A new, rigorous and important study of Covid transmission—with or without prior vaccination—in 621 people with mild infections
Just published @TheLancetInfDis thelancet.com/lancet/article…
Vaccination reduced spread, but it still occurred in household contacts (unvaxx 38%, vaxx 25%)
Viral load was assessed from 8145 respiratory tract samples for up to 20 days, irrespective of symptoms
The peak load (Delta variant) was similar for unvaccinated vs vaccinated cases, but faster clearance in the latter
All breakthrough cases were mild
From the accompanying editorial thelancet.com/pb-assets/Lanc…
“This study unfortunately also highlights that the vaccine effect on reducing transmission is minimal in the context of Delta variant circulation”
This is what a real breakthrough infection report should look like. Thanks Oregon oregon.gov/oha/covid19/Do…
People < age 60 are not "immune" from hospitalizations and deaths
J&J>Pfizer>Moderna
Currently ~1/4 of cases
We still do not have this for the US, let alone most states
In contrast, the US has only posted such data once, now 2 months outdated, and represent only ~30% of the country covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tra…@CDCgov
If the US ever produced and published an up-to-date, informative report, it would be a real breakthrough
Hello @HHSgov@WHCOVIDResponse@CDCgov
2 new @NatureMedicine papers
First from half of US public school data
"Schools can open for in-person learning during the pandemic with minimal contribution to sustained community incidence of infections, provided other public safety measures are adopted." nature.com/articles/s4159…
2nd from Japan
"We do not find any evidence that school closures in Japan reduced the spread of COVID-19." nature.com/articles/s4159…
Young children, age 5/6-11, and vaccination dose of mRNA
Pfizer used 10 μg in their trial of 2,270 children w/ 90.7% efficacy vs symptomatic infections
Moderna used 50 μg in their trial of 4,753 children
Wondering about this 5X mRNA dose; both trials small for v rare side effects
Another issue:
We have learned that vaccine dose spacing 8-12 weeks induces a better immune response than short (3-4 week spacing). Why hasn't this been incorporated in the new trials and roll out?
The event curve for symptomatic infections in the age 5-11 Pfizer trial presented at FDA today (2 doses given, 3 weeks apart) fda.gov/media/153513/d…
The 1st randomized trial of a booster (3rd) shot in 10,000 people, placebo-controlled, shows 95.6% efficacy, with 5 cases (Pfizer vaccine) vs 109 in placebo group, Delta variant, broad benefit across age groups ft.com/content/d4e58d…
Until now there were only vaccine effectiveness reports without randomization, without a placebo control group, and multiple potential confounding factors. That’s what makes this trial report significant proof of benefit of booster shots, at least for this vaccine regimen.
Current booster recommendations. They are going to need to be revised.
Yesterday the FDA Advisory committee recommended that the 15 million Americans who have had J&J vaccines, more than 2 months out, get a 2nd shot.
There are some significant issues with this that could have been prevented /1
By May 1, there were over 8 million people 5.5 months out
By June 1, the number rose to nearly 11 million people 4.5 months out
Yet data have consistently been showing attrition of protection vs infections for this vaccine, this week in 620,000 US Veterans /2
This is the only Covid vaccine that was positioned as "one and done." J&J is the largest healthcare company in the world, yet research to back that up was undone until recently.
Single dose: 70% protection vs symptomatic infection
2-dose: 94% protection /3 fda.gov/media/153129/d…