OK - it's US v. #GhislaineMaxwell trial Day 6, beginning with Judge Nathan ruling on the admissibility of exhibits and, Inner City Press hopes and has requested, the unsealing of court filings storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.usco… Inner City Press will live tweet, thread below
Now before the jury comes in, Judge Nathan is reading rulings on exhibits.
Judge Nathan: The pictures on the wall [of Epstein's massage room] risk prejudice and distracting the jury. They should be redacted. The other photos, of vibrators, the court will exclude.
Judge Nathan: I will also exclude the photos of the "creepy animals" Jane testified to. The tigers, for example, are high idiosyncratic. The school girl uniforms may be admissible, depending on the testimony.
Judge Nathan: For exhibits the jury has, the public should get the redacted version.
[But why did Judge Nathan not rule on Inner City Press' request to unredact exhibits, instead only docketing the letter in order deny a call in line? storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.usco…
Judge Nathan: So when the jury comes out, what would you like me to tell them?
Maxwell's lawyer: That the parties have reached a stipulation about the last witness and that to not to call him back we will read in the stipulation.
AUSA: Uh, could we have a sidebar?
Judge Nathan: Bring the jury in. [Then] Please be seated. You may recall the last witness from Friday, they parties have a stipulation. Mr. Everdell?
Maxwell's lawyer Everdell: It is hereby agreed by US Attorney Damian William and Maurene Comey etc of counsel and Ghislaine Maxwell that the witness would have said that the cardboard box was found in the closet of a guest bedroom had items unopened. Def Exh B.
Assistant US Attorney: The government calls "Kate."
Judge Nathan: The witness testifying under the name Kate may come forward. [Adds notice to sketch artists to not be accurate.]
AUSA: Jurors should pick up there binder and turn to Exhibit 16, under seal.
AUSA Pomerantz: Kate what's your work?
Kate: I work with women who are victims of trauma.
AUSA Pomerantz: What did you do before?
Kate: I was a musician and singer.
AUSA: How did you meet Ms. Maxwell?
Kate: I had a boyfriend who introduced me to her in Paris.
AUSA Pomerantz: When did you next see Ms Maxwell?
Kate: A few weeks later. I went to her home for tea. I saw a photo of her with a man with salt and pepper hair.
AUSA: Did you find out who it was?
Kate: Jeffrey Epstein.
AUSA: So where did you meet Epstein?
Kate: At Maxwell's townhouse. She invited me over. Jeffrey Epstein was in sweat clothes speaking on the phone very loudly. Maxwell told him I was surprisingly strong for my size. He asked for a massage; he said he liked it.
Kate: Then Maxwell told me that the massage therapist had canceled and that I should give him the massage since my hands were too strong.
AUSA: Did she comment on how often Epstein needed massage?
Maxwell's lawyer: Objection - leading.
Judge Nathan: Sustained.
AUSA: What was Epstein wearing?
Kate: A robe. He took it off.
AUSA: What was he wearing under?
Kate: He was naked.
AUSA: Was Maxwell there?
Kate: Yes
AUSA: Did Epstein initiate sexual contact with you?
Kate: Yes. Then Maxwell said, How did it go? Did you have fun?
Kate: Later Maxwell told me to find someone to give Epstein a blowj*b. She said he needed to have sex 3 times a day.
AUSA: When he first met Maxwell and Epstein what was your understanding of their relationship?
Kate: I thought they were boyfriend and girlfriend.
Kate: Maxwell told me she was friends with Prince Andrew, Donald Trump. The names would just come up in conversation.
AUSA: What gifts did you receive from Maxwell?
Kate: A small black Prada bag for my 18th birthday.
AUSA: After sex with Epstein?
Kate: Yes, after.
AUSA: Were you given clothes to wear at Epstein's Palm Beach house?
Kate: Yes, a school girl's outfit with a short skirt, white panties and white socks.
AUSA: Did they come a time you stopped communicating with Epstein?
Kate: Yes. In my late 20s.
AUSA: Were you compensated by the Epstein Victim's Fund?
Kate: Yes.
AUSA: Are you planning to sue Maxwell?
Kate: No.
Now Maxwell's lawyer Bobbi Sternheim cross examination of Witness Kate:
Sternheim: You had a beautiful mother, didn't you?
Kate: Yes.
Sternheim: And your step father was rich and you lived in the Belgravia section of London, didn't you?
Kate: Yes.
Sternheim: You were an international model?
Kate: I was a model.
Sternheim: You were dating an older, prominent gentleman who was an Oxford classmate of Ghislaine, correct?
Kate: Yes.
Sternheim: You were a model for a UK version of Victoria's Secret?
Kate: No. The company failed almost right way.
Sternheim: But you were a lingerie model?
Kate: Yes.
Sternheim: You were in a piano bar and were discovered by the musician Seal, right?
Kate: No.
Sternheim: But you said that. You acted in movies?
Kate: I did not have speaking roles.
Sternheim: You were in a movie with a very well known UK actor, correct?
Kate: Yes
Sternheim: You spoke publicly, in your own name, in this courthouse, right?
Kate: Yes.
Sternheim: You were invited by a judge in this courthouse, Judge Berman, to speak, and you spoke, right?
Kate: Yes.
Sternheim: And you've spoke with Virginia Robert Giuffre?
Kate: Yes.
Sternheim: You used drugs for 10 years, right?
Kate: Yes.
Sternheim: And you dated other men, right?
Kate: Yes, I dated men.
Sternheim: And you even married one of them?
Kate: Are you asking me if I've been married?
Sternheim: And you were with a prominent restauranteur?
Kate: I was with a man who owned 2 restaurants.
Sternheim: Didn't a tabloid encourage you to get a man connected to the royal family to buy cocaine?
Kate: Not exactly.
Sternheim: And that became a big tabloid spectacular, right?
Kate: I suppose.
Sternheim: When were you last in contact with Epstein?
Kate: 30s.
Sternheim: Give me a date.
Kate: I don't have a date.
Sternheim: How old are you?
Kate: 44.
Sternheim: Aren't you trying to get a victim's visa? Isn't this your name?
Kate: My visa application is base on extraordinary ability.
Sternheim: Which one?
Kate: Music teaching to treat trauma.
Sternheim: Any unlicensed music coach can get it?
Sternheim: Nothing further.
Judge Nathan: Re-direct?
AUSA: Let's take the lunch break.
Judge Nathan: OK.
Live tweeting will continue, watch this feed and patreon.com/MatthewRussell…
OK - here was the lunch break live-stream from Foley Square - now back in, with Judge Nathan holding a lawyers' argument session before the jury comes in. Thread will continue below
OK, the jury is finally back in, for re-direct of still pseudonymous witness Kate, staring with her award from the Epstein victims' fund.
Next US witness: Patrick McHugh of JP Morgan Chase: "I'm an officer of the firm. I can speak to who is authorize to access accounts and the like."
Assistant US Attorney names a slew of financial exhibits and calls them public exhibits. We'll see when we get access to them. Watch this feed.
Pending getting all these exhibits, the current one shows a wire transfer involving Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell for $7,400,000, JPM Chase and BONY Mellon.
Now JPM's McHugh is being asked about helicopter purchase. The exhibits as shown on the screens are blurry - will have to wait to get access to legible copies.
Maxwell's lawyer: This document doesn't show who approved it, right?
McHugh: Yes, the statement does not
Next witness is FBI's Ms. Kelly McGuire, Special Agent.
AUSA: What is this?
Agent McGuire: The front view of the resident [at 9 E. 71 Street]. When there was no response, we forced our way in.
AUSA: Did you come across the massage room on the third floor?
McGuire: We, we did. This photo, 902r, is the entrance to the massage room.
AUSA: And 903r?
McGuire: It's the massage room.
[The pictures on the wall are redacted, in the public exhibit]
McGuire is done. Judge Nathan asks if the US has a short witness (for the next 10 minutes).
Now starting: another FBI agent.
AUSA: Does each FBI investigation have its own number?
Agent: Yes.
AUSA: Did you review CDs in 2020?
Agent: Yes, with Amelia Young.
AUSA: We offer into evidence this photo of Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell.
Judge Nathan: We'll break for the day. Jurors, have a good night. Counsel? Anything we need to take up?
Maxwell's lawyer: We object to the photo of our client lying on a boat.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
OK - now in US v. #GhislaineMaxwell, her lawyer Pagliuca is cross-examining survivor Carolyn who testified Maxwell paid her $300 to have sex with Jeffrey Epstein. Inner City Press will live tweet, thread below, after midday podcast here anchor.fm/innercity-pres…
Pagliuca: Look at the notes the FBI took during your interview, about a lady with short black hair and an "unknown" accent. They didn't cut you off, correct?
Carolyn: That was a bad day for me. I was not expecting the FBI to come to my home.
Pagliuca: You knew what a British accent was, but you said "an unknown accent," right?
Carolyn: The day that you're talking about --
Pagliuca: I'd ask the Court to make her answer.
OK - it's US v. @GhislaineMaxwell Day 7, starting with lawyers' arguments about witnesses learning what's been said in court the previous day. The issue will have to be decided by Judge Nathan. Inner City Press will live tweet, thread below patreon.com/posts/59625123
Maxwell's lawyer Menninger: My request is to find out what was communication to him by Jane, before he gets on the stand in front of the jury. He was shown a document Jane was asked about.
Judge Nathan: Which one?
Menninger: The Interlochen [school] application
Assistant US Attorney: Jane told him, The defense lawyer is an expletive.
Menninger: But what else did she tell him?
Judge Nathan: He shouldn't testify until after lunch.
OK - US v. #GhislaineMaxwell Day 5, PM edition, with officer on search of Epstein's residence (found photos of young girls, school girl uniforms, etc). Screens will exclude public & press. Inner City Press will live tweet, thread below patreon.com/posts/59466473
They are showing the jurors a video of the search warrant reading (and execution?) at Epstein's house. But we the Press and public can't see it.
AUSA Maurene Comey: at 1 minute, were are we?
Parkinson: In the 3 car garage
Assistant US Attorney Maurene Comey: What do we see here, during the search?
Officer Parkinson: A picture of Pope John Paul with Jeffrey Epstein.
[Note: while these exhibits are sealed, for some reason, could it be this one, with #GhislaineMaxwell? #MaximumMaxwell
Maxwell's lawyer (before jury comes in) Seeing semen on the table is going to be prejudicial.
AUSA: It was a white stain. It is entirely probative as to whether these massages were just messages or were in fact sexual.
Judge Nathan: I would permit lab tests
Assistant US Attorney: The fact that Mr. Epstein had a collection of school girl uniforms is relevant.
Maxwell's lawyer: This has little connection Ms. Maxwell and is prejudicial.
AUSA: School girl costumes, small ones, were found in the massage room.
AUSA: Look at Government Exhibit 721. Do you recognize it?
Kane: An enrollment application for a student.
AUSA: Don't say the name. Is it an accurate copy?
Kane: Yes.
Maxwell's lawyer: Objection - hearsay!
AUSA: It's a business record.
Judge Nathan: Overruled.
Maxwell's lawyer: Can I question the witness?
Judge Nathan: Go ahead.
Maxwell's lawyer: The Professional Children's School doesn't verify the accuracy of the info on the form, does it?
Kane: I think they do.
Maxwell's lawyer: All of it?
Kane: That, I don't know.
OK - In US v. #GhislaineMaxwell, now final segment before end of Day 3, it's Victim Jane's ex-boyfriend "Matt," uses pseudonym. Inner City Press covered AM innercitypress.com/sdnytrial31max… & will live tweet, thread below
AUSA Moe: How do you know Jane?
Matt: She's my ex-girlfriend. From 2006 to 2014.
AUSA: Did you live together?
Matt: Yes. From 2007 to 2014.
AUSA: Are you still friends?
Matt: Yes. And we work on the same TV show.
AUSA: What did Jane tell you about her home life?
Maxwell's lawyer: Objection.
Judge Nathan: Any foundation?
Maxwell's lawyer: It's hearsay.
[Another non-public sidebar]