Apparently @drlucymcbride and colleagues are hosting a zoom event tonight to discuss their awful and unscientific #UrgencyOfNormal advocacy paper. I've been asked if i can go there to challenge them.
/1
I understand. But playing on their home turf and how liberally they use misinformation would only be an exercise in frustration in which they would gishgallop their way through their bungled appropriation of mental health and i'd be left to write more 29 tweet threads.
/2
Were I to have a "guest spot" on their zoom event, I would read the 29-tweet thread in its entirety, & then log off. I don't care what they think about it, I don't care about them personally, and I am not interested in people who ghoulishly wield child suicides without care.
/3
The media needs to learn how to critically look at data (heck, many do, even @HHSGov made some of their mistakes) before making policy decisions.
Me fighting with ideologues pretending to be experts in child MH is not going to help that, and only helps their "notoriety."
/4
Media email dr.tylerblack at gmail if you want to discuss this further.
If anyone is attending the zoom event; do not be surprised if they simply either ignore the evidence i've presented or do exactly what tweet 2 said they would. But if someone can, read my thread to them :)
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Moral panics exist because of anecdotes, disproportionately hyped harms and exaggerated claims of fear-supporting research (while fear-rejecting research ignored) fueled by media fearmongering and political exploitation.
This is why people beleive suicides increased in 2020.
It's hard hard hard work to overcome moral panics. I cite my work, provide error estimates, and discuss any aspect requested of me. I am constantly being riddled with questions that I've been asked a million times by people who "know suicides increased."
I've heard "but what about ODs/deaths of dispair" and have responded hundreds of times (they are usually accidents/don't use that term if you're not a PhD winning economist).
***********
Canadian Suicidology Update
***********
We have official @StatCan_eng suicide data for 2020, ready to analyse by year. This lets us look at the trends and to see whether or not the "pandemic year" was associated with any significant changes, by gender and age.
/1
The headline is the MASSIVE drop in suicide rates during the first year of the pandemic. While not as massive as suggested in McIntyre et al*, it's still huge and significant:
DOWN 17.6% in males and 12.5% in females. 16.4% overall.
/2
I can break down our age groups as well, to look at specific groupings.
CANADIANS 65+
For older Canadians, both decreases (men down 14%, women down 6%) are no longer statistically significant (super close for the 65+ men).
The OPPOSITE of what is actually occurring (NON-EXPERTS scaremongering using inaccurate data on suicides, and selective citation science that is shoddy & poorly reported) to justify OPENING schools.
Nobody is taking position that "SCHOOLS MUST BE CLOSED"
/1
In my advocacy, I don't just discuss suicides, I discussed the state of the evidence globally including incident rates of eating disorders, depresison, anxiety, and suicide.
/2
In all of that, my position is clear: schools should be last to close and first to open. School is good. But closures, whenever necessary, are likely less harmful to kid's mental health than anything the pandemic is doing to our kids (orphanhood, worries about illness).
/3
/2 I'm skipping the first line (for now), but the second part, about "deaths from child suicide vastly outnumbering deaths from COVID and are increasing" is about as awful as it gets. I consider it ghoulish to wield child suicide statistics inaccurately to make advocacy points.
/3 In order, I'm going to go through your awful slide on mental health as you selectively cited "scary findings." Of course, as the suicidologist, I'm going to start with your clearly expert-free statement on child suicides in the US, as this is my expertise.
Vaccines remain effective against every outcome, including receiving the diagnosis of COVID. Based off of the past month in BC.
For overwhelming our hospital system (Each case requires special procedures and staffing, draining our resource), massive protection.
/1
We will see the case protection numbers increase again, as unvaccinated people continue to get infected at a high rate with this Omicron spread, whereas vaccinated people peaked and are now well below the unvax rate once again.
/2
There are 710,138 unvaccinated eligible British Columbians. A portion of these people can not be vaccinated due to medical issues, but the majority can be. Please do your part and #getvaccinated.
So proud of this. My research guru & mentor & boss @QdQwerty and I are proud to present MyHEARTSMAP - A psychosocial tool for the screening and assessment of youth.
It can be filled out by kids 10+ or parents of any age.
This represents countless hours with a dedicated team of @QdQwerty's lab and colleagues, and coworkers. I'm so proud of the final product and, we've demonstrated that a tool like this can be completed by kids or parents with good reliability to interview & assessment.
/2
On a personal note, working with @QdQwerty is a dream; one of the smartest, kindest, ethical, and principled people I've ever worked with. Honoured to be part of her team.
/3