#SupremeCourt is hearing a batch of petitions from women army officers seeking to be granted permanent commission in the Indian Army
@adgpi #permanentcommission
@adgpi #permanentcommission
Justice Chandrachud: till when did the Unit assessment scheme hold fort?
Sr Adv V Mohana: till 2005
DYC J: How many candidates got selected based on this UAC. If we were to replace UAC like HC said what alternate method of appraisal should we direct?
Sr Adv V Mohana: till 2005
DYC J: How many candidates got selected based on this UAC. If we were to replace UAC like HC said what alternate method of appraisal should we direct?
Mohana: they are saying the consideration is only for that period. Out of 4 petitioners, they have done meritorious
SC: Have their case been re-considered in the light of our judgment?
ASG Sanjay Jain: after this plea was filed, we saw the marks its in the range of 55.
SC: Have their case been re-considered in the light of our judgment?
ASG Sanjay Jain: after this plea was filed, we saw the marks its in the range of 55.
ASG also places the counter affidavit before the court.
Sr Adv Huzefa Ahmadi: you had directed overall assessment to be taken and not stop at 5 to 10 years. these officers also have ACRs and so way was to evaluate the ACRs and check if they score above 60 percent
Sr Adv Huzefa Ahmadi: you had directed overall assessment to be taken and not stop at 5 to 10 years. these officers also have ACRs and so way was to evaluate the ACRs and check if they score above 60 percent
Ahmadi: UAC was introduced as an appraisal mechanism from 1999 onwards. army had noted that the efficacy of UAC had to be reviewed. #supremecourt #permanentcommission
Ahmadi: the counter does not deal with this specific part of the issue highlighted
Mohana: tribunal and HC proceeded as if the officers have been discharged and nothing remains
Mohana: tribunal and HC proceeded as if the officers have been discharged and nothing remains
DYC J : Why dont you (centre) and Col Bala take into account the updated records since you did not take into account their record after 5th and 10th year. This is with regard to all fairness shown by you #supremecourt #permanentcommission
DYC J: We are not saying ignore UAC but please look into the ACRs. if they have subsequent ACR which is outstanding then dispensing such officers will be such a disservice to the army and the nation #supremecourt #permanentcommission
ASG: In a lighter vein the coverage we receive in media is also very disheartening
DYC J: It all boils down to judgment since these are just dialogues. #supremecourt #permanentcommission
DYC J: It all boils down to judgment since these are just dialogues. #supremecourt #permanentcommission
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
