The Pension War Room™️is pleased to report that the ATRF Annual Report just dropped! Get your copy here! There is so much provocative reading inside that I will analyze right here for your pleasure. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension atrf.com/annual-reports/
Due to excellent investment returns coupled with strong risk control, contribution rates will go down next year (starting Sept 2022).
They will go down by aprox 2%: 1% of pay for teachers, and 1% of pay for GOA. More money in your pocket. #AbLeg
This one move of reducing contribution rates has done more to save Travis money than being forced to use @aimcoinvests ever will. Sigh.
Investment Performance: remember this past year was combo of the original ATRF portfolio and the @aimcoinvests portfolio.
1 year return: 15.6%
1 year benchmark: 13.8%
Value add: +1.8%
Excellent. Fantastic. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
Longer term ATRF Return
4 year return: 9.6%
4 year benchmark: 8.9%
4 year value add: 0.7%
10 year return: 10.0%
10 year benchmark: 9.2%
value add: 0.8%
Those positive value add numbers will make all the difference for financial security far into the future. #AbLeg
This is not a perfect comparison, but I know I am going to be flooded with this question, so here it goes:
The most recent @aimcoinvests annual report(2020):
4 year AIMCO Balanced return: 6.7%
4 year AIMCO Balanced Benchmark: 7.9%
4 year AIMCO Value Add: -1.2% #AbLeg#handsoff
The negative sign in front of that value add for @aimcoinvests will have far reaching negative consequences for for all public sector pension plans EXCEPT teachers (teachers were not using AIMCO for the period in question.) #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
If you read the Compensation Disclosure you would note that, unlike @aimcoinvests, ATRF is not paying retention bonuses to employees that have been severed. Kevin is gone but he is still burning AB taxpayers. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
If you read the section on discount rate has been decreased to 6.25% from 6.35%. This is the ATRF Board taking risk off the table. This is a prudent move given the changing demographics of the teacher workforce in AB. I will be interested to see what the COVID effects are. #AbLeg
I will bring you more observations later in the day. I have some calls out for some professional opinions. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️brings you more ATRF Annual Report comment and analysis!!!
Travis gets a 1% cut in contribution rates (so do teachers): which will save him many, many times the amount he will save by forcing @aimcoinvests on us.
It is interesting to note that the ATRF Board is making this momentous decision; the very same ATRF Board that could not be consulted over over which investment manager to use. Go figure.
May I remind you the ATRF Board is joint, representing both sponsors, ATA & GOA. #AbLeg
If you are a regular reader, you will note that this is the first Annual Report that has not contained a schedule of investments. That is all @aimcoinvests. It is industry standard to include a listing of investments and major partners. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
She used to be the Executive Director of the Washington State Investment Board, and I think I met her at a Pacific Pension Institute session. In any event, it is again good to see that @aimcoinvests is moving beyond out-of-work oil and gas executives again. #AbLeg#handsoff
WSIB is (roughly) the AIMCO of Wahington State. Rest assured loyal followers, your pension plan fiduciary and trustee was in no way consulted on this appointment. Travis made (and can rescind) this appointment at any time. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
This is your daily pension announcement: Heritage Fund meeting today, video is available. Some good information along with some misinformation. The value add target for the Heritage is 1.00% over five years. Actual value add 0.3%. #readitandweep#AbLeg
In answer to the question Evan and Dale (CIO) let it slip that 0.7% value add would be top quartile.
You know, like ATRF had before you wrecked it. You took a manager with a value add of 0.7% and replaced it with one with 0.3%. Duh. #AbLeg
This decision will cost AB billions.
I get angry when @aimcoinvests refers to the pension funds as "clients". Hostages comes to mind as more accurate. Does anyone out in the Twitterverse have better word for enforced participation? #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
Well, do need to swing away from pensions for a thread on teacher discipline. The non-progressive conservatives seem to be substituting their opinions for fact. This may be TL:dr; regardless, facts do need to live. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
In the mid-90's Minister of Education Gary Mar appointed me to the Council on Alberta Teaching Standards (COATS). It had representatives from all the major stakeholders, staff from AB Ed and a lawyer from justice. #AbLeg#handsoff
You remember Gary Mar? Heir-apparent in training for Ralph. Anyway, COATS was charged with developing a regulation that would address teacher discipline for NON-MEMBERS of the ATA. Ab Ed and the minster felt there was a strong and robust process in place at the ATA. #AbLeg
This is your daily pension announcement. The Pension War Room™️notes that @aimcoinvests still makes the news! This is the intrepid @LeannaO who broke the story about the VOLTS losses. While the article as a whole may not be much interest to you....#AbLeg#handsoffmypension
It is a good indicator of what is going on.
I would differ in the numbers a bit. I have it at 40 layoffs, another 40 substantially altered job descriptions and at least one external manager fired.
This is not likely the end either. When a new Chief Investment Officer is hired there will be more changes.
The Twitter version of public accountability is necessary here because teachers and other plan members are in no way represented on @aimcoinvests Board. #AbLeg
This is your daily pension announcement! The Pension War Room™️ wants you to read this, the most cogent response from Travis about the pension brouhaha. Then I will explain how it is still bullshit!🐂🐂💩💩 Please read this carefully. Critical thinking! #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
Did you get the last sentence? The one about an analysis conducted "based on publicly available information". Wrong. Travis is the Minister of Finance. He is one of the sponsors. He is entitled to all the data NOT just the public data. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
He goes into a complex financial decision that will ultimately cost teachers and taxpayers $1.8 billion without proprietary data that is readily available to him? Really? Give your head a shake.
Travis, apparently could not be bothered to even access the data. #AbLeg#handsoff