We profile Luciana Gouveia & her impact story as part of our 25th anniversary celebrations. Read thread👇 on how Luciana & team used the JBI approach to implementation to improve mothers’ experience of childbirth through evidence-based intrapartum care. #WeAreJBI
Abuse & disrespect in childbirth care has been deemed a public health issue in Brazil. Many studies have documented the prevalence of discriminatory & hostile attitudes in childbirth care.
Only 5.6% of Brazilian women have normal births without inappropriate & excessive invasive (often not informed or consented to) interventions during vaginal birth, eg the Kristeller manoeuvre, often leading to poor obstetric outcomes.
Luciana Magnoni Reberte Gouveia is a professor in the Department of Maternal-Infant & Psychiatric Nursing, at the University of Sao Paulo School of Nursing.
The midwifery & nursing professionals, residents & students at the obstetric centre of the teaching hospital where Luciana taught were dissatisfied with the care they were providing to women in labour.
‘Women must be the protagonist of their own birth experience, & the teaching & learning process should take place in a respectful environment for mothers & babies’, says Luciana
Luciana used the JBI PACES audit & feedback tool to conduct a baseline clinical audit measuring 20 evidence-based criteria for best practice intrapartum care.
She then applied the Getting Research into Practice (GRiP) approach to: evaluate baseline audit findings; identify barriers & enablers to evidence utilisation; and develop & implement strategies for change.
Initiatives introduced as part of Luciana’s evidence implementation project included training & education activities for 30 nursing professionals, such as the ‘Game of Values’.
This activity comprised exercises in empathy & dialogue based on human values such as equality, respect & dignity, and nurses reflecting on how they practiced those values in daily care.
Nurses were also able to reflect on their beliefs that hindered optimal intrapartum care. ‘In relation to the lack of acceptance by the medical team for humanising childbirth, in my head I didn't think I was committing obstetric violence, I thought it was helping.’
Values were practiced in different situations in caring for women during childbirth. Employing the Game of Values in this way motivated nurses to adopt & implement the evidence-based practices taught in training, leading to significant improvements in intrapartum care.
The follow-up audit demonstrated improvements in care, eg use of the partograph during labour increased by 20%; women being offered pain relief increased by 40% and mothers and babies being given skin-to-skin contact increased by 21%.
‘The success of this project was an important step in furthering the collaboration and commitment of the health professionals in the obstetric centre to humanise the childbirth experience for mothers and deliver optimal intrapartum care’, says Luciana.
Overall, intrapartum care compliance has been maintained at >75%. The evidence implementation project has resulted in efficient & sustainable practice change. It also indicates that nurse midwives are able to improve quality of care for women & newborns.
🧵Globally, migrant nurses and midwives make up a significant proportion of healthcare workers, and trends indicate an exponential rise in #nurse & #midwife migration globally. #JBIEBHC 1/8
The @WHO healthcare workforce report predicts a shortfall of ~ 6 million nurses by 2030 2/8
Many countries rely on nurse and midwife migration to manage their shortfall of healthcare professionals 3/8
🧵In hospitals, paediatric patients aged 1-3 are at higher risk of falls, with most falls occurring from an inpatient bed in the presence of a caregiver #JBIEBHC 1/6
JBI Evidence Summaries bring together world-class evidence in a single, easy to read summary crafted by review experts and are found in the JBI #EBP Database wolterskluwer.com/en/know/jbi-re… @ovid_wkhealth
3/6
On #IND2022 we reflect on JBI’s origins as the ‘Joanna Briggs Institute for Evidence Based Nursing’ and the continuing importance, 25 years on, of evidence-based nursing research and clinical practice #JBIEBHC 🧵 1/7
Quality healthcare services require that clinical decision-making in #nursing is based on evidence, particularly in standardising and aligning healthcare practices with evidence at the point of care. JBI was founded by Emeritus Professor Alan Pearson to address this very need 2/7
‘When I was involved in setting up JBI in the 1990s, #EBM was increasingly adopted across the world, but #EBN was in its infancy. Since then, JBI has played a stellar role in developing great models and systems to support the implementation of evidence into nursing practice' 3/7
Read this Tweetorial on relative ranks for methodological quality assessment by Jennifer Stone, Research Fellow in the JBI #EBHC Research Division, for #JBImethodology month 1/7
Did you know that there’s an alternative bias assessment method for primary studies in meta-analyses and systematic reviews that does not require reviewer judgments? 2/7
This approach uses relative ranks that are based on quality counts.
#Qualitative evidence synthesis seeks to provide an understanding of meanings, practices and processes associated with social experience, behaviour and culture 2/10
Qualitative evidence synthesis involves the identification and synthesis of qualitative studies to provide insights related to a focused question 3/10
A/Prof Edoardo Aromataris gives key points on umbrella reviews in this tweetorial. #JBImethodology
With the ever-increasing number of systematic reviews and research syntheses available to inform topics in healthcare, SRs of existing reviews, or #umbrellareviews, are increasingly being conducted to summarise a broad scope of issues related to a given topic.
An umbrella review is also ideal in highlighting if the evidence base around a topic or question is consistent or if contradictory or discrepant findings exist, and in exploring and detailing the reasons why.