The ability of the governor to put this particular sort of condition on the grant of clemency could (and possibly will) be challenged, but courts definitely have allowed certain conditions to be placed on grants of clemency in the past.
This is one of the wildest conditions I saw in my earlier clemency research. Nixon’s authority to do this never, ultimately, got resolved by SCOTUS because Hoffa disappeared.
The specifics of the Oklahoma Constitution, Oklahoma laws, and state court precedents would control most of this discussion — up to the point where someone (Jones?) challenged the federal constitutionality of Oklahoma law permitting such conditions (if it is found to do so).
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
So, my summer was great (until I got Covid), and I’ve really enjoyed doing project-based work, from columns to speaking to podcasts and beyond. Now that I’m recovered from Covid and back from my (wonderful!) Paris trip, I’m trying to get things a bit more organized going forward.
I am a legal expert, having written about the Supreme Court for 20+ years. I have deep knowledge of LGBTQ and criminal justice issues, government and politics, and media and journalism. My expertise ranges from in-depth process issues to real-world effects on people everywhere.
In short: If you are looking for an expert in any of these ares, I’m your person! I love creative work, too, so do think creatively about how I could be used — writing, editing, speaking, analysis, strategy, teaching, etc.
An amici brief from DC and other territories and states questions the federal government's position that you can discriminate against states so long as you meet rational basis:
There are others who know even more directly how offensively ahistorical this is, but, suffice it to say, this is complete bullshit: There was an entire infrastructure of laws passed and policies implemented stigmatizing people with AIDS — some of which still exist!
"For more than 20 years, people living with HIV or AIDS needed look no further than the United States' front door for a reminder of the stigma associated with their disease." abcnews.go.com/Politics/unite…
"The FDA initially banned gay and bisexual men from ever giving blood in 1983, then revised the lifetime ban in 2015 to a year's sexual abstinence." nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-ou…