I hate engaging in these conversations about people with large platforms who make trans people's lives miserable & more precarious. In all my despair & anger over the current landscape of course I do not want anyone else to be in danger. But let's talk about precarity....
Trans people are facing so many systematic and interpersonal assaults on their existence. From violence at home, in the street, in employment, shelter, health care. The rates of unemployment, homelessness, poverty set off a cycle leading to criminalization & premature death.
Hating us and devoting your life to exacerbating those conditions is a choice. Being trans is not. Or if it is, I choose it every day because the alternative is unimaginable.
In over 35 states in the US in 2021, lawmakers introduced bills to make trans survival harder. In Arkansas, the state passed a law banning health care for minors. We are now on appeal defending our lower court win blocking this insidious law.
I spent the last week reading briefs defending this law. Defending the idea that we should not be who we are. That we should not get health care. That we should not survive. An institutional, systematic, death threat - made by the government, supported by a global campaign...
...leveraged against young people. Not against billionaires. Not against adults with time to debate our existence. Against Kids trying to survive in a world that tells them over and over that they should not.
There are briefs from parents of trans kids saying they want their kids to suffer, states saying they want our health care banned, "medical providers" claiming that we will never live full lives. This is animated & legitimized by the rhetoric of powerful voices on these platforms
We feel so stuck, so unable to navigate and fight back and it is excrutiating and then somehow those who hate us become the victims and we are left to fight for survival in a world that not only exacerbates our suffering but then uses our suffering to claim we deserve more.
You are not protecting us from ourselves, you are not protecting children, you are weaponizing your own fear that the world is more nuanced than you imagined and using that fear to try to stop people from finding survival, joy, and possibility.
We are about to face another onslaught of attacks compounding generations of attacks and yet we find ourselves having to carefully mediate our rage and pain because that rage and pain will be shoved in our faces as a justification for our eradication.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
So what happened today in the UK with trans legal rights and why does it matter? Some quick thoughts!
As part of a well-funded global movement attacking trans people, our bodies, our rights, and our healthcare, a challenge was filed to try to stop the National Health Service’s ability to provide gender-affirming care for trans minors.
Last year, a High Court decision in the UK effectively put a halt to care for trans minors across England and Wales. The decision claimed that gender-affirming care warranted unique intervention by the courts.
Flying down to Arkansas for court on Wednesday in @ACLU's challenge to the state's prohibition on gender-affirming care for trans minors. Here are some things that the state and its experts argue in defense of the law (with fact checks):
That most trans kids ultimately "desist" and end up cis.
FACT CHECK: Nope. They are distorting data about pre-pubertal kids (and that data is also flawed). But once reaching puberty, almost no trans-identified minors ultimately come to identify as cis.
That gender-affirmation makes kids trans.
FACT CHECK: Nope. You can't make someone trans and you definitely can't make them cis by denying affirmation.
For everyone who is outraged about what happened to trans people in Arkansas, there is still time to help us stop these cruel and senseless bills elsewhere. I am going to provide an action plan below. #ProtectTransKids#LetKidsPlay
Tomorrow, West Virginia will be voting on HB 3293, a bill barring trans people from sports. If it passes the Senate tomorrow then we will need a veto from @JimJusticeWV. Call lawmakers in WV now.
Yesterday Florida advanced another anti-trans sports bill. We need to contact lawmakers in the Florida Senate to make sure they do not advance SB2012/HB1475. These bills are so cruel and dangerous.
Arkansas's HB1570, which could become law next week, is unlike any piece of anti-trans legislation that has ever become law in the United States. It will strip kids of their needed health care and prohibit insurance coverage for trans people of all ages.
If it becomes law, it will likely set off a chain reaction and could encourage Alabama to pass it's FELONY ban on health care for trans youth (SB10/HB1), which could be voted on next week as well.
I don't know what to say at this point. We are talking about cutting cuts off from ongoing treatment that we know to save their lives. We are talking about embedding in law the policy norm that being trans should be prevented.