A fundamental question that is overlooked as traders jump into indicators, tools, chart types, patterns, moon cycles or whatever: why should the market reward your trade? Why here? Why long or short? For what target and at what stop? Cont... #trading
What inefficiency are we exploiting? Why is this price unfair? Is our evidence based in fact? Statistics? Or.... #trading
Is it because our moving average crossed & that's all there is? Or maybe some dot showed up on our chart?
Think about it: Everyone is seeing the same price, time and volume. These are the elements.
Knowing that, what is it we are doing that deserves to be rewarded? #trading
As a trader for me, if someone has a trade on and can't impulsively answer the basis for that trade, then they don't deserve my risk capital. Period.
It needn't be complex. In my own trading, cld be as simple as:
1) Range statistic is extended beyond norm (1 Sigma) 2) Price is not moving down as easily as it has been 3) A key area has been tested 4) Rotations are expanding the other way 5) There is sufficient upside vs risk
The truth becomes real as soon as the trade is on. Without a firm idea & logic that we believe, it is hard to let the trade work/run.
Break it down: Why should I get paid on this trade? If I don't know then I'm losing. #trading
RT if useful
Another angle: Would you invest in a bank that loans money to borrowers who dreamed up an idea without proper study, no merit, no reasonable expectations, no multiples of reward per unit of risk & a person who cannot execute with discipline?
Based on comments made on #TraderBite this morning about the trend up yesterday and how it contained a TON of delta divergence sell signals and seemed to rise on negative delta. Many have emails, DMed, etc. Saying they were the "imbecile" selling all the way up....
So I get why this happens and how enticing it is to try to call a top and catch that turn for a super-dose of dopamine and euphoria. BUT this is not trading. Not by a mile. It isn't stupidity, it is just not recognizing where we are on the map and staying objective....
One can be a very consistently profitable and even very rich trader, but also a very miserable person. That isn't success. Success to me is about growth, expansion, comebacks, inner-awareness, thoughtless execution, being in the flow & loving every second of it
I would be a bullshitter if I said that this is my constant experience. It isn't. The market really tests everyone. Really creates moments of doubt. Has it changed or is this just an unfavorable market regime causing a drawdown? Am I off balance? Am I honest with myself?
On trading: I started trading @ professional equities arcade w/ guys who cld make/lose a doctor's annual salary in a day. I moved to futures prop & was profitable in less than a yr before I left & started my own shop. I've put 29 traders thru my group. Saw the same issues (cont)
again & again. We r all very similar. I've been doing this for 19 yrs now. The thing that amazes me is how often ppl come in & do same thing every day, again & again even though results r poor. Very little emotional/self-awareness. (cont...)
This isn't these traders' fault. It is an issue w/how we r trained to think. We don't stop to ask "what am I doing? How is it working? Why am I continuing to doing this? Can I be doing something better or differently?" My traders had to be taught to be self-aware (cont...)
On my semi-annual long-stay visit with parents in Canada. Mom has to make a 4-course feast on every meal. I'm generally fasting and on OMAD (one meal a day) for the health benefits & energy management.
Mom: You aren't eating
Me: I had a big piece of salmon and tons of veggies 1/
Mom: You are losing weight. Are you diabetic? Oh my god, you have diabetes and aren't saying!
Me: No, I eat once a day and I don't like heavy food. I'm not diabetic.
Mom: Is there something missing in the food? (starts reaching for the salt shaker)
Me: Food is always great!
2/
Mom: Do u want me to make something else for u? (there are 4 meals on the table plus salads)
Me: No, this is great. God bless you, mom. I just don't eat much and I don't need that much to eat.
Mom: OK. I don't know why you stopped liking my food. Also, see a doctor soon
3/