Josh Duggar has been found guilty on two counts of downloading and possessing CSAM. So much grief for the survivors, and for everyone caught in the cross hairs. Perhaps most disturbing however is how the patterns noted in this earlier post, played out...
Despite clear evidence, there was no grief at what was, but rather a continual effort to thwart justice and deny. From a family member who changed his testimony on the stand, to a father who "couldn't remember" the abuse of his own four daughters, to a wife who held his hand...
The focus continued to be the living out of the same twisted theology that led us here.
The situation for everyone is devastating, but acting as though this isn't serious only furthers the devastation.
What Anna needs is someone to validate how evil this is, and grieve with her
Repentance can only come when the depth of guilt is felt. Healing can only come when the full truth of the wound is acknowledged. Safety can only arise when the danger is admitted and fled.
I ache tonight. Not only that the evil was done, though that is heavy enough,
But that it is still unacknowledged, ungrieved, and by that then, minimized and excused.
This is a good time to reflect also on the long term realities that survivors face, and where that responsibility lies.
The survivors of Josh's earlier abuse have now, yet again, had to see their stories brought out. These charges resurrected the old stories,
And the survivors once again, had no choice.
And while most survivors won't necessarily have their stories as headlines, it's very true that at any point their stories can be resurrected too, with no real choice given to them.
The guilt for the immediate consequences of abuse lies with the abuser. But so does every moment of consequence that follows.
We need to grapple with that reality, and mindsets that blame shift or feed enabling.
Justice has been done insofar as it can be, and it is good that we rejoice in that.
But remember that tomorrow everyone wakes up still living the consequences. Don't lose that reality in the midst of sober rejoicing in the truth.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Ok first, what I said was "that the kids can decorate with their own ornaments" NOT "all by themselves". We have 4 kids, it can't be a TINY tree. I never envisioned a tree the kids could put the star on themselves and that's not what I said!
I am deeply thankful for the guilty verdict in the slaying of Ahmaud Arbery, but in this gratefulness, it's so critical to remember a few things:
1. Remember how close we came to no trial at all due to corrupt systems and authority figures. Justice was terrifyingly slow and it took far too much suffering and effort from Ahmaud's family, press, and other law enforcement, to get this. That is a terrifying reality.
2. Getting some measure of justice is often the exception, not the rule. This result was good. This does NOT mean the systems are changing/will continue to change, without constant effort and vigilance. Don't stop paying attention - let this spur you to pay MORE attention.
4 yrs ago today I was sitting in court hearing Larry plead guilty to possession of CSAM. The prosecutor read "how much is a little girl worth?" from my letter to the judge, asking for the maximum penalty. Judge Neff gave it. It was the best possible result, and yet...
The little girls in that material still live with it. None were in the courtroom that day to know that anyone even fought for them. I was allowed to write a letter speaking to the sentence because of my role in the assault cases, but I think about them nearly every day.
It was an incredible privilege to speak in any way on their behalf, but even in the best of results, the damage and grief is still there.
The last two weeks have been extra raw for me and I couldn't figure out why until FB reminded me of the date. The body keeps the score.
I am disappointed and grieved to say that this is not what survivors and advocates actually called for and not what LU needs. I hope that this is the result of a lack of understanding on the part of LU and that it will be rectified quickly.
While a Title IX review is not a bad step, most of the allegations and concerns do not relate to technical Title IX policy violations (some do, but not most).
The actual concerns and allegations primarily center around allegations of:
1. A culture that silences survivors and minimizes abuse.
2. Poor responses by faculty and leadership.
3. Resistance to reform by leadership.
4. Lack of good communication on abuse related issues.
5.Lack of awareness and priorization of these issues by leadership.
This article inadvertently plays a part in one of the major reasons, when it notes that sexual contact between Dr and patient is an ethical violation. As if what is described here is consensual contact that just breaches some ethics rules.
Yes, the ethics rules are important and yes there is always a power dynamic, that's why the rule is there.
But when predatory abusive and criminal behavior is flagged as wrong because of an ethics violation, it severely mischaracterizes the abuse and downplays needed response.
Dear EC member who answered the asked question "how much is a little girl worth?" By saying "worth having insurance proceeds to pay her", please hear my heart -
If you are going to speak those words, first ask those little girls and boys what they care about the most:
Ask them if they value money, or the truth, more.
Ask them which one they would rather have.
They will tell you they want the truth. They will tell you the incredible cost they have already paid fighting for it.
Ask the little girls and boys which they would rather accomplish: getting insurance money, or getting to the root problems and fixing them so another child doesn't live through their hell.
They will pick saving a child every single time. They've dedicated their lives to it.