Chancellor says this Budget does not “draw a line under Covid” still “challenging months ahead”.... But he says “today’s Budget does begin the work of preparing for a new economy post Covid. The Prime Minister’s economy of higher wages, higher skills, and rising productivity”
Chancellor says OBR predicts average inflation of 4% over next year and the “pressures caused by supply chains and energy prices will take months to ease. It would be irresponsible for anyone to pretend that we can solve this overnight”
Chancellor says UK will reach pre covid GDP level at the turn of the year - which is 6 months earlier... and growth revised up from 4% to 6.5%... growth next year lower from 7% to 6% - then settles at 1.3-1.6%
Long term scarring of pandemic - OBR assumption down from 3% to 2% which gives extra room for manoeuvre for Chancellor... unemployment also forecast to peak at 5.2% much lower than expected...
Fiscal Rules - 1. underlying public sector net debt must be declining as a percentage of GDP by third year of forecast 2. Borrow only to invest, taxation must cover day to day spending...
Unsurprisingly, Chancellor meets booth fiscal rules he has just set
“Borrowing as a percentage of GDP is forecast to fall in every single year. From 7.9% this year to 3.3% next year, then 2.4%, 1.7%, 1.7% and 1.5% in the following years”....
That compares with March figures of 10.3%, 4.5%, 3.5%, 2.9%, and 2.8%...
Sunak delays the PM’s target of £22bn innovation spending for 2024 by two years...
From 2023 R&D tax credit will have to be for investment in the UK, at the moment £48bn is claimed, but total business investment is only £26bn... should repatriate investment into the UK, as other countries do...
Flights between airports within the UK will have a lower rate of air passenger duty from April 2023... lowering tax on carbon emitter ahead of COP - but ultra long haul will be charged more
“We will retain business rates” he says after review, rejecting Opposition push to abolish it. Says revaluations will happen every 3 years - tax break against it for green investments in solar panels...
1 year 50% discount for business rates for retail, hospitality and leisure to reflect pandemic hit...
“Fair and affordable pay rises” for public sector workers under the normal pay body process... says the Chancellor - confirming the £9.50 national living wage...
Chancellor takes on the rise in the tax burden - says he doesn’t like it... but cant apologise for it
Sunak: “My goal is to reduce taxes - by end of Parliament I want taxes to be going down not up - that is what we believe - that is my mission...”
Universal rate taper cut by 8% to 55% - which was IDS original plan... will be brought in in December, a £2bn targeted tax cut, reversing a third or so of the impact of the £20 reduction in Universal Credit...
Spending as a percentage of GDP stabilises at 41.6% of GDP in 24/25 - higher than pre pandemic, highest sustained level since 1970s...
Taxation/ GDP is at its highest level since Clement Atlee’s post war Labour Government - up to 36.2% of GDP
Inflation forecast - look at this hump....
OBR says the Chancellor has “smaller headroom” than most previous Chancellor’s mandates - though none of those previous mandates were met...
0.6% of GDP on debt target (£17.5bn)
0.9% on current budget (£25.1bn)
Clip from interview with OBR chief Richard Hughes:
“This Chancellor has raised more in tax in 2021 than any Chancellor has ever raised in a single year since 1993, when it took two Chancellors, Lamont & Clarke to raise as much”
NEW OBR’s Richard Hughes on Brexit -
“so far the data that we've seen on impact of Brexit, especially taking into account fact new trading arrangements came in in January is broadly consistent with assumption we had, which is that it would reduce our long run GDP by around 4%”
To be clear this is Government’s official forecaster pointing out initial evidence from trade data is consistent with their forecast 4% hit from extra Brexit trade barriers..
OBR’s Hughes confirmed “in the long term it is the case Brexit has a bigger impact than the pandemic”
4% has long been OBR forecast of the hit from post Brexit trade barriers with Europe, what is new now is that is double the forecast long term hit of the pandemic, and they see some initial actual data of the fall in UK exports to the EU, and UK export intensity as consistent
... in full report OBR says while initial data is consistent with a 15% fall in the UK’s import and export intensity its too early to be “definitive” because the TCA is yet to be implemented in full, and the full effect will take several years & difficult to disentangle pandemic
free trade agreement meant no taxes on trade, known as tariffs, but it did involve introduction of what is known as “non tariff barriers”, which are more important in modern trade, things like regulations, massive paperwork, customs delays, checks etc.
HT to @benedict_king for asking the question to the OBR - and other ones including the quote on the taxation levels... difficult to argue that the OBR is not acting independently with analyses such as that. Document is a goldmine of interesting analysis - more tomorrow.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Chancellor speaking to Andrew Marr... says there will be “investment across the board” in public services on Wednesday - suggesting some top ups to those unprotected areas set for immediate further squeezes
Marr asks Chancellor if workers should take PMs words and ask their bosses for a pay rise... he points out that real wages are higher than pre pandemic, concludes “in order to make it sustainable we must invest in skills”
“Believe me I wish I didn’t have to raise taxes” Chancellor says to Marr... also articulates the argument I wrote about last month - that the income tax rise would have to be 2p in £, whereas with NI its 1.25p for both employers and employees...
On comparative Covid picture - interesting thing, noticed by pretty senior UK officials too, about being in Washington DC last week, was it felt like being transported back to UK early spring.
Everyone wearing masks indoors, many outside too...
And just whole town feeling empty
DC has broadly comparable vaccination rates - partial - 72% vs 73%, full 60% vs 67%... but completely different in relation to opening up. Goes to show what many economists stressed - lifting lockdowns is one thing, people to have confidence to end voluntary social distancing too
There are relatively few people able to make such comparisons because ordinary travel to US from UK still just about banned until November, we were allowed under State Dept exemption...
Perhaps its consequence of POTUS focus on caution/ masks etc ...
NEW
Hastily deleted Govt Net Zero research paper, suggests
🍖 shift diet habits to plant based & producers/retailer tax on high carbon foods
🌱 policy “to normalise plant based food”
✈️ make in person meetings requiring biz flights “immoral indulgence” bbc.co.uk/news/business-…
Government swiftly, deleted & disowned “BEIS Research Paper Number 2021/063” written by the Nudge Unit, aka the Behavioural Insights Team famous for sugar levy and “herd immunity” comments...
source: “We have no plans whatsoever to dictate consumer behaviour in this way”
Govt say was never policy, was part of range of inputs into Net Zero strategy considered, but then did not make it into policy... and shouldn’t have been published.
But it shows what influential team say is necessary as regards a Government “nudging” consumers towards net zero
Treasury net zero review is very interesting, in green terms, but also as a mere statement of strategy - eg openly pointing to poor UK productivity performance, in the last few years again the worst in G7 for investment, having been overtaken by Italy...
*Levelling up* code alert - will green policy on cars eventually subsidise wealthy Tesla-drivers in cities, & punish less well off drivers who stick with petrol/diesel for longer, Treasury muses to itself....
Also the £30bn elephant in the room known as “VED” or road-pricing...
Also this translated -
We’ll have to tax gas more and electricity less, because although electricity is now very low carbon/ renewable, we load all carbon levies on to it rather than tax the actual carbon in gas.
But right now after the gas price quadrupled to a record? 2022!
Food & Drink Federation chief Ian Wright tells MPs hospitality inflation is running at 14-18%, which is “terrifying”, says it is a precursor to retail, relays story from the 70s of supermarket prices rising twice in a day… says we can’t go back to that…
“says inflation is bigger scourge than anything else esp for levelling up because it discriminates against the poor…” first part about shortages on shelves - said seasonal produce, traditionally given top place on supermarket aisles replaced by lynx deodorant as that’s available
FDF also broke down the different dynamics of labour shortage, in particular the hundreds of thousands of EU workers WITH settled status, who have nonetheless gone home and not returned (so not a Brexit issue on its own, but In combination with pandemic/ lifestyle changes etc…
NEW French finance minister Bruno Le Maire said he discussed with Chancellor Rishi Sunak at IMF about how supply chain crisis “more difficult” for Britain outside Single Market. He told me “when you ask for more truck drivers.. single market helps facing these bottlenecks”...
In interview with me in DC, Le Maire also said G7 discussed replacing supply chains stretching to China, Taiwan and Korea and rebuilding them in western democracies “building these new value chains among partners among friends has been one of the solutions discussed within G7”
Le Maire reflected that President Biden sounded “Gaullist” in his speech this week saying the US would “never again” become overly reliant on one country or one person for supplies. “I'm a Gaullist. So, I’m fully supportive to that kind of approach...”