mazoe, I think it is definitely laced with some sort of drug, it is really that good.
Its in every rural or town households, whether you’re having your bread on metal Kango or enamel Le Creuset plates. As a result, Sun Jam is easily one of the most recognisable and longstanding brands in the country. Who can forget this brilliant ad!
So in 1995, Cairns registered the trade mark of a logo which consists of the word “SUN” with various fruits under it. When the mark was registered, Cairns entered a disclaimer for the use of fruit images.
For those who don’t remember….when you register a trade mark, the Registrar can ask you to enter a disclaimer against the non-distinctive elements of your trade mark.
This just informs the public that you do not claim rights to that non-distinctive element and other people are free to use it in relation to those goods. Cairns had only agreed to enter a disclaimer on the images of fruits and not the word “Sun”, this will be important later.
This brings us to the next party in our story, a company called Netrade Marketing. I’m not sure when exactly they were established but in 2011, they registered the trade mark ROYAL SUN in class 29 in relation to a wide range of products including jam.
Eventually, probably around 2017, they moved into the Jam market and came up with a logo which said ROYAL SUN and the words “Mixed Fruit Jam” at the bottom.
Cairns wasn’t at all happy about this, and in August 2017, they dragged Netrade to court for trade mark infringement and passing off. Cairns argued that the use of the mark by Royal Sun in relation to Jam together with the words “Mixed Fruit Jam” was likely to cause confusion.
In fact, Cairns had evidence that one of their merchants had ordered the Royal Sun jam by mistake, thinking it was the Cairns SUN JAM.
The High Court compared the two marks and didn’t agree with Cairns, they looked at the marks and held that the marks were not similar and there was no confusion or infringement.
Their view, was that Cairns did not have monopoly rights to the word SUN, they held that their rights were in the representation of the mark/logo as a whole and they dismissed the application with costs.
Cairns wasn’t happy with this ruling and decided to appeal the High Court judgment at the Supreme Court. They felt the High Court misdirected itself on a number of issues. Reading the claims, they basically said the Court had no idea what it was doing.
In a judgment written by Justice Mathonsi, the Supreme Court agreed with Cairns and basically blasted the High Court. In one sentence, referring to the High Court’s decision that Cairns did not have rights in the word SUN.
Mathonsi J said, and I quote good people, “In fact, such a factual finding could not possibly be made by a court applying its mind to the facts.”
His words, not mine! They considered some SA case law and other principles of trade mark law and found that the word “SUN” is in fact a prominent feature of the trade mark.
What was disclaimed, was the use of a fruits image. Anyone using the word “SUN” in relation to Jam in Zimbabwe, would likely be guilty on an infringing on the SUN Jam trade mark.
The test for infringement which was applied by Mathonsi J and whether there is confusion is simple really. You have to put yourself in the shoes of an “average” customer leisurely doing shopping.
In my head, I always pretend the average customer is my Dad doing the shopping, my mom might a bit be too attentive to be an average customer.
You have to ask yourself, would the average consumer pick up ROYAL SUN jam thinking it’s the popular SUN JAM if they came across it in store. If the answer is Yes, then there is confusion and and infringement.
In my opinion, it goes without saying that the word SUN is the distinctive part of the trade mark. Any other Jam manufacturer in Zim who uses that word is likely trying to infer an association with Sun Jam.
Sidenote: Cairns was represented by @BrendaMatanga ‘s firm. I think they’ll be a more in depth post on their website about this case soon!
Big Lesson: When thinking about whether there’s an infringement, always consider the average consumer. If they would confuse the later mark for the earlier one, then there’s an infringement. ❤️💛💚

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Uncle Sena ™

Uncle Sena ™ Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @senamisomoyo

19 Aug
Sorry for the wait good people, life ya know! Welcome to another week and another #IPThursday! This week we’ll do one on one of the most infringed trade marks in the world. The adidas 3 stripes.
I’ll start our story in the very beginning, as far back as the 1st World War…..Well soon after the 1st World War, with this man Adolf…..Dassler. Not the most famous Adolf. Although after WW1…….Dassler joined Hitler’s Nazis for WW2.
Anyways, thats besides the point. After WW1, Dassler decided to start producing shoes. He got his little brother Rudolph to help him out. I really should get my lil brother or sister to help me out with these threads too….
Read 28 tweets
18 Mar
Its #IPThursday again good people. Sorry for missing last week, but we’re back to regular programming. This week we take a look at the Harry Potter lawsuits.
Our starring this week, is Joanne Rowling. Born on 31 July 1965, she is one of the best selling authors ever.
She was born and raised somewhere in England, in a county whose name I’m lazy to type. Growing up, one of her high school teachers said se was bright, but not really exceptional. She took up English at A-Level and of course, she killed it. Got As in the process.
Read 35 tweets
25 Feb
By popular demand. Its #IPThursday. This week we look a look at the IP issues surrounding the #JerusalemaChallenge. Can Warner Music sue the people who took part in it?
The star of our story this week is Kgaogelo Moagi, but you probably know him by his stage name “Master KG”. Born on 31 Jan 1996 in a village close to Tzaneen in Limpopo, he is one of the biggest artists in South Africa.
I had no idea he was this young, but then it me...96s are 25 this year 😭😭😭. Siyaguga.
Read 38 tweets
3 Dec 20
Its #IPThursday again good people! This was one also requested a lot. Its the story of how the Polo you wear in South Africa is fake. Well maybe fake is harsh..... just not from the original company.
Meet Ralph, Ralph Lifshitz, or as we have come to know him, Ralph Lauren. Ralph was born and raised New York City, the youngest of 4 kids and your typical last born.
In his college years, Ralph pursued a career in business but he dropped out after two years, something only a last born would dare try to do.
Read 19 tweets
2 Dec 20
I love what Daliwonga and Kabza are doing with these samples of old songs. Truly brilliant 👏🏾🎶
If she doesn’t know this she’s too young for you. 😂😂😂😂🔥🔥🔥
Ndofaya 🔥🔥🔥🔥🎶🎶🎶
Read 4 tweets
26 Nov 20
Its #IPThursday again good people! This week we go through the story of how two brothers “stole” some trade marks belonging to Apple Inc. This is all about the little ways of exploiting trade mark law.
If you’re familiar with these threads, you know we start from the very beginning. The year is 1976, in a garage somewhere in a California surbub, three men Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak and Ronald Wayne.
The three tech geeks wanted to create a computer. Wozniak or Woz, as they called him was slightly ahead of the curve. He hand-built the first computer, the Apple 1. So in order to fund this project, they all committed to selling some personal assets.
Read 28 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(