Thread by @BillyBostickson

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed I guess you concede that your rmap is just plain wrong, after being totally deconstructed by @danwalker9999

https://twitter.com/danwalker9999/status/1461591621749772292

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 who also exposed the propagandistic essence of the map and figures used by your colleagues, Holmes et al in their tedious cell paper, replete with errors:

https://twitter.com/danwalker9999/status/1439367442430451720

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 In fact the rising number of critiques of your paper and that of Holmes et al in Cell, is evidence of serious problems in both logic and substance.

See here:

zenodo.org/record/5517659…

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 and here for your recent paper:

https://twitter.com/jbloom_lab/status/1462231887670235140

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 and here an anonymous critique (not mine):

https://twitter.com/BillyBostickson/status/1463536793756729348

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 Another recent critique of your paper by @quay_dr

zenodo.org/record/5717589…

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 @quay_dr Back to the Holmes et al Cell Paper

zenodo.org/record/5106841…

that effectively spawned your recent paper

it has been hammered constantly on many fronts:

By @Rossana38510044 in a thread here:

https://twitter.com/Rossana38510044/status/1413001207136858121

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 @quay_dr @Rossana38510044 Yet another excellent and thorough critique by
@aychan here (12th July) of Holmes et al:

A response to “The Origins of SARS-CoV-2: A Critical Review”

ayjchan.medium.com/a-response-to-…

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 @quay_dr @Rossana38510044 @aychan Some more deconstruction of Holmes et al here:

researchgate.net/publication/35…

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 @quay_dr @Rossana38510044 @aychan and my own humble contributions:

Straw Lab argument:

https://twitter.com/BillyBostickson/status/1412874776620666881

https://twitter.com/BillyBostickson/status/1414088847957250051

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 @quay_dr @Rossana38510044 @aychan The straw mouse claim (N501Y) by @stuartjdneil

https://twitter.com/BillyBostickson/status/1416322485151145984

https://twitter.com/BillyBostickson/status/1416322887741370368

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 @quay_dr @Rossana38510044 @aychan We need to call out the infiltration of “fake news” into scientific journals & the utter failure of editorial discretion & peer review to stop it.

The very core of science is under attack, and if nothing is done, the public will rightly lose faith in the scientific community

@MichaelWorobey @stuartjdneil @ScienceMagazine @franciscodeasis @Drinkwater5Reed @danwalker9999 @quay_dr @Rossana38510044 @aychan unroll Worobey and Holmes et al critiques @threadreaderapp