Hard to avoid noticing that the relationship between cases and deaths in the UK has not been severed, but nor has it been constant. The big delta spike in July had relatively few immediate severe consequences, that's no longer the case 1/?
The most recent data are showing a decline in case counts (when was the half term break?) and a slackening in the pace of hospitalizations, but it is clear that even if things slow (at least temporarily) the country is still in a bad place headed into the winter 2/?
Obviously the consequences of infections depend on who has been getting infected - even vaccinated older people are at higher risk than unvaccinated younger people (who are themselves not at zero risk. And even rare outcomes can add up when enormous numbers are infected) 3/?
and they have been, especially in schools. 7% or so of high schoolers infected for the last several weeks! This is the consequence of opening schools without mitigations. In contrast schools have been fully open in my town in MA since early Sept with no large outbreaks (yet) 4/?
Kids can also transmit and so lead to infections including breakthroughs. I just eyeballed the data from the @ONS and there are not obvious differences in the age distribution of deaths between now and July. But it does look that there are more serious breakthrough infections 5/?
So best guess right now would be waning of protection in older age groups. Can't get boosters into them quickly enough. Of course we should not ignore that this is happening when there is a very high force of infection in the community which will continue to pose a risk 6/?
Worth noting that you don't *have* to have a high force of infection. Where I am right now there is about 1/5th the daily incidence. This has been a choice. Once more the @GOVUK tried to blow the final whistle on the pandemic only for the virus to force extra time 7/?
The UK did an excellent job vaccinating in the face of the B.1.1.7/Alpha surge. As a result until recently those huge case numbers have not been coming with concomitant costs. But that is changing. 8/?
Like @jsm2334 says there is also AY.4.2 on the scene which is another part of the mix. This variant has mildly increased transmissibility (looks like about 10-20% more than regular delta) but… 9/?
The most recent technical briefing has not found an association between AY.4.2 and more severe outcomes. Caveat - there are lots of things that get in the way of estimating this accurately. Need to account for age, vaccination status etc. 10/? assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/upl…
eg if AY.4.2 is mostly in younger people, you expect less severe disease in that age group. Watch for the next briefing as sure we will get better data. It's not like there's a shortage of infections to study 11/?
This was longer than I expected. In closing I just want to say that with all this 👆🏼and the perennial foot dragging of the @GOVUK this move shouldn't come as a surprise 12/end theguardian.com/world/2021/nov…
ps might have time to write something later about what "vaccine plus" might look like, but gotta dash now

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Bill Hanage

Bill Hanage Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @BillHanage

22 Oct
The situation in the UK right now is complicated, with increasing cases while vaccines keep the very worst consequences at bay. However that makes no difference to the status of this as a contender for the most stupid statement of the pandemic bbc.com/news/uk-politi…
I wear masks at work unless alone in my office. Compliance is pretty good though not universal all the time. These are people I know. There have been no outbreaks there as yet. And we would know as we are all tested weekly
While I am at work I see people I know. Their ability to infect me is not altered by my knowing them. Most infections will be by someone you know
Read 4 tweets
14 Oct
A short 🧵 about the value of rapid tests. As long time followers will know, a runny nose is not very informative for me because I have allergies, and they have been playing up recently. I had three -ve PCR tests, but a worsening of symptoms over the weekend had me anxious... 1/?
even worse, I was visiting (vaccinated) friends and hanging out indoors and unmasked. You might think that epidemiologists are safer than most to hang with, and I could think of no known exposures, but I couldn't escape the (irrational) sense that fate has a sense of irony 2/?
After all, the prevalence is not super high here but I have been riding city buses, going to work etc and while it's not like I've been attending illegal raves (those days are past) I have been venturing indoors. So my persistently runny nose had me a bit 😬 3/?
Read 9 tweets
1 Oct
This fascinating article from @dylanlscott clearly draws out how those who sought to belittle the risk early in the pandemic have wound up embracing ineffectual and dangerous alternatives to vaccines, even as the virus keeps killing vox.com/coronavirus-co…
Key line: "people have still proven quite capable of shaping and reshaping a narrative that doesn’t require them to admit they might have been wrong." And sadly this includes a small but vocal minority of scientists you'd hope would know better
The protection of vaccination should be extended to all those who want it, and that *includes* giving people accurate information, from a trusted and trustworthy source, that helps them make the right choice
Read 10 tweets
15 Sep
When I see statements like this, especially now, I wonder what people mean by "the overwhelming of [healthcare]"

We shouldn't talk about healthcare being overwhelmed, we should talk about it being compromised or otherwise damaged, in a way that could have been avoided 1/?
Healthcare is compromised when elective surgeries are canceled, when screening is canceled. It is compromised when we run low on ICU nurses because they are needed in too many places or because they are sick with a virus 2/?
It is compromised when campaigns against scourges like malaria, TB or polio are damaged because of an uncontrolled pandemic 3/?
Read 5 tweets
6 Sep
Some more thoughts prompted by this article - the notion of an 'end' to the pandemic is itself faulty in my opinion. But that emphatically does *not* mean interventions forever. It means that the transition to endemic disease can and should be managed 1/?
The reason 'end' is dangerous is that it suggests a date when everything changes overnight and we return to 'normal'. That takes no account of variants, waning immunity or the fact that most of the world is struggling to access vaccines, among many other things 2/?
However in vaccinated places it is true things are *much* better than they easily could be, but that doesn't mean the pandemic is 'over'. This is Oregon and Idaho *now*. 3/? nytimes.com/2021/09/06/us/…
Read 12 tweets
3 Sep
I follow twitter less than you might think, but I have noticed a trend for people calling themselves "covid centrists". I find this difficult because it suggests a spectrum between extremes. I'm not a covid anythingist, I am just a scientist
This means I think about claims based on the evidence for them as I understand it. If you ask me what I think will happen if we take a particular action, I can tell you that.
That means I also need to admit when things don't go as I expected. For eg, while I expected (and publicly predicted) a dent in the rate of increase in the UK as the schools closed, before transmission resumed. But I was surprised by the scale of the drop. Now about that...
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(